Profile

jgelfand

Best pie in NoLita / East Village?

Do they do whole pies?

The Serious Eats All Star NYC Barbecue Dream Team

The beef ribs at Daisy May's are quite impressive - and gigantic, one portion easily feeds two. Though a different style than Mighty Quinn's or Hill Country, they are very tasty.

Airport Food That's Actually Good

Manny's at Midway Airport in Chicago has a great pastrami sandwich.

Clay Pot Rice at Yummy Noodle: The Best Deal in Chinatown?

Awah on Catherine Street between E. Broadway and Madison (?) does the same as well, and the expect you the keep the pots. I recently got take out from them and asked if I should return the pots, and they said "keep it." I've also found their clay pots to be as good if not better than Yummy Noodles, but not an expert.

Havana brand alfajores in NYC?

Unfortunately I'll be out of NY this Saturday - will you be at the Hester Street Fair all summer?

Oaxacan Mole Sauce in NYC

Thanks a lot for the info. Does Tulcingo del Valle sell just their mole sauce for take away? I looked at their website and they appear to be a restaurant. I guess I'm more looking for a good Mexican / Oaxacan grocery store somewhere in the city...

Inexpensive BBQ or Mexican Dinner for 10 in Village

We actually ended up going to Yerba Buena, which somehow had room even though it is a tiny space (we did go early, about 6:30pm). Restaurant week menu was really good - highly recommend the beef entree. Thanks for the suggestions!

Get Out of Town: Rhinebeck, Red Hook, and Tivoli

I second the recommendation of Le Canard in Kingston, which has very good hearty French bistro food.

Malaysian Restaurant Week (NYC) Recommendations?

My wife and I and two friends went to Laut for dinner and Fatty Crab (West Village) for lunch for Malaysian Restaurant week so far. At both places, you get an appetizer, entree, and dessert. Here were our impressions:

Laut - The appetizers we got were otah otah (fish cake wrapped in banana leaf), five-spice pork rolls (spiced minced pork wrapped in some form of wrapper and then deep fried), and roti chanai (curry and a very thin bread). The otah otah was tasty but small, we all enjoyed the five-spice pork roll a lot - the spice was not overwhelming, and it came with a nice sauce (deep fried minced pork, how can you go wrong?), and the roti chanai had a nice flavorful coconut curry. Our entrees were chili crab, shrimp coconut curry with okra and black rice, beef rendang, and a fourth I can't remember. The chili crab was really nice, two soft-shell crabs with a spicy thick red chili sauce - served with rice buns to mop up the sauce. The shrimp coconut curry was nice as well, the black rice added an interesting nuttiness, the curry was spicy but not overwhelmingly so, though the okra was a bit slimier than I like. The beef rendang was flavorful and soft, but not overly so. For desert, we got fried ice cream, peanut crepe, and sticky rice with pandan pudding. Unfortunately, the dessert overall was disappointing - the batter of the fried ice cream had a weird consistency, the ice cream was freezer burned, and the sticky rice was fairly tasty but very small. Overall, the meal was very nice, and am definitely interested in going back to Laut.

Fatty Crab - This is a restaurant I'd wanted to try for a while, so I was very excited to see they were participating (albeit only for lunch). The selection at Fatty Crab was much smaller than that at Laut - only 3-4 entrees and 1 dessert while Laut had ~7 entrees and 4 desserts. For the appetizers we got grilled asparagus and mango & papaya salad. The grilled asparagus was tasty, and came with a nice chili-mayo type sauce, but still was grilled asparagus. The salad had a good amount of mango and green papaya, and was spicy, but was missing the sour flavor that really brings this dish together. For the entrees we had nasi lemak, clams with pepper and yuzu, and beef redang. The clams were very peppery and tasty, but overall somewhat disappointing. The nasi lemak was extremely tasty, very good rice, tasty chicken curry, excellent anchovy and grilled onion side - BUT the otah otah was just crumbly red grains that tasted nothing like fish and the chicken in one of ours did not appear to be cooked all the way through (they apologized and reheated it. It is braised for hours, so the pink color inside was a bit surprising). The beef redang was amazing though - a small beef rib, ridiculously tender, with a lovely coconut curry sauce. The dessert was a small coconut sticky rice concoction that was tasty. Also, the service was friendly, but there were problems with the meal - the chicken as mentioned above, one otah otah had nothing inside of it, the portion sizes were okay but not great, and >10 minutes separated when the different appetizers and entrees were brought to the table (I know they bring food when ready to promote sharing, but it was still a bit ridiculous).
Overall, the meal was good but I didn't feel it lived up to my expectations. Very good deal, esp. given their usual prices.

Hope you find this helpful.

Malaysian Restaurant Week (NYC) Recommendations?

Thanks. I once went to Nyonya in Chinatown and was really disappointed, the food seemed bland to me... I think it is a former branch of the "Penang" chain of restaurants which have been very hit or miss for me - the one in Chinatown Boston is my favorite so far...

Lunch near Metropolitan Museum of Art

We ended up going to Ko Sushi at 71st and 2nd avenue (Shabu 70 was closed for whatever reason), which isn't that close to the Met, but was a good and reasonably priced neighborhood Sushi restaurant and worth going to if hungry and in that area.

Sugar Rush: Cinnamon Buns at Fairway

Do you know where I can get good cinnamon rolls without raisins?

Favorite Japanese curry spots in NYC?

menkuitei and go curry are really good (and cheap) too.

Taim sets for a falafel truck

I like their spicy falafel the best, but they probably should go with "original."
If the food truck doesn't cause the restaurant to go out of business, or distract them too much, don't see the harm.

The Best Macaroni and Cheese in New York City

Did you try MacBar on Prince just E of Lafayette (it is next to Delicatessen, and I believe it is run by the same people)? The duck and chipotle mac & cheese are pretty good...

Sugar Rush: Spot's Peanut Butter Cookie

I'm not a big fan of the green tea lemon cookie, tastes too much like green tea powder to me, but like pretty much everything else. The coconut chocolate cookie is really good, mostly chocolate though, with a nice texture from the shredded coconut. Also really like the caramel cupcake.

Speaking of Mac 'n Cheese...

Japanese Restaurant in the East Village

Menkuitei is good and cheap. As is Go on St. Mark's Place.

What's Your Favorite Cupcake In New York?

Spot (btw Batch = Spot).

What's Your Favorite Coffee In New York?

Just the regular cup of coffee Roasting Plant is pretty good.

Quality thai places in the city

Rhong Tiam on Laguardia Place north of Bleecker is the best my wife and I have had in Manhattan.

The Great Bagel Debate

I've found that St. Viateur bagels, when fresh and hot, have the consistency of a NY pretzel, NOT a NY bagel. A very good pretzel - better than what you can get from street vendors in NY, but still a pretzel in bagel-shape. I really feel they are two separate beasts, both good but so different it doesn't make sense to compare them.

Motorino in Manhattan

I went there recently for lunch, and for me (at least), it committed two of the cardinal sins that no restaurant should ever commit - don't advertise a lunch (or any) special on your website if you don't actually do it, and charge prices significantly higher than what is listed on the menu posted on your website. Motorino did both, and while my Sopresseta pizza was tasty and the crust was very very good it had too little cheese and sopresseta and too much liquidy (though very good) tomato sauce. Not going back. At all.

Dulce de Leche/Caramel Cheesecake in New York?

I haven't tried the Dulce De Leche cheesecak at Eileen's, but the other flavors I've tried have been wonderful.

What's Your Favorite Chocolate Chip Cookie?

I'm a fan of Insomnia Cookies on 8th Street. Nothing fancy or special, just tasty.

Best pie in NoLita / East Village?

I'm looking for a good place to get a basic pie (e.g., cherry, apple) in the East Village, Village, Soho, NoLita area. Any suggestions? I'm not looking for anything particularly fancy, just tasty.

Thanks.

Where to get a Good Birthday Cake in the Village?

Hello,

I'm look for a good bakery in the Village / East Village area to get a nice, simple, moist chocolate birthday cake. If Pinisi was still around, I'd get their Chocolate on Fire cake. But their gone. Blackhound is a little too fancy, and not a big fan of Bruno's cakes. Any suggestions? Thanks.

Havana brand alfajores in NYC?

Hello all,

I was wondering if any of you knew where I could find "Havana" brand alfajores (it comes from Argentina, not Cuba) in NYC? If not those, do you know of any places that have similar quality alfajores? The places I've tried in Queens based on past seriouseats NY posts are too much cookie, too little dulce de leche, and the cookie is too crunchy for my tastes. Thanks a lot.

Saturday Lunch/Brunch in Lancaster/Hershey, PA?

Hello, some friends and are going from NYC to Amish Country and Hershey, PA on Saturday, and was wondering if anyone had any recommendations for where to get lunch / brunch in the area. We are particularly interested in going to a good smorgasborg if there are any. Thanks.

Inexpensive BBQ or Mexican Dinner for 10 in Village

Hello,

I was wondering if any of you had recommendations on where to take a party of 10 (gulp), including kids, for either a BBQ or Mexican dinner in the Village area that isn't too pricey. I was thinking of Dallas Jones BBQ (I was also thinking of either Wildwood BBQ by Union Square or Bone Lick Park on Greenwich & 7th Aves but haven't been that impressed with either). I know this isn't the best area for either cuisines, but any suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

Nice Sitdown Mexican Restaurant for Dinner?

I was wondering if anyone had a recommendation for a good, nice, sitdown Mexican restaurant for dinner in Manhattan to take a guest from far out of town (UAE). Was thinking of Rosa Mexicana or Crema, but not wedded to either. Any preferences / suggestions? Thanks.

Veritas Restaurant. Any thoughts?

My wife and I are looking for a restaurant to celebrate our anniversary, and are trying to decide between Daniel and Veritas. Veritas's menu sounds very intriguing, but was wondering if this restaurant was still any good. Thanks a lot.
PS Any other restaurant recommendations similar to these would be greatly appreciated...

NE Style Seafood Shack on the North Shore of Long Island?

I was wondering if any one knew of a good New England style (fried clams, scallops, boiled lobster, steamers, that sort of thing) seafood shack on the North Shore of Long Island? Would prefer something not particularly fancy, but any good seafood restaurants in that area would also be welcome. Lastly, any winery recommendations?

Thanks.

jgelfand hasn't favorited a post yet.