Recent Comments

From A Hamburger Today

New York's First Steak 'n Shake Opens Tomorrow

Wait, I forgot a line there, the seasonal white chocolate shakes are wonderful while they last. It's just the fries (and cottage cheese) that are forgettable.

At their full-menu locations at least, they do have a "Wisconsin Buttery Steakburger" (as well as the In-N-Out-style California one, a barbecue one, a Fritos-chili cheese one, some sort of avocado one last I checked, etc. etc.)

From A Hamburger Today

New York's First Steak 'n Shake Opens Tomorrow

Here's the detail that everyone is missing, and this is me saying this as a resident of St. Louis, which has either the second or first highest concentration of Steak 'n Shakes in the country (that's right Indianapolis, you have competition): the quality of Steak 'n Shakes varies entirely by location. I've had so-so SNS, I've had "pretty good" SNS, and I've had absolutely sublime SNS. It always feels like some locations care about getting it right, and some are just slinging burgers out the drive-through window. Midwesterners, choose your location with care. (For what it's worth, the best Steak 'n Shake I've ever eaten in the St. Louis area was way out west in Wentzville. I wouldn't make a field trip for it, but if you're in the neighborhood, definitely worth a stop.)

That this is the first NYC Steak 'n Shake, and it's getting its own custom menu, menu item, and ordering/serving configuration says to me that they're probably putting their best foot forward on this location. Rejoice, New York, you're getting one of the good ones!

That all said, in my opinion, even the best Steak 'n Shake I've had didn't top an animal-style Double Double from In-N-Out or a burger from P. Terry's in Austin in the pantheon of best fast food burgers I've ever eaten. If the NYC Steak 'n Shake is getting the California Steakburger on its menu though, SNS does at least have a reasonable approximation of the tangy flavor profile of an animal-style In-N-Out burger, if there are any homesick West Coasters out there.

And oh yeah, the holiday seasonal white chocolate shake, and the fries are indeed probably the most forgettable item they serve this side of the cottage cheese side item.

From Slice

Is This The Only Neapolitan-style Buffalo Chicken Pie In The World?

"Is This The Only Neapolitan-style Buffalo Chicken Pie In The World?"

Possibly not full VPN, but close:
http://www.peelpizza.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=48
Buffalo
Wood fired chicken, house buffalo sauce, mozzarella, gorgonzola, finished with ranch and celery. $10.99

From Drinks

Taste Test: Grape Soda

I'm from St. Louis and I actually love Fitz's grape soda -- Fitz's is definitely primarily known for their root beer, but I always thought that their grape soda was sort of under-recognized. I'd wager that I like it for much the same reasons that I like their root beer so much versus other craft root beers: pleasant carbonation, not too sweet, not too syrupy, cane sugar, very drinkable.

The Red Ribbon sounds interesting. I should give it a go if I see it.

See more comments by esseelig »

Recent Posts

esseelig hasn't written a post yet.

Recent Favorites

From A Hamburger Today

Steak and Shake Coming to NYC in Midtown

From Recipes

Chocolate Chip Cookies

See more favorites by esseelig »

Recent Polls

From Slice

esseelig answered "Crisp and curl" to Should pepperoni crisp and curl or lie flat?

From Slice

esseelig answered "Yes. Always" to Do you get the reheat on your slice?

From A Hamburger Today

esseelig answered "No way, and I don't know anyone else who does that." to Do You Eat Burgers Around the Periphery Towards the Center?

From Slice

esseelig answered "Pizza!" to Deep dish: "pizza" or "casserole"?

Recent Quizzes

esseelig hasn't taken any quizzes yet.

See more polls and quizzes by esseelig »

Recent Comments

From A Hamburger Today

New York's First Steak 'n Shake Opens Tomorrow

Wait, I forgot a line there, the seasonal white chocolate shakes are wonderful while they last. It's just the fries (and cottage cheese) that are forgettable.

At their full-menu locations at least, they do have a "Wisconsin Buttery Steakburger" (as well as the In-N-Out-style California one, a barbecue one, a Fritos-chili cheese one, some sort of avocado one last I checked, etc. etc.)

From A Hamburger Today

New York's First Steak 'n Shake Opens Tomorrow

Here's the detail that everyone is missing, and this is me saying this as a resident of St. Louis, which has either the second or first highest concentration of Steak 'n Shakes in the country (that's right Indianapolis, you have competition): the quality of Steak 'n Shakes varies entirely by location. I've had so-so SNS, I've had "pretty good" SNS, and I've had absolutely sublime SNS. It always feels like some locations care about getting it right, and some are just slinging burgers out the drive-through window. Midwesterners, choose your location with care. (For what it's worth, the best Steak 'n Shake I've ever eaten in the St. Louis area was way out west in Wentzville. I wouldn't make a field trip for it, but if you're in the neighborhood, definitely worth a stop.)

That this is the first NYC Steak 'n Shake, and it's getting its own custom menu, menu item, and ordering/serving configuration says to me that they're probably putting their best foot forward on this location. Rejoice, New York, you're getting one of the good ones!

That all said, in my opinion, even the best Steak 'n Shake I've had didn't top an animal-style Double Double from In-N-Out or a burger from P. Terry's in Austin in the pantheon of best fast food burgers I've ever eaten. If the NYC Steak 'n Shake is getting the California Steakburger on its menu though, SNS does at least have a reasonable approximation of the tangy flavor profile of an animal-style In-N-Out burger, if there are any homesick West Coasters out there.

And oh yeah, the holiday seasonal white chocolate shake, and the fries are indeed probably the most forgettable item they serve this side of the cottage cheese side item.

From Slice

Is This The Only Neapolitan-style Buffalo Chicken Pie In The World?

"Is This The Only Neapolitan-style Buffalo Chicken Pie In The World?"

Possibly not full VPN, but close:
http://www.peelpizza.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=48
Buffalo
Wood fired chicken, house buffalo sauce, mozzarella, gorgonzola, finished with ranch and celery. $10.99

From Drinks

Taste Test: Grape Soda

I'm from St. Louis and I actually love Fitz's grape soda -- Fitz's is definitely primarily known for their root beer, but I always thought that their grape soda was sort of under-recognized. I'd wager that I like it for much the same reasons that I like their root beer so much versus other craft root beers: pleasant carbonation, not too sweet, not too syrupy, cane sugar, very drinkable.

The Red Ribbon sounds interesting. I should give it a go if I see it.

From Recipes

The In-N-Out/Telway/White Manna Ultimate Animal-Style Slider Mashup

Kenji, this is some sick, twisted alchemy you're pulling here, and I love it.

From A Hamburger Today

Steak and Shake Coming to NYC in Midtown

PuckOTG22, if you ever plan to eat a Frisco Melt again, I implore you not to look up its nutrition facts online. Or if you have any recurring heart/health issues, I implore you to look up the Frisco Melt nutrition facts immediately.

From Chicago

Chicago Essential: Extra Sauce and Extra Cheese Make Pequod's Extra Awesome

I actually went to Pequod's on the 27th without knowing that this had been posted. As with when I went there last year, truly one of my favorite pizzas I've ever had. "Tomato explosion" is a great way to put it -- every component of the pizza is great, but the taste of cooked-down rich, fresh, vividly red tomato is really a strong aspect of it. The caramelized-cheese crust really is kind of an ingenious way to get some flavorful crispness to the crust without cooking it too stiff, or getting the coarseness of adding cornmeal. Before I'd gone to Pequod's, I never really "got" Chicago-style pizza, but eating Pequod's was like flipping a light switch on.

@steamsoldier
I just came back from being in Chicago for 3 days. I ate exactly two deep dish sausage pizzas while there: Lou Malnati's, and Pequod's. The Lou Malnati's was very good, no doubt, but the Pequod's is an eminently, eminently eatable pizza. You would have a pleasant memory of Lou's, but you would have continuing haunting memories of how great Pequod's is.

From Slice

The Corner Slice: The Best Slice on Eighth Between 30th and 31st

Not going to lie, that photo of the Amadeus pizza -- were that pizza sold as a crustless rectangle rather than a standard slice, it was be an absolute dead ringer for the cheese pizza that we were given at my Midwestern grade school cafeteria. I'm just saying.

From A Hamburger Today

St. Louis: Carl's Drive In

I love Carl's! I actually have mostly replicated it (and learned how to do so from Serious Eats at some point). The trick to the crispy edges is to start with a ball of ground beef slightly larger than a golf ball, pan-fry the intact ball on one side so that it holds together, then flip it over, and then smash it flat so that the edges can crisp up without the center falling apart. Minute on one side, minute on the other, you're set.

From Slice

Farotto's, St. Louis: Thin, Sweet, and Provel'd

"Why is it every time slice goes to St. Louis, they go to the worst places in the city?"

Seriously. With the tendency towards Neapolitan-style here, where's Peel, Good Pie, Tivoli, or Laganini? If someone really has to do St. Louis-style, at least hit Guido's, Fortel's, Frank & Helen's, or one of the homey rectangular baking pan places, am I right?

From Slice

Watch the Toppings Move on This Strange Chinese Pizza

Katsuobushi always gives people pause the first time. It's tasty, though! I'd easily eat a pizza with it.

From Chicago

It's All About the Sauce at Chicago's Revolution Brewing

I tried this place last September! I got a burger and got to try a bit of the arugula pizza, and both were fantastic, among the best food that I had during a week's worth of good Chicago food.

From Sweets

SE Staff Picks: Our Favorite Chocolate Things

I also really miss creme brulee-flavored Pocky at my local grocers. Does Glico still make that flavor?

From Serious Eats

The Search For America's Best Hot Dog: The Midwest

Didn't even need to check the caption to know where the opening photo was from. I've got a photo from Hot Doug's that looks almost just like this, except I didn't get the foie dog. I was trying to think if St. Louis would have anything major to add the national/Midwest hot dog pantheon, and at first I couldn't think of much, but then I realized, oh! Iron Barley's Monte Christo Dog.

From A Hamburger Today

The Slider Scale

That dip for the single-patty, diner-style burger is entirely unwarranted :(

From Serious Eats

Seriously Delicious Super Bowl Party Giveaway: Baby Back Ribs and Pulled Pork

I would enter, but it hardly seems fair when I can drive thirty minutes and eat the contents of both of the pictures above, both of which I can verify to be absolutely fantastic. Even if you lose, if the shipping isn't too high, for the curious, I would highly recommend buying a bottle or two of their lighter, mustard/apple cider-based barbecue sauce. I usually hate mustard-based barbecue sauces, and I find this stuff downright addictive.

From A Hamburger Today

Reality Check: Burger King's Jalapeño and Cheddar BK Stuffed Steakhouse

Whelp, I think that the whole stuffed/speckled burger thing that I'm seeing out of BK and grocery stores is just a cop-out way to hop on the Jucy Lucy bandwagon. Bite the bullet and make a blasted Jucy Lucy or don't fiddle with this "stuffed burger" stuff at all!

From Serious Eats

Photos from International Serious Eats Day

There was one in St. Louis and I didn't know about it? :'( Revolution Brewing is really awesome too, I loved both the burger and the pizza I had there last year...

From Slice

San Francisco: Deep Dish Worth the Wait at Little Star

Lest anyone forget, Little Star also was the source of the pizza recipes for Pi pizzeria in St. Louis, President Obama's favorite pizza in the entire country. The Pi and Little Star pies are reportedly still pretty close to one another, cornmeal crust and all. A Chicago politician loving Chicago-style deep dish pizza made in St. Louis created from Little Star's recipes in San Francisco. Madness, innit?

From Slice

The United States of Pizza: Illinois (Beyond Chicago Edition)

I hear good Neapolitan-style things about Peel in Edwardsville, IL.

From Slice

Poll: Eggs on Pizza - Way or No Way?

There's something to be said for simplicity in pizza, so you don't always NEED an egg, but if you're up for an unhealthiness splurge, a well-cooked egg on a well-cooked pizza is exquisite.

From Slice

Thai Pizza Co in St. Louis: Testing the Universality of Pizza

Okay, lifelong U. City resident and former WU student here -- I can settle a few of the questions. For the "space that formerly ______" question, Thai Pizza Co. is in the space that formerly held another Prapaisilapa Thai restaurant, Thai Seafood Cafe.

As for introducing Thai food to St. Louis, as I look at the website, I think that it's the phrasing that's key here, since they don't explicitly say that they had the first Thai restaurant in St. Louis. I know for a fact that there was a good but short-lived Thai restaurant also in the U. City area called Thai Town on Olive Blvd. in the eighties. With the longevity of the Prapaisilapa restaurants though, it probably is fair to say that Thai Cafe and Thai Country Cafe have probably been more successful at introducing Thai food to St. Louis, as they were pretty much contemporary with the Loop's escalation in popularity. I would imagine that The King & I on South Grand has probably been around since the '80s (or maybe even '70s?) as well.

I've been to Thai Pizza numerous times since it opened, and my findings have pretty much been this: next to falafel wraps from Al-Tarboush, the pizzas from here were always one of the best food deals in the Loop (I think that the 9" pizzas used to be either $6 or $7, but pretty much every restaurant has raised their prices in the last 2 years). The thin crusts always seemed pretty filling, so to get the thick crust was basically total overkill (and yes, since their crusts are lacking for flavor a bit, it's usually best to stick to the thin).

I enjoy Thai curries quite a bit, but every time that I've tried a curry pizza from here, the curry flavor does get lost between the crust and the cheese combo. On the other hand, as a few people mention above, their chicken satay pizza has never let me down, always quite flavorful.

Incidentally, for all cultural fusion pizza superfans, I just had some really good gyro/tzatziki pizza in St. Louis from Anthonino's, a Greek/Italian restaurant on the Hill.

See more comments by esseelig »

Recent Posts

esseelig hasn't written a post yet.

Recent Favorites

From A Hamburger Today

Steak and Shake Coming to NYC in Midtown

From Recipes

Chocolate Chip Cookies

See more favorites by esseelig »

Polls

From Slice

esseelig answered "Crisp and curl" to Should pepperoni crisp and curl or lie flat?

From Slice

esseelig answered "Yes. Always" to Do you get the reheat on your slice?

From A Hamburger Today

esseelig answered "No way, and I don't know anyone else who does that." to Do You Eat Burgers Around the Periphery Towards the Center?

From Slice

esseelig answered "Pizza!" to Deep dish: "pizza" or "casserole"?

From Slice

esseelig answered "Way!" to Egg pizza: Way or No Way?

See more polls by esseelig »

Quizzes

About esseelig

Website:

Location:

About:

Favorite foods:

Last bite on earth: