Looking for help with homemade yogurt

Okay, for my very first time ever, I made homemade yogurt.

I used:

1 quart whole Ronnybrook milk 1/2 cup full fat Ronnybrook plain yogurt 1/3 cup nonfat dry milk (the yogurt maker called for 1/4 to 1/2)

I heated the milk and dry milk to just below boiling, cooled it to 110, mixed in the plain yogurt, put in the preheated yogurt maker and left it there for 6 hours. Stirred it a little then stuck it in the fridge for 12 hours or so. Then hit it with a whisk.

So here's the thing - it's a little grainy. Not terribly, but it is noticeable.

So my question is - Is that how homemade yogurt is supposed to be? It's never been that way with the commercially prepared yogurt I buy (I generally go organic and plain - Stonyfield Farms or Ronnybrook (my absolute favorite). Have I under whisked? I did it for a while, but maybe not enough? Did I use too much nonfat dry milk? Or is that the nature of the beast? It's not bad, but I do prefer totally, totally smooth. If any of you make your own, can you please tell me what the deal is? It would be most appreciated.


The tastiest bites delivered to your inbox!

Show 15 Comments

Talk is closed - check out our Facebook and Twitter accounts instead.