I’m a little nervous about putting this recipe before this crowd, which probably includes more people with dearly-held opinions about barbecue and tacos than I could find anywhere else. Me, I like pulled pork, but I’m from Texas, so that’s not the brand of barbecue I was raised on; and again, I’m from Texas, so I’ll accept a crispy shell full of ground beef and orange cheese as a “taco” just as happily as I’ll eat carnitas wrapped in a fresh tortilla. In short, people with standards more exacting than mine might argue that this is not real pulled pork and these are not real pork tacos. But recently I fed them to a discerning friend who went back for seconds and thirds, and their excellence has made it hard for us to enjoy pork tacos at our former favorite places, so…I’m going to risk putting this out there.
I have been in thrall to The Lee Bros. Southern Cookbook since I got my copy. It has much to recommend it—wonderful writing, near-perfect recipes—but the most brilliant thing lurking in its brilliant pages is definitely the recipe for Oven BBQed Pork Picnic Shoulder. You cook a big, inexpensive piece of pork for a long time with some simple flavoring, and the result is meat far more tender and delicious than you thought you could produce in your little kitchen. You can carve it into slices to serve, but I like it best pulled and eaten on a bun with coleslaw or in a warmed tortilla (it’s also good for making enchiladas, but that’s a whole other post). The pork shoulder is so much better the second day that you shouldn’t even consider eating it the day you make it; cook it up and pull it on Saturday, and then when your friends come over for the game on Sunday all you’ll have to do is chop cilantro, slice onions, warm tortillas, and reheat the pork. I can’t stand football, but I’d get cozy and enjoy any old thing on television if someone was feeding me these.
Read more: Serious Eats Super Bowl Party Food Round Up
- One 28-ounce can whole tomatoes, lightly crushed, with their juices
- 2 teaspoons Spanish smoked paprika (pimentón) or 2 chipotles in adobo, plus more to taste [I use 3 or 4 chipotles]
- 2 tablespoons sorghum molasses, cane syrup, or honey, plus more to taste [I use honey]
- 1/2 cup white wine vinegar, champagne vinegar, or cider vinegar, plus more to taste
- One 6-8 pound pork picnic shoulder (or Boston butt, if you prefer)
- 2 teaspoons kosher salt, plus more to taste
- 1 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper, plus more to taste
- 1 1/2 tablespoons canola oil
- 4 large plum tomatoes, cored
- 1 medium yellow onion, trimmed, peeled, and quartered
- 1 small bunch cilantro
- 1 red onion
- 24-36 flour tortillas
Preheat the oven to 400°F.
In a large enameled cast-iron stockpot or Dutch oven, bring the canned tomatoes, paprika, sorghum molasses, and 6 tablespoons vinegar to simmer over medium heat. (The authors recommend a 6-quart pot, but in my experience that is not large enough to hold these ingredients plus, later, the pork. I use a 9 1/2-quart Dutch oven, which is a little roomy but works fine. I suspect 7 1/2 quarts would be perfect.)
Set the pork skin side up on your work surface. Use a sharp knife to slice the skin from the shoulder with a gentle sawing motion, working back from the point diagonally across from the leg end where the skin forms a corner (you can ask your butcher to do this to save yourself time). Leave a thin layer of fat on the shoulder. Season the pork with the salt and black pepper.
Pour the oil into a 12-inch skillet or sauté pan and heat over a high flame. When the oil shimmers and just begins to smoke, put the pork in the pan, skinned side down, and sear until golden brown all over, about 3 minutes per side. Lower the pork, skinned side down, into the pot with the tomato braising liquid.
Add the plum tomatoes and onion to the skillet and cook, turning every few minutes, until the tomato skins blister and blacken and the onion is caramelized on all sides. Tuck the vegetables around the pork in the pot. Add the remaining 2 tablespoons vinegar to the skillet and stir with a wooden spoon, scraping up any caramelized pork, tomato, and onion bits from the bottom. Pour over the pork.
Cover the pot, transfer to the oven, and cook for 30 minutes. Baste the pork, then turn the heat down to 300°F and continue to cook, basting every 30 minutes, until the pork is tender, about 2 1/2 hours. For pork so tender it falls from the bone—the kind suitable for barbecue sandwiches or tacos—cook 1 hour longer for a total of 3 1/2 hours.
Remove the pot from the oven and the pork from the pot. Let the pork cook on a cutting board. Season the sauce in the pot with molasses, vinegar, salt, pepper, and smoked paprika to taste (it usually tastes pretty good to me without further seasoning).
When the pork is cool enough to handle, pull it into shreds. I’m not going to lie to you—this is pretty gross, because the muscles in the shoulder are very articulated and, well, muscle-y. But you can’t run from the fact that you’re eating an animal here, so fortify yourself with a beer and get to it. Refrigerate the pulled pork overnight in a container with the sauce.
When the time comes to serve the tacos, reheat the pork gently in its sauce on top of the stove. Chop the cilantro and slice the onion very thin. Warm the flour tortillas (I do this in a skillet, individually, but this gets really tiresome with so many tortillas—any great ideas out there about how to warm a bunch of tortillas at once and still have them taste and feel good?) Let your guests build their own tacos, adding as much cilantro and onion as they like. The Lee brothers recommend using 1/4 cup pork and sauce per taco.