Get the Recipe
Forget the candy, my favorite treat at school Halloween parties were the frosted marble cupcakes decorated with a mellowcreme pumpkin. (I prefered the mellowcreme cupcakes because, to me, mellowcreme pumpkins tasted like giant pieces of candy corn. And back then I loved candy corn.)
Those schooltime marble cupcakes inspired this recipe. But instead of swirling vanilla and chocolate cake batter together, I combined pumpkin and chocolate batter; the spiciness of the pumpkin cake works really well with chocolate. It adds a subtle spiciness to the chocolate without overwhelming it.
Not only are these cupcakes flavorful, they're incredibly light. During baking, the batter just about doubles in size. So be sure not to fill the cupcake cavity more than halfway full with batter or you might need to deal with overflowing pans.
To finish the cupcakes, ice them with a simple cream cheese buttercream. If you want to keep the cupcakes dairy-free, use a dairy-free cream cheese replacement, like the one from Tofutti.
And if you'd like to decorate the cupcakes with candy corn or mellowcreme pumpkins, just a note that not all mellowcremes/candy corn is gluten-free.
This post may contain links to Amazon or other partners; your purchases via these links can benefit Serious Eats. Read more about our affiliate linking policy.