Get to Know a Serious Eater.

stu_spivac's Profile

Website: http://www.stuartspivack.com/blog

Location:

About:

Favorite foods: toast, cottage bacon, smoked sable, noodle soup

Last bite on earth:

The Ten Most Recent Comments By stu_spivac

From Serious Eats

Serious Eats City Guide Premiere: New York (How to Leave Here Pleasantly Full)

I'm planning to visit New York in a couple weeks. The only question I have left is what to pack for dinner on travel day. I'm looking for something that can be stored in a cooler or at room temperature and be eaten at a highway rest stop. I was already thinking about a sandwich from Blue Ribbon Bakery but fried chicken sounds even better. Except. A mere month ago no less an authority than Ed Levine himself said the fried chicken sandwich at Blue Ribbon Bakery was consistently disappointing. So, is the fried chicken as fried chicken that much different from the fried chicken as a sandwich or has something changed dramatically in the last month?

From Serious Eats

Huarache Glory at Huaraches Dona Chio in Chicago

I've only been to the Maxwell Street Market once but I recall a sea of food vendors and I remember seeing huaraches there for the first time. I was already too stuffed to try one. Aren't there several that serve huaraches? Which one should I look for?

From Serious Eats

Yelp Extorting Businesses

Also, regarding the quality of reviews at Yelp!... Obviously, you have to take them for what they're worth. Unedited, quickly jotted notes from random strangers. They're pretty useless individually. Collectively, I think it's very valuable. If restaurant A has 1 bad review and restaurant B has 10 reviews, 8 good, then I think you can make a reasonable inference of relative quality. Of course, you'll be misled on occasion but it's certainly safer than walking down the street and picking a restaurant at random. And professional reviews aren't perfect either. Yelp! is just another tool. Personally, I get more use out of Serious Eats recommendations, local papers and Google but Yelp! is another tool and it may have its place.

From Serious Eats

Yelp Extorting Businesses

So, the reporter talks to two people. One is apparently gaming Yelp! with practices that are questionable at best. The other seems to be a case of sour grapes. The proprietor seemed to expect that her business account would allow her to quash any number of bad reviews. Her Yelp! page is generally positive but there are a small number of very negative ratings. This is a feature, not a bug.

Yelp!, on the other hand, is offering businesses the ability to shape their presence on the internet. I don't know exactly how their salespeople are selling the feature. They may be making misleading or unreasonable promises. However, the feature that they're selling is clearly ethical and nothing like extortion. They don't move or remove reviews, positive or negative, except where the reviews are believed to be fraudulent. I suppose it comes down to an issue of credibility. The proprietors interviewed for the article both seem sketchy and I have no reason to doubt Yelp!.

Frankly, I'm disappointed at how this is being handled by Serious Eats. Even if you give more credence to the news report than I do, you can't ignore that this is a two-sided issue. Your screaming scare-title gives a bad name to blogging.

I actually reported a fraudulent review to Yelp! once. I knew the restaurant in question well enough to be certain that the review was a lie. It was actually racist, too. I was disappointed that it took so long for Yelp! to address the issue. Months. At least. It's gone now though.

I've used Yelp! in the past because the map implementation is fantastic. It was much easier to do a broad survey of restaurants in a given area using Yelp! as compared to Google Maps.

From Serious Eats

Win Fuchsia Dunlop's 'Shark's Fin and Sichuan Pepper'

Shrimp with scrambled eggs
steamed chicken

From Serious Eats

Introducing Photograzing: Share Your Favorite Food Photos Here

I never participated in Tastespotting because they didn't permit links to bare photos. (The photos had to be part of a blog post.) I'm looking forward to participating here. Even though it allows me to participate, I mention it because it may have been a wise policy. You should keep an eye on flickr-centric posts and see if you consider them to be as worthy as full-fledged blog posts.

I'm curious whether the new Tastespotting still has that policy. I noticed that they're now linking directly to the source of the image from the RSS feed. I'm glad Photograzing also does that and I hope it stays that way. As I recall, the old Tastespotting and one or two of the pretenders to the tastespotting throne required you to click through their home pages to get to the original source of the image. I'd rather see ads in the rss feed than have to click twice.

From Serious Eats

Seriously Delicious Holiday Food Giveaway: Russ & Daughters

From Serious Eats

Seriously Delicious Holiday Giveaway: D'Artagnan Heritage Smoked Ham

mustard and swiss.

From Serious Eats

Seriously Delicious Holiday Giveaway: Southside Market Sausage

Neat. Two other votes for Hot Sauce Williams and I'll make three.

From Serious Eats

Seriously Delicious Giveaway: Zingerman's Gift Certificate

Responses to Comments by stu_spivac

From Serious Eats

Serious Eats City Guide Premiere: New York (How to Leave Here Pleasantly Full)

Rethinking the Hamburger I would add the Lamb Burger at L'Express on PAS.

From Serious Eats

Serious Eats City Guide Premiere: New York (How to Leave Here Pleasantly Full)

I really think that the best steakhouse experience can be had at Porter House New York: great view, serious prime, dry-aged steak, excellent
sides, and truly wonderful desserts. And you can usually get in, something you can't do on a moment's notice at Peter Luger's, unless you go for lunch.
As far as dim sum is concerned, the last meal I had at Jin Fong was less than mediocre. Joe Ng of Chinatown Brasserie is by far the best dim sum chef in NY. @stuspivak: The fried chicken at Blue Ribbon Brasserie is what I love, and I don't even think they sell it to go. You could either get a couple of sandwiches to go from Blue Ribbon Bakery or go to an Amy's Bread for a sandwich and a cookie. Or you could get a banh mi from either Nicky's Vietnamese Sandwiches or even some Chinese spare ribs from Big Wong. You will need a wet nap or two if you get the Big Wong spareribs. They are sticky, messy, and so delicious.

From Serious Eats

Serious Eats City Guide Premiere: New York (How to Leave Here Pleasantly Full)

Where would you recommend the best steak to be had? I'm there for 2 nights and am eager to have a decent steak!

From Serious Eats

Serious Eats City Guide Premiere: New York (How to Leave Here Pleasantly Full)

Yeah, the regular bagels at Absolute are huuuuuuuuuuuuuuge. But so tasty!

From Serious Eats

Serious Eats City Guide Premiere: New York (How to Leave Here Pleasantly Full)

Decent list but I have to disagree about the Chinese food in Manhattan. The Chinese food in Manhattan is pretty mediocre. If you want the good stuff you have to make a trek to Flushing.

From Serious Eats

Serious Eats City Guide Premiere: New York (How to Leave Here Pleasantly Full)

Under Barbecue, I agree with Ed that particular places are best for particular items. I would put RUB's burnt ends in the same category as his other "bests".

From Serious Eats

Serious Eats City Guide Premiere: New York (How to Leave Here Pleasantly Full)

The name of the cocktail bar you recommended is Employees Only. There's no "For" in the name.

From Serious Eats

Serious Eats City Guide Premiere: New York (How to Leave Here Pleasantly Full)

Masa is the type of place that if you can afford it you'd know about it and don't need a guide to point it out.

From Serious Eats

Serious Eats City Guide Premiere: New York (How to Leave Here Pleasantly Full)

Ed you nailed it - as usual an earnest, informative, thorough post.

I couldn't agree more on Absolute Bagels, Blue Ribbon, and Totonno's.

I dislike Una Pizza Napolatana and would rank many other pies higher. To me UPN suffers from doing parts of its pizza TOO well. Pies there have a perfect crust, incredible cheese (I'm going to assume they justify the astronomical prices with the top-quality cheese), and great toppings - yet often, the flavor of the tomato sauce doesn't come through and create the glorious harmony of a true NYC pie.

Anyway, awesome list, I have a lot to try now.

From Serious Eats

Serious Eats City Guide Premiere: New York (How to Leave Here Pleasantly Full)

I'm glad Ed still stands by Totonno's. I never understand when I hear talk that they have fallen off (something I've heard at various times over the last 10-15 years). In my experience they are one of the most consistent shops that turn out top quality pizza. It is, and probably always will be, my favorite overall pizza place anywhere.