pete’s Profile

Recent Comments

From Serious Eats: New York

Is a Fancy-Pants Burger A Contradiction in Terms?

Bux, I'm sure Bill Telepan, Geoffrey Zakarian, David Burke and Bobby Flay will be delighted to hear they're not first-class chefs!

I agree with you that the flavor of the db burger is its most successful aspect. But why did Boulud have to dress it up like a burger when it doesn't eat like a burger? It's not a successful dish. It's a press release on a plate.

From Serious Eats: New York

Is a Fancy-Pants Burger A Contradiction in Terms?

Mr. Cutlets is somewhat fanatical on the subject of buns. Yes, a basic, cheap-ass hamburger bun can be just right sometimes, but that doesn't mean it can't be improved on. Where a lot of fancy-pants burgers go wrong is in trying too hard. I take no pleasure in eating a burger that sits on a blimplike brioche so tall you need the detachable jaw of a python to bite into it. If a chef wants something fancier than a regular bun, fine, but they should keep in mind that it's not about the visuals. Eventually, somebody's going to have to eat the damn thing.

Eatability in general is my biggest issue with fancypants burgers. If the meat is too thick, again, it's hard to eat it without the aid of a knife and a fork. That silliness at db is Public Enemy Number One in this regard. It defies all the principles of eatability.

From Serious Eats: New York

Why do most birthday cakes suck?

I don't know if I'm prepared to say that all birthday cakes suck, but without a doubt most of the layer cakes you can buy in NYC do. Some of them may LOOK great but they just do not deliver. The cake itself is either dry and crumbly or gummy; the frosting is all too often either a grainy sugary mess or a wad of wax that sticks to the roof of your mouth until your next birthday.

I agree completely about Two Little Red Hens; I served ten of their cakes at my wedding and people were very happy. Before we bought them, my wife and I ran all over New York sampling layer cakes (we didn't even get into the "wedding cake" scam) and we were depressed and disappointed over and over until we got to the Little Red Hens. Why do people support bakeries that turn out sub-par cakes? I can only speculate that because cake is now a once-or-twice-a-year occasion, people don't eat it often enough to be discerning. It's like the roast turkey at Thanksgiving--sure, everybody knows it's dry as sandpaper, but most of them have never know it any other way, and they can put up with it once a year.

The red velvet cake at Cakeman Raven in Fort Greene is a lovely thing but the employees there are, in my experience, flakey. I wouldn't want to rely on them if I absolutely needed a cake for a special occasion--which a birthday, by definition, is.

See more comments by pete ยป

Recent Posts

pete hasn't written a post yet.

Recent Favorites

pete hasn't favorited a post yet.

Recent Polls

pete hasn't answered any polls yet.

Recent Quizzes

pete hasn't taken any quizzes yet.

Recent Comments | Response to Comments

From Serious Eats: New York

Is a Fancy-Pants Burger A Contradiction in Terms?

Bux, I'm sure Bill Telepan, Geoffrey Zakarian, David Burke and Bobby Flay will be delighted to hear they're not first-class chefs!

I agree with you that the flavor of the db burger is its most successful aspect. But why did Boulud have to dress it up like a burger when it doesn't eat like a burger? It's not a successful dish. It's a press release on a plate.

From Serious Eats: New York

Is a Fancy-Pants Burger A Contradiction in Terms?

Mr. Cutlets is somewhat fanatical on the subject of buns. Yes, a basic, cheap-ass hamburger bun can be just right sometimes, but that doesn't mean it can't be improved on. Where a lot of fancy-pants burgers go wrong is in trying too hard. I take no pleasure in eating a burger that sits on a blimplike brioche so tall you need the detachable jaw of a python to bite into it. If a chef wants something fancier than a regular bun, fine, but they should keep in mind that it's not about the visuals. Eventually, somebody's going to have to eat the damn thing.

Eatability in general is my biggest issue with fancypants burgers. If the meat is too thick, again, it's hard to eat it without the aid of a knife and a fork. That silliness at db is Public Enemy Number One in this regard. It defies all the principles of eatability.

From Serious Eats: New York

Why do most birthday cakes suck?

I don't know if I'm prepared to say that all birthday cakes suck, but without a doubt most of the layer cakes you can buy in NYC do. Some of them may LOOK great but they just do not deliver. The cake itself is either dry and crumbly or gummy; the frosting is all too often either a grainy sugary mess or a wad of wax that sticks to the roof of your mouth until your next birthday.

I agree completely about Two Little Red Hens; I served ten of their cakes at my wedding and people were very happy. Before we bought them, my wife and I ran all over New York sampling layer cakes (we didn't even get into the "wedding cake" scam) and we were depressed and disappointed over and over until we got to the Little Red Hens. Why do people support bakeries that turn out sub-par cakes? I can only speculate that because cake is now a once-or-twice-a-year occasion, people don't eat it often enough to be discerning. It's like the roast turkey at Thanksgiving--sure, everybody knows it's dry as sandpaper, but most of them have never know it any other way, and they can put up with it once a year.

The red velvet cake at Cakeman Raven in Fort Greene is a lovely thing but the employees there are, in my experience, flakey. I wouldn't want to rely on them if I absolutely needed a cake for a special occasion--which a birthday, by definition, is.

From Serious Eats: New York

Why do most birthday cakes suck?

"Moist cake and a not too sweet frosting." I like that as a birthday cake mantra. Maybe we should add "smooth, not grainy" to the frosting description.

From Serious Eats: New York

Why do most birthday cakes suck?

I agree with Ed. Most birthday cakes are tasteless cavity traps. I like the red velvet cupcakes from Amy's bakery. I haven't tried the cake version, but I'm sure it has to be the same recipe. For the Red Velvet cupcake she uses a whip cream for the top (not icing), and her cupcake is moist. For me, it's all about moist cake and a not too sweet frosting.

From Serious Eats: New York

Is a Fancy-Pants Burger A Contradiction in Terms?

Pete, I'm sure Telepan, Zakarian, Burke and Flay could hardly care less whether I think they are running a restaurant that competes with Daniel.

I don't know why Boulud had to dress the db burger like a burger. I doubt he had to do it at all. He chose to do it and I'm sure his choice was very much affected by the prospect of some publicity. For what it's worth, when I had one, I pretty much ate it like a burger. As for its success, Boulud constantly tinkers with his food. When a dish stays on the menu for years, it's almost always because his clientele keeps demanding the dish. Beyond what pleases your, or my, subjective taste, that pretty much defines "successful dish" for a restaurateur. We both seem to like the flavor, or taste, of the db burger and we both acknowledge a certain PR consideration in its creation, but I think its success has been judged by others and its appearance on the menu shouldn't detract from our enjoyment of db Bistro just because others are having fun.

Recent Posts

pete hasn't written a post yet.

Recent Favorites

pete hasn't favorited a post yet.

Polls

pete hasn't answered any polls yet.

Quizzes

pete hasn't taken any quizzes yet.

About pete

Website:

Location:

About:

Favorite foods:

Last bite on earth: