Matt Jacobs’s Profile

Recent Comments

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

Wow, sounds like there have been a lot of pizza developments in Madison! I'll have to head back with an open mind.

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

Ugh, I never liked Ian's when I was there. It had unusual combinations, but the pizza puritan side of me wouldn't tolerate it. I was always a big fan of Glass Nickel. It still has that west coast-y, puffy crust, but was pretty damn delicious. Of course, it's been over 5 years so I should really go back and taste it again to confirm my memories.

From Talk

Has anyone received the Cook's Illustrated test recipes yet?

And I got a fish one yesterday, so it looks like not everyone is getting the same recipes. I guess patience is the key here. I'm guessing we'll all get our chance. :)

See more comments by Matt Jacobs »

Recent Posts

From A Hamburger Today

Meat-o-philes, Head to Rare Bar & Grill

From A Hamburger Today

Are These the Ultimate Beef Burgers?

From A Hamburger Today

Damn, This Truth Really is Inconvenient

From A Hamburger Today

Michael Bauer on the Best Bay Area Burgers

See more posts by Matt Jacobs »

Recent Favorites

From Serious Eats: New York

Shameless Rumormongering: Leah and Hosea Both Taking Off

From A Hamburger Today

The AHT Guide to Hamburger and Cheeseburger Styles

From A Hamburger Today

Hamburgers on 'The Martha Stewart Show'; AHT Makes an Appearance on TV

From A Hamburger Today

Guide to Sliders in Northern New Jersey

See more favorites by Matt Jacobs »

Recent Polls

Matt Jacobs hasn't answered any polls yet.

Recent Quizzes

Matt Jacobs hasn't taken any quizzes yet.

Recent Comments | Response to Comments

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

Wow, sounds like there have been a lot of pizza developments in Madison! I'll have to head back with an open mind.

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

Ugh, I never liked Ian's when I was there. It had unusual combinations, but the pizza puritan side of me wouldn't tolerate it. I was always a big fan of Glass Nickel. It still has that west coast-y, puffy crust, but was pretty damn delicious. Of course, it's been over 5 years so I should really go back and taste it again to confirm my memories.

From Talk

Has anyone received the Cook's Illustrated test recipes yet?

And I got a fish one yesterday, so it looks like not everyone is getting the same recipes. I guess patience is the key here. I'm guessing we'll all get our chance. :)

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

I just had a slice of Ian's mac & cheese pizza (Chicago location) on a whim today. I've been in love with this slice since I was in college and would make the trip from the University of Minnesota to Madison, it was my one requirement while visiting. Also, you definitely do not need to be drunk to enjoy this slice, it's amazing in any mind state.

Also, check out http://thisiswhyyourefat.com/ as the mac and cheese pizza is featured there today, 7/6/09. This slice is definitely worth the calories!

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

@goosegirl: Thanks for the report. Wish I could hop a plane and try the mac-and-cheese slice. It's gotten such a surprising amount of love here in the comments.

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

This is my first post and the reason behind it is that I had Ian's mac and cheese for the first time on Friday night and after frequenting this site for months, I had to chime in.
The mac and cheese was not on the counter, you had to ask for it - it was the most unique, comforting, and surprisingly delicious slice of pizza I've ever had. Consumed on the street on a cool day after a few pints of delicious Goose Island beers, nothing has hit the spot quite like that pizza.

For most food in the Peoples' Republic of Madison, I'm a fan, however the service is usually quite poor. But after having Ian's and Dotty's hamburgers this weekend, all I can say is "Go Badgers!"

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

Ziti pizza is a standard at T&R, on Amsterdam Ave. in Manhattan...

T&R Pizza

...and on rare occasion, spaghetti pizza shows its face, too. What the folks at T&R were thinking when they first put pasta on pizza, I've never asked, but the pizzeria is just south of a stretch of spilling-onto-the-sidewalk bars.

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

Glass Nickel may be in the process of overexpanding. They've now got six locations and are apparently opening a seventh in Brookfield. It seems to me that the Fetalicious was always a bit too soggy, but my old favorite the Santa Fe had gotten noticeably worse over the last couple years (less BBQ sauce, dry and tasteless chicken). I hope not, but for me the point is pretty much moot since I moved out of the Madison area last month.

Speaking of weird pizza toppings, my wife brought home a chicken cordon bleu (I think--it might have been something equally improbably) pizza from Casa Bianca on Junction Rd once that was just fantastic. The Glass Nickel version was too heavy. Never been to Ian's.

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

I live in Jersey, which is hardly 'odd' pizza country, and I've seen baked ziti (tomato sauce, pasta, cheese) on pizza many times.

I haven't injested such a slice, but the mac n' cheese just seems like a 'white' pizza version of that...who knows who got the idea to think 'hey, pasta is Italian! Pizza is Italian! The two must go together.'

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

I've had this slice. Their quesadilla pizza is more exciting. It's for those times you can't decide between quesadilla and pizza; just have both!

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

I was a little hesitant to try this pizza (raised on "normal toppings" and only started branching out a few years ago), I had it for the first time a few weeks ago and it was DELICIOUS. Didn't even have to be drunk to appreciate it's yumminess.

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

Glass Nickel used to be our standby in Madison until we discovered Pavlov's thin crust pizza. Unfortunately, Pavlov's can be a little lax on opening on time (or even at all), which can be frustrating, so our new favorite is Pizza Brutta on Monroe, especially if you eat it immediately. Thin crust, awesome local ingredients. Superb.

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

@BangieB: I think the "Fetallicious" is a rather unfortunate name for a pizza, considering the possibility for a misread on that name.

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

the black bean avocado is my fave. one slice is definitely enough for a meal, although i have been known to have TWO slices.

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

Matt - in my opinion, Glass Nickel has gone way downhill. We've dubbed the Fetalicious the "Wetalicious," because of all the liquid the tomatoes leech out onto everything. Though, to give you a context for my opinion, I always thought (and still think) that Falbo Bros. has the best pizza in Madison.

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

when i first looked at the pic i thought it was vile, but the more i thought about it, the more i want to get drunk right now and then eat that pizza.

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

You're probably right, JudyH. I just changed it. Yiddish is not my first language ;)

From Slice

Mac and Cheese Pizza: Ian's Pizza, Madison, Wisconsin

Adam - Wouldn't it be more accurate to spell it bupkes?

From Talk

Has anyone received the Cook's Illustrated test recipes yet?

I received a test recipe for last week for a pork stir-fry lo mein that ended up being really good.

From Talk

Has anyone received the Cook's Illustrated test recipes yet?

re: the pizza..
anyone planning on making it soon? I was going to but I just found out that I'm going to be out most of the weekend. If anyone does try it, please post to say how it is :)

From Talk

Has anyone received the Cook's Illustrated test recipes yet?

I a no-roll pizza bianca, too, but it calls for portabella mushrooms and taleggio cheese. Looks interesting, but not sure I'll have a chance to try it. Not to mention, could be tough finding the taleggio cheese around here...

From Talk

Has anyone received the Cook's Illustrated test recipes yet?

I just got No-Roll Pizza Bianca. The only "toppings" on this is olive oil, salt, and rosemary. Sounds like the tomato and parm one might be tastier!

From Talk

Has anyone received the Cook's Illustrated test recipes yet?

Still nada for me too. Why did I do wrong? Do they just hate me or something? I know I can be very opinionated sometimes...

From Talk

Has anyone received the Cook's Illustrated test recipes yet?

I just got my first one .. Crunchy oven baked fish .. today.

From Talk

Has anyone received the Cook's Illustrated test recipes yet?

That's interesting, Brooke -- I just got a recipe for No-Roll Pizza Bianca with Tomatoes and Parmesan! I wish I'd gotten the one you got, frankly.

I just made the dough, and it's a sticky mess; I think the technique as described is overly complicated and a waste of time. I'll bake the pizza later today and see what's what. I'll be interested to hear how yours turns out.

V.

From Talk

Has anyone received the Cook's Illustrated test recipes yet?

Yay! I got my first recipe to test - it's a No-Roll Pizza Bianca with Caramelized Onions and Gruyere. Sounds good!

Recent Posts

From A Hamburger Today

Meat-o-philes, Head to Rare Bar & Grill

From A Hamburger Today

Are These the Ultimate Beef Burgers?

From A Hamburger Today

Damn, This Truth Really is Inconvenient

From A Hamburger Today

Michael Bauer on the Best Bay Area Burgers

From A Hamburger Today

Burger Cake...With Fries!

From A Hamburger Today

We Try the Bamn! Burgers

From A Hamburger Today

Brgr: A New NYC Burger Joint for the Fall

From A Hamburger Today

Breaking: Soup Burg is Closing

From A Hamburger Today

Top 5 NYC Burgers According to NY Magazine

From A Hamburger Today

June 24th: Gothamist/AHT Burger Party

From A Hamburger Today

A Birthday Burger Basket

From A Hamburger Today

Whiffs of a Burger at Craftsteak

From A Hamburger Today

Review: Peter Luger Steakhouse

From A Hamburger Today

You Don't Win Friends with Salad

From A Hamburger Today

Pimp My Burger

From A Hamburger Today

Quick Bites: Luxbar, Chicago

From A Hamburger Today

AOL City Guide Releases City's Best 2006

From A Hamburger Today

We Made the Roethlis-Burger

From A Hamburger Today

A Thomas Keller Burger Joint in Napa Valley

From A Hamburger Today

Hamburgers Invade Fashion Week

From A Hamburger Today

Accident Gives Cows a Glimpse of Their Fate

From A Hamburger Today

Review: Houston's

From A Hamburger Today

The Whopperettes Make Their Debut

From A Hamburger Today

The Roethlis-Burger

From A Hamburger Today

Review: Mo Pitkin's

Polls

Matt Jacobs hasn't answered any polls yet.

Quizzes

Matt Jacobs hasn't taken any quizzes yet.

About Matt Jacobs

Website: http://www.capndesign.com

Location: Brooklyn, NY

About:

Favorite foods: Burgers, burgers, burgers

Last bite on earth: