esseelig’s Profile
Recent Comments
New York's First Steak 'n Shake Opens Tomorrow
Here's the detail that everyone is missing, and this is me saying this as a resident of St. Louis, which has either the second or first highest concentration of Steak 'n Shakes in the country (that's right Indianapolis, you have competition): the quality of Steak 'n Shakes varies entirely by location. I've had so-so SNS, I've had "pretty good" SNS, and I've had absolutely sublime SNS. It always feels like some locations care about getting it right, and some are just slinging burgers out the drive-through window. Midwesterners, choose your location with care. (For what it's worth, the best Steak 'n Shake I've ever eaten in the St. Louis area was way out west in Wentzville. I wouldn't make a field trip for it, but if you're in the neighborhood, definitely worth a stop.)
That this is the first NYC Steak 'n Shake, and it's getting its own custom menu, menu item, and ordering/serving configuration says to me that they're probably putting their best foot forward on this location. Rejoice, New York, you're getting one of the good ones!
That all said, in my opinion, even the best Steak 'n Shake I've had didn't top an animal-style Double Double from In-N-Out or a burger from P. Terry's in Austin in the pantheon of best fast food burgers I've ever eaten. If the NYC Steak 'n Shake is getting the California Steakburger on its menu though, SNS does at least have a reasonable approximation of the tangy flavor profile of an animal-style In-N-Out burger, if there are any homesick West Coasters out there.
And oh yeah, the holiday seasonal white chocolate shake, and the fries are indeed probably the most forgettable item they serve this side of the cottage cheese side item.
Is This The Only Neapolitan-style Buffalo Chicken Pie In The World?
"Is This The Only Neapolitan-style Buffalo Chicken Pie In The World?"
Possibly not full VPN, but close:
http://www.peelpizza.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=48
Buffalo
Wood fired chicken, house buffalo sauce, mozzarella, gorgonzola, finished with ranch and celery. $10.99
Taste Test: Grape Soda
I'm from St. Louis and I actually love Fitz's grape soda -- Fitz's is definitely primarily known for their root beer, but I always thought that their grape soda was sort of under-recognized. I'd wager that I like it for much the same reasons that I like their root beer so much versus other craft root beers: pleasant carbonation, not too sweet, not too syrupy, cane sugar, very drinkable.
The Red Ribbon sounds interesting. I should give it a go if I see it.
See more comments by esseelig »
Recent Posts
esseelig hasn't written a post yet.
Recent Favorites
See more favorites by esseelig »
Recent Polls
esseelig answered "Crisp and curl" to Should pepperoni crisp and curl or lie flat?
esseelig answered "Yes. Always" to Do you get the reheat on your slice?
esseelig answered "No way, and I don't know anyone else who does that." to Do You Eat Burgers Around the Periphery Towards the Center?
esseelig answered "Pizza!" to Deep dish: "pizza" or "casserole"?
Recent Quizzes
esseelig hasn't taken any quizzes yet.

Wait, I forgot a line there, the seasonal white chocolate shakes are wonderful while they last. It's just the fries (and cottage cheese) that are forgettable.
At their full-menu locations at least, they do have a "Wisconsin Buttery Steakburger" (as well as the In-N-Out-style California one, a barbecue one, a Fritos-chili cheese one, some sort of avocado one last I checked, etc. etc.)