Pizza dough: Moving from a food processor to stand mixer

Hi, I recently blew the motor on my food processor, via which I used to make wonderful pizza dough (using the CI recipe, essentially, but times 1.5, which is probably what killed the motor!).

Anyway, we're broke so I can't buy a new food processor just yet. As a former baker/pastry chef, I've got a workhorse of a stand mixer that I'm making our pizza dough with now. However, after making pizza last night the dough turned out tasty with a good structure, but it was a serious pain in the rear to form. (By which I mean that the gluten was so developed that it didn't want to stretch out to my usual 14" (for a 14 oz. ball, measured after bulk rise).)

So, I wonder if one can just take the CI recipe and simply just use a stand mixer, or if there is some extra tweaking that needs to take place.

(Full disclosure: I likely overmixed this batch as I neglected to add the oil and salt after the 10-minute autolyse and had to mix all that in for another 1-2 minutes on the dough hook.)

Is there anyone out there that doesn't use a food processor to make either Kenji's or the CI recipe? That is, they either mix/knead by hand or use a stand mixer? I'm not finding that the flavor is all that different (i.e., I don't buy the argument that fast food processor mixing reduces oxidation on the surface of the dough.)

Any thoughts welcome, sorry so long and rambling! best, Joe


The tastiest bites delivered to your inbox!

Show 12 Comments

Talk is closed - check out our Facebook and Twitter accounts instead.