Cake-Like Cookies Need Some Tinkering & Frosting Recipe Needed

Hello! I have a recipe that I really like for cutout cookies, with one minor issue: although they work really well for cutting out shapes and they do taste yummy, I find them to be a little too cakey for my preferences. I prefer chewy cookies in general, or cutout cookies that are more dense and crumbly. Can someone help me adjust this recipe to achieve the right result? I was thinking maybe reduce the eggs, or melting some of the butter first. Here's the original recipe:

2 cups sugar 1 cup butter 3 eggs 3 tsp. baking powder 1.5 tsp vanilla extract

Cream the above ingredients until fluffy. Stir in:

1 cup milk 1 Tbls. vinegar 1 tsp. baking soda

Add enough flour to form a soft dough. Roll it out, cut out shapes and bake at 400 degrees F.

I would really appreciate any suggestions! Also, does anyone have a good basic frosting recipe for cutout cookies? Thanks in advance.


The tastiest bites delivered to your inbox!

Show 11 Comments

Talk is closed - check out our Facebook and Twitter accounts instead.