"As the colors of the dessert get darker, the wine gets darker."
Everything you want to know about chocolate
I'm still learning my way around wine, but I had more or less stopped cold at dessert, where I tend to switch to coffee. But my friend (and Italian food expert) Francine Segan informed me that I'm doing it all wrong.
"There are several differences between how Italians serve dessert compared to how we do here in the States," Francine says. "Italians generally linger at the table after a meal, taking time to chat, nibble sweets, and relax. Desserts are served with dessert wines in Italy, not with coffee or tea." (by the way, Francine is also now the "U.S. ambassador" for Dolce Italia, where she is an official "sweets spokesperson," spreading the gospel about Italian desserts. Nice gig, but I digress.)
So how to figure out what wine to pick with dessert? There are three factors to consider: acidity (an acidic wine may pair best with a fruit dish, which also has natural acidity), intensity (the more intense the flavors of a dessert, the more intense the wine), and sweetness (a dessert wine should be sweeter than the dessert itself).
- Custard and vanilla
- Fruit and spice
- Caramels and chocolates
In general, as the colors of the dessert get darker, Gand says the wine gets darker. Here is a guide to wine pairings with each of the major dessert genres:
Custard and Vanilla
Desired Flavors (in the wine and dessert): Mild, light, buttery
Suggested Wine Pairings: White wines (late-harvest Riesling), sparkling wines like demi-sec champagne, and Asti Spumanti.
Fruit and Spice
Desired Flavors (in the wine and dessert): Apples, pears, cinnamon
Suggested Wine Pairings: White wines (Sauternes, late-harvest Gewirtztraminer) and pink champagne.
Caramels and Chocolates
Desired Flavors (in the wine and dessert): Dark, buttery, caramelized, rich.
Suggested Wine Pairings: Red wine (like late-harvest Pinot Noir, Banyuls, Grenache, Australian Shiraz), port (the classic chocolate pairing), and Grappa.
Desired Flavors (in the wine and dessert): Versatile.
Suggested Wine Pairings: Port and champagne.
Suggested Wine Pairings: Ice wine. (It's a dessert in itself!). And acidic, crisp white wines.
How do you decide what to pair with dessert? If you serve wine with dessert at all?
This post may contain links to Amazon or other partners; your purchases via these links can benefit Serious Eats. Read more about our affiliate linking policy.