Why It Works
- Bone-in beef short ribs come closest to the size of Texas-style ribs.
- A low and slow cook ensures moist, flavorful meat.
- Wrapping the meat in a layer of butcher paper for the later cooking stage helps with bark formation.
When I got the request to tackle giant Texas-style beef ribs as a grilling post, I was a bit dubious as to whether it could even be done. Unless there's some secret every Texas pitmaster is guarding with their life, the path to transcendent beef barbecue is all about knowing your meat and your cooker, plus the months, years, and generations it takes to perfect the art. Still, I'm not one to back down from a challenge, and after a couple racks of short ribs done in my humble smoker, I realized there's enough to say to set you on the right track to great ribs. That said, making them the best they can be will still come down to your dedication to cooking them over and over again.
Big 'n' Beefy
Everything might be bigger in Texas, but it sure is smaller in New York. Starting out with that fundamental requirement of giant bones top-loaded with beef wasn't so easy in my home locale of Astoria, Queens.
When I went looking, I came across two common varieties of beef ribs—back ribs and short ribs. Back ribs are what you get when a rib roast is divorced from its bones. That rib roast meat fetches top dollar, so it makes sense that most of the meat stays with the roast or steaks, and very little is left on the ribs, but they do have some great stuff between the bones. Back ribs make fine barbecue, but they weren't the giant hunks of meat I was after.
That leaves the short ribs, which are cut from the lower portion of the rib cage and often have a nice layer of fat-laced meat sitting on top. The challenge here was finding ones that would live up to the Texas name. More often than not, the short ribs I came across were cut into small, individual bone portions with wildly varying amounts of meat on them. Fortunately, my local butcher had a few nice racks that had four bones each—around 10 inches square—with approximately 1 1/4 inches of meat sitting on top. They may not have been quite as large as some ribs I've gotten in Texas, but were close enough to do the job well.
After I had ribs in hand, the prep was pretty minimal. As I do with my pork ribs, I started by peeling the membrane off the backside of the ribs. This was probably more out of reflex than necessity, but that membrane becomes plasticky and leathery during cooking, and if you're going to gnaw on all sides of the bone, it doesn't make for great eats.
From there, I trimmed down any excessively large areas of hard fat. Fat on the ribs is your friend—and delicious—but big, thick blocks of it will be overly chewy in the end, so I shot for a layer of fat on top that was about 1/8 inch thick.
Finally came the seasoning. When it comes to Texas barbecue, a beef rub needs no further than salt and pepper. I did a fifty-fifty mix of kosher salt and coarsely ground black pepper, with a little garlic powder thrown in for my own taste. I liberally covered each of the racks with the rub and they were ready to get smoking.
Low and Slow
The concept of cooking barbecue is to take tougher pieces of meat and make them tender and delicious. Cuts like pork shoulder, brisket, and short ribs all have a lot of intramuscular fat and connective tissues that need time to break down and render, which is why these cuts are all preferably cooked low and slow.
Since short ribs aren't quite as giant of a chunk of meat as brisket—which can take upwards of 12-18 hours to slow cook—the time commitment isn't as demanding. I started my two racks cooking at 225°F (107°C), using a mix of charcoal and oak wood chunks, and let them go until I was able to insert an instant-read thermometer into the meat with no resistance, which clocked in at six hours. Starting out, I wasn't sure what the right temperature was for tender short ribs, but both racks got there at around the 165°F (74°C) mark.
The Butcher Wrap
If you're taking a barbecue trip around Texas, you'll likely encounter butcher paper-wrapped barbecue. While foil-wrapping meat during the cooking process is super prevalent in competition-style barbecue—it's also used by some great Texas pitmasters—swapping foil for butcher paper serves a slightly different purpose.
Foil is not porous, so when you wrap meat in it, moisture is trapped inside and humidity jumps to nearly 100%. This counters typical surface evaporation on the meat, drastically speeding up the cooking process. Butcher paper, on the other hand, allows moisture to escape, so it's not very effective in speeding things up. That said, it does retain some moisture and, most importantly, butcher paper helps with the development of the bark—the dark outside layer that forms on slow-cooked meats.
Since butcher paper "breathes," just enough steam is retained to soften the bark, but not enough to make it lose its thick, slightly crunchy character altogether. Plus, butcher paper becomes saturated in the rendered fat of the meat, and a little extra fat sitting on the surface of the beef only seems to make things better.
Just to test things out, I wrapped one rack of ribs in butcher paper in the last hour of cooking, and left the other unwrapped. With the short cooking process and holding times—I let the ribs rest about one hour in a Cambro before digging in—the butcher paper didn't make a huge difference, but the bark of the wrapped ribs was slightly superior. I assume if cooking and holding times were longer, the moisture retained by the butcher paper would make more of a difference.
Don't Mess With Texas (Beef Ribs)
Salt, pepper, smoke, and meat are all I started with; what we ate were some ribs that were incredibly moist, tender, peppery, and insanely beefy that I think would make a Texan proud (they passed muster with my Texan wife, but she's from Houston, so take that for what it's worth). Did they match the quality of the best beef ribs I've ever had at Louie Mueller's? No. But they were inching up towards some of the really excellent bones I've enjoyed at Black's, in Lockhart.
The only way I'm going to improve these is by cooking giant beef short ribs over and over again, until I can spot the perfect cut of meat, hit the right temperatures in my smoker, discover the ideal time to wrap, and the best amount of time to hold. None of these can fully be translated into a recipe, since they'll vary from cook to cook. At the end of the day, it’s the intuition resulting from repetition that's this recipe's "secret" ingredient, but I'm sure this post will, at the very least, give you a good start toward making some truly excellent beef ribs.
- 1/4 cup coarsely ground black pepper
- 1/4 cup Kosher salt
- 1 tablespoon garlic powder (optional)
- 2 racks beef short ribs, 4-bones each, 10- to 12-inches square, membrane removed and hard fat cap trimmed to 1/8 inch
- 3 to 4 chunks of a medium smoking wood, such as oak or hickory
- 2 large pieces of butcher paper
In a small bowl, combine pepper, salt, and garlic powder (if using) to make the rub. Season ribs all over liberally with the rub.
Fire up smoker or grill to 225°F (107°C) adding chunks of smoking wood chunks when at temperature. When the wood is ignited and producing smoke, place the ribs in the smoker or grill, meat side up, and smoke until an instant-read thermometer registers 165°F (74°C) when inserted into the thickest part of the ribs.
Wrap each rack of ribs tightly in butcher paper and return to smoker. Continue cooking until an instant-read thermometer registers 185°F (85°C) when inserted into the thickest part of the ribs. There should be no resistance when inserting the thermometer into the meat.
Transfer ribs to an empty cooler and let rest for a minimum of 30 minutes, up to 3 hours. Slice ribs into individual bones and serve.
Type of fire: Indirect
Grill heat: Low