Adapted from Kenji's grilled skirt steak fajitas recipe—with its rich and flavorful lime, soy sauce, and cumin-spiced marinade—this version reworks the recipe using chicken thighs instead of steak and alters the technique so that all you need is an oven and a single sheet pan. Because it's all cooked on a large half-sheet pan, it's perfect for feeding a larger group, plus the prep and cleanup are kept to a minimum.
While you could use boneless, skinless chicken breasts in this recipe (we've tested it; it works), our preferred option here is chicken thighs. The dark meat is less prone to drying out with high heat, which gives you more time to properly brown the chicken under the broiler, without having to worry too much about overcooking.
The recipe also gives the option of using a preheated baking steel or stone to brown the chicken from the bottom at the same time (a sheet pan, even when preheated, is too thin to brown the chicken on its own, and therefore needs the help from the mass of a baking steel or stone). It's fine if you don't have one, though, you can just flip the chicken to broil the second side until browned instead. (Don't be alarmed if your sheet pan buckles when on the hot steel or stone; in our experience, a good aluminum rimmed baking sheet always returns to its normal form on its own.)
As with all sheet-pan recipes, it's important to know your oven well and to adjust accordingly. Some broilers are underpowered, in which case you may be better off using only a preheated baking steel or baking stone with the oven at its highest heat setting. Others may be unusually strong, in which case you may need to lower the oven rack just a bit (if you use a baking stone with an oven rack at its highest position, it's possible you won't have the clearance to insert your sheet pan below the broiler element; in that case, lower the oven rack as needed).
Why It Works
- A baking steel or stone is included as an option for those who want to maximize browning.
- Chicken thighs are tolerant of high heat and won't dry out during cooking the way chicken breast can.
Read more: How to Build a Sheet-Pan Dinner
- Yield:Serves 4 to 8
- Active time: 45 minutes
- Total time:4 hours
- For the Fajita Marinade:
- 1/2 cup (120ml) soy sauce
- 1/2 cup (120ml) fresh lime juice, from 6 to 8 limes
- 1/2 cup (120ml) canola or other neutral oil
- 1/4 cup (55g) packed light brown sugar
- 2 teaspoons ground cumin seed
- 2 teaspoons freshly ground black pepper
- 1 tablespoon chili powder (see note)
- 3 medium cloves garlic, finely minced (about 1 tablespoon)
- 2 pounds (900g) boneless, skinless chicken thighs
- For the Fajitas:
- 1 large red bell pepper, stemmed, seeded, and cut into 1/2-inch-wide strips
- 1 large yellow bell pepper, stemmed, seeded, and cut into 1/2-inch-wide strips
- 1 large green bell pepper, stemmed, seeded, and cut into 1/2-inch-wide strips
- 1 white or yellow onion, cut into 1/2-inch slices
- 12 to 16 fresh flour or corn tortillas, hot (see note)
- 1 recipe guacamole, for serving, if desired
- 1 recipe pico de gallo, for serving, if desired
- Sour cream, shredded cheese, and salsa, for serving, if desired
For the Fajita Marinade: Combine soy sauce, lime juice, oil, brown sugar, cumin, black pepper, chili powder, and garlic in medium bowl and whisk to combine. Transfer 1/2 cup (120ml) marinade to a separate vessel and set aside.
For the Chicken: Place chicken in a gallon-sized zipper-lock bag and add remaining marinade. Seal bag, squeezing out as much air as possible. Massage bag until meat is fully coated in marinade. Lay flat in refrigerator, turning every couple of hours, for at least 3 and up to 10 hours.
For the Fajitas: When ready to cook, preheat broiler and position over rack to highest position. If you have a baking steel or stone, set it on the top rack and allow to preheat. If using a baking steel/stone, set a rimmed baking sheet on it to preheat as well; otherwise leave baking sheet at room temperature.
Remove chicken from marinade and blot dry with paper towels. Arrange chicken in an even layer on rimmed baking sheet. Broil, without flipping, until chicken is well browned on top side, about 5 minutes. Broiler strength and oven designs vary greatly, so cooking times will vary as well; keep a close watch. If your broiler heats unevenly, you may need to move the sheet tray around for more even browning. Flip chicken and broil until second side is also browned, about 4 minutes longer (chicken cooked with the help of a baking steel/stone will already have browned on the bottom, so you can flip it and continue cooking to ensure it's fully cooked through). Remove from oven and transfer chicken to a platter to rest.
Switch oven from broil mode to 450°F (230°C). Add red, yellow, and green bell peppers as well as onions to baking sheet. Pour reserved 1/2 cup of marinade all over and toss until evenly coated; using a wooden spoon, scrape up any browned bits on the baking sheet. Arrange peppers and onion in an even layer that covers the baking sheet from edge to edge, then cook, stirring occasionally, until vegetables are tender and browned in spots, about 25 minutes (if your oven heats from the top, you will want to cook the vegetables on a middle rack to avoid excessive scorching and burning). If you're using a baking steel/stone, you can cook the vegetables on it, but keep a closer eye since they run the risk of scorching on the bottom; if this begins to happen, move the sheet pan to another rack.
Slice chicken into thin strips, then add back to sheet pan with any juices. Return to oven to warm through.
Serve immediately with hot tortillas, guacamole, pico de gallo, and other condiments, as desired.