Serious Eats - seriouseats.com

Sallys is better than Pepe's by a hair. A white fresh tomato and garlic pizza from Sallys is unbeatable. Onion pizza is also great. You can't complain about the service from Sallys, you have to know what to expect. They've got one or two waiters at a time, and they get you your drinks and pizza with no sugar-coating...they've got a lot of people to satisfy and their number one priority is efficiency. I find ithe service great, in a strange kind of way. Modern pizza is number three in New Haven with some great pies as well. But Sallys will always hold a place in my heart as the top pizza in New Haven, and for me, the best pies that I've ever had. Awesome baby!!!!