MFK Fisher - Just a Little Word - Fair or Foul?
In 'Garum' MFK Fisher writes of the foodways of Ancient Rome. She discusses the overeating that occurred and the habit they had of quickly emptying their stomachs with emetics in order to eat more.
Then she writes:
The wholesale catharsis necessitated certain architectural changes. And suddenly these changes, luxurious privies to start with, metamorphosed once more. Vomitoria came into being.
Then after writing how little boys and girls hear the name with disgust only one person ever used the word in public with the proper 'reverence': Colette, who noted that a certain eclair vomiteusement chocolate.
Following that is
Romans, their minds less of future derivatives of the word than on their next course, used their vomitoria with appreciation.
The end of the piece lists a heavy banquet to be dined upon then finishes with:
A good old Roman custom - vomitoria! .
This has been in print since 1937. MFK Fisher is considered to be one of America's finest 'food writers'. Some people say that the word 'food writing' was practically invented for her, because of her then-innovative style of writing that blended fact with memoir.
Blending fact with memoir can be problematic in general, in writing. One either does not question, believing the writer of the tale to be telling the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth or one questions the writer's understanding of their own reality. Memory is a funny thing. It is not all that objective.
But here in this case is a telling of facts, but a telling of facts that simply is not true. Vomitoria is not something one vomits into, it is an exit from a building.
MFK Fisher may have been confused due to the general use of the word in her time. But then again she is an educator about food, and in this case writes as one, and one to be respected.
Fair or foul? Should this have been corrected by an editor or by the publishers at some point since 1937 with a note to explain this?
renzata - I understand your point that you escape your higher thinking in other things by coming here to discuss other things, and that if you want deeper discussion you'll read elsewhere.
If I had what you call a 'pretentious hissy fit' I'm glad I did. About time, I think. I've had them before, and each time - by the time I did it made me realize that it was time to do exactly as you say - read elsewhere.
I think you for the term 'hissy fit' used though - it shows clearly that you understand that foodvox is Karen Resta who is a person, a real one - and also a female person . . . for I've seen this sort of 'hissy fit' here on SE before thrown by a guy and the word hissy fit was not used as description of these sorts of things. I note this since as you appear to be a young woman entering the professional world you may notice these things those times when you are trying to put your own foot down. 'Hissy fit'. Or (?)
No, I haven't been back. As they say 'Things can go on without you' and I sincerely believe this. We all have to find our own places to be, and when the place one has been is one where little biting flies continue to swarm around it's time to move on.
One other note - my name and background are clear and can be confirmed. Many others commenting above are doing so with screen names - no real names attached. I've even seen photographs of people showing up on Facebook as 'people you may know' with their screen name attached - no real name. Are they real people? Are they straw people or ghosts - made up by an active imagination?
And as for the rapt attention to my topic, seriously - I didn't ask for it. All I asked was to be left to explore it without ongoing snipes from the same little biting flies who always seem to gather round to make themselves known by their hilarious one-liners (which can be read above).
LOL. LOL. As they say. LMAO, too.
All's well that ends well.