Just 1 Bottle: 9 Cocktails to Make With a Bottle of Rye and a Trip to the Grocery Store

20130901pour1.jpg

What to make with a bottle of rye. [Photo: Maggie Hoffman]

Rye cocktails often pair the whiskey with another bottle as a helper: sweet vermouth in the Manhattan, a little pastis or absinthe in the Sazerac. But if you don't really want to add another type of booze to your liquor cabinet, you can still enjoy a rye drink at home. Here are nine recipes to get you started.

Still looking for the right rye? Check out our picks for the best budget bottles—or these delicious high-end ryes.

Old Fashioned

[Photo: Vicky Wasik]

Let's start with something really simple—about as simple as a cocktail gets. Rye adds peppery spice to the easy stirred drink. As long as you have bitters and sugar on hand, you're good to go.

Get the Old Fashioned recipe »

Southern Baptist

20141008-rye-cocktails-2.jpg

[Photo: Wes Rowe]

Like your drinks fresh and spicy? Then this is the rye cocktail for you, bringing together an easy (uncooked!) syrup made from fresh ginger with tart lime.

Get the Southern Baptist recipe »

The Smash

20141008-rye-cocktails-9.jpg

[Photo: Robyn Lee]

If you like mint juleps but are looking for something even easier to make, try subbing rye for the bourbon in this simple classic. All you have to do is dissolve sugar in water, then add fresh mint and spirits, then shake away.

Get the Smash recipe »

Filibuster

20141008-rye-cocktails-3.jpg

[Photo: Wes Rowe]

Rye has a natural affinity for maple syrup, and we like the way the maple adds both flavor and sweetness. This riff on a classic sour calls on bright, tangy lemon to balance the syrup's earthy richness. Frothy egg whites crown the drink with foam, and a few dashes of Angostura anoint the top.

Get the Filibuster recipe »

Pumpernickel Highball

20141008-rye-cocktails-6.jpg

[Photo: Heather Arndt Anderson]

This cocktail riffs on the traditional flavors found in a Jewish deli using a caraway simple syrup that's rich with woody and floral flavors. It's all lightened up with club soda and cucumber. Serve at a bagel brunch if desired.

Get the Pumpernickel Highball recipe »

The Fine Feller

20141008-rye-cocktails-7.jpg

[Photo: Nick Guy]

So you finally got rid of your Christmas tree, but you're missing its piney scent. This cocktail will bring you right back home, thanks to a syrup sweetened with honey and steeped with pine needles. The drink is spiked with rye and lengthened with apple cider and Darjeeling tea—delicious!

Get the Fine Feller recipe »

Kale Pineapple Basil Smash

20141008-rye-cocktails-4.jpg

[Photo: Autumn Giles]

In this cocktail, the rye is brightened up with basil, fresh pineapple juice, and kale juice for a drink that's wonderfully sweet-tart and herbaceous.

Get the Kale Pineapple Basil Smash recipe »

New York Shrub

20141008-rye-cocktails-5.jpg

[Photo: Wes Rowe]

Cooking down regular old grocery store balsamic vinegar leaves you with a rich reduction that's surprisingly delicious in cocktails. Here, it's shaken with rye, lemon, and a little simple syrup for a whiskey drink that's wonderfully fresh-tasting.

Get the New York Shrub recipe »

Salted Peanut Old Fashioned

[Photo: Elana Lepkowski]

If you want to get fancy, you can bottle this ready-to-drink cocktail with a capper and everything—but you can also just prep this party drink in advance and keep it in a large size mason jar or sealed pitcher until ready to serve. The drink is inspired by the flavor of ballpark peanuts, and it's made with a touch of salt that balances the sweet and savory flavors of roasted nuts.

Get the Salted Peanut Old Fashioned recipe »

More One-Bottle Drinks

10 Cocktails to Make With Bourbon »
14 Cocktails to Make With Tequila »
15 Cocktails to Make With Gin »
14 Cocktails to Make With Rum »