egadman’s Profile

Recent Comments

From Slice

Dear Slice: 'Barring Di Fara, Where Should I Go for Pizza on My NYC Visit?'

Lombardi's. Do it. It won't disappoint. Can't get pizza like that virtually anywhere outside of NYC.

Motorino's fantastic, but good neapolitan-esque pizzas aren't too hard to find these days.

Co. ... eh. I don't get what the fuss is about. It's good, but not great in my book.

From Slice

Pizza Madness 2009: I Left My Heartburn in San Francisco

I was just in SF this weekend and did a Delfina Vs. Tony's head-to-head. My Delfina margherita easily came out on top, with a perfectly baked crust—crisp, yet pliant with the edge revealing soft spongy innards—sweet and tang-tastic sauce, and a drizzle of fragrant olive oil. Tony's margherita was good, but the sauce lacked the flavorful punch of Delfina's and the cheese was not entirely melted. It did benefit from the added smokiness from wood-burning oven. Extra kudos to Tony's for being open for lunch.

I also tried the clam pie at Delfina and Tony's Cal Italia (Asiago, Mozzarella, Imported Italian Gorgonzola, Sweet Fig preserve from Croatia, Prosciutto di Parma, Parmigiano, Balsamic). Both were delicious. The Cal Italia is baked in a domed, gas oven, and uses a different flour (higher gluten content, it seemed) than their margherita. It was overpowered by the sweet fig to some degree, which was heavy-handedly dolloped into the center of each slice, with a small piece of prosciutto and a couple shavings of the parmigiano stuck on top. The gorgonzola was used sparingly and counterbalanced the sweet figs with its bitterness. It was pretty delicious, but maybe too rich and I had a hard time getting through my third slice.

Delfina's clam pie was fantastic, with toothsome shelled clams scattered about on a sea of spiced tomato sauce. All underscored by a salty pecorino.

I also tried a slice from Arnell's Pizza, which would give most NYC corner slice establishments a run for their money. A thin, crisp crust, topped with your standard greasy, cheesy fair. A good sauce-to-cheese ratio. And served up by a gentleman with a slightly toothless grin.

... I second the motion to hit up the Bi-Rite Creamery after—or before!—hitting up Delfina. I sampled their salted caramel and malted vanilla. A+ in my book. I also had the pleasure of tasting Humphry Slocombe's off-kilter ice cream flavors: secret breakfast (bourbon and cornflakes), peanut butter curry, blue bottle coffee, and balsamic caramel. Victory for the forces of good!

From Slice

Pizzeria Gialina and a Summer of Super Slices in San Francisco

this review comes not a moment too soon, for i head to the bay area this weekend for four (4!) days of pizza pleasure. tony's was top of my list, but i'll have to look into this gialina business. the atomica looks amazing.

pizzeria picco looks great, but i probably won't be able to get out to it, as i'll be sans automobile.

my two cents on A16, which i was able to get to a couple of months ago: hugely disappointing. after all the praise i'd read about it here i had pretty high expectations, but i found the margherita was only pretty good—pros were the lightly seasoned sauce and nice blistered edges. cons: too soupy in the middle, completely flavorless crust. i also had their funghi. the funghi's crust was also not just insipid, but dry (i'm like goldilocks... too soupy, too dry—i'm just missing the third one) and kind of tough in that jaw-exhausting, difficult-to-bite-through way. maybe it was just an off night, but given the hectic environment and the wait for a table, i'm disinclined to give it another shot.

See more comments by egadman »

Recent Posts

egadman hasn't written a post yet.

Recent Favorites

egadman hasn't favorited a post yet.

Recent Polls

egadman hasn't answered any polls yet.

Recent Quizzes

egadman hasn't taken any quizzes yet.

Recent Comments | Response to Comments

From Slice

Dear Slice: 'Barring Di Fara, Where Should I Go for Pizza on My NYC Visit?'

Lombardi's. Do it. It won't disappoint. Can't get pizza like that virtually anywhere outside of NYC.

Motorino's fantastic, but good neapolitan-esque pizzas aren't too hard to find these days.

Co. ... eh. I don't get what the fuss is about. It's good, but not great in my book.

From Slice

Pizza Madness 2009: I Left My Heartburn in San Francisco

I was just in SF this weekend and did a Delfina Vs. Tony's head-to-head. My Delfina margherita easily came out on top, with a perfectly baked crust—crisp, yet pliant with the edge revealing soft spongy innards—sweet and tang-tastic sauce, and a drizzle of fragrant olive oil. Tony's margherita was good, but the sauce lacked the flavorful punch of Delfina's and the cheese was not entirely melted. It did benefit from the added smokiness from wood-burning oven. Extra kudos to Tony's for being open for lunch.

I also tried the clam pie at Delfina and Tony's Cal Italia (Asiago, Mozzarella, Imported Italian Gorgonzola, Sweet Fig preserve from Croatia, Prosciutto di Parma, Parmigiano, Balsamic). Both were delicious. The Cal Italia is baked in a domed, gas oven, and uses a different flour (higher gluten content, it seemed) than their margherita. It was overpowered by the sweet fig to some degree, which was heavy-handedly dolloped into the center of each slice, with a small piece of prosciutto and a couple shavings of the parmigiano stuck on top. The gorgonzola was used sparingly and counterbalanced the sweet figs with its bitterness. It was pretty delicious, but maybe too rich and I had a hard time getting through my third slice.

Delfina's clam pie was fantastic, with toothsome shelled clams scattered about on a sea of spiced tomato sauce. All underscored by a salty pecorino.

I also tried a slice from Arnell's Pizza, which would give most NYC corner slice establishments a run for their money. A thin, crisp crust, topped with your standard greasy, cheesy fair. A good sauce-to-cheese ratio. And served up by a gentleman with a slightly toothless grin.

... I second the motion to hit up the Bi-Rite Creamery after—or before!—hitting up Delfina. I sampled their salted caramel and malted vanilla. A+ in my book. I also had the pleasure of tasting Humphry Slocombe's off-kilter ice cream flavors: secret breakfast (bourbon and cornflakes), peanut butter curry, blue bottle coffee, and balsamic caramel. Victory for the forces of good!

From Slice

Pizzeria Gialina and a Summer of Super Slices in San Francisco

this review comes not a moment too soon, for i head to the bay area this weekend for four (4!) days of pizza pleasure. tony's was top of my list, but i'll have to look into this gialina business. the atomica looks amazing.

pizzeria picco looks great, but i probably won't be able to get out to it, as i'll be sans automobile.

my two cents on A16, which i was able to get to a couple of months ago: hugely disappointing. after all the praise i'd read about it here i had pretty high expectations, but i found the margherita was only pretty good—pros were the lightly seasoned sauce and nice blistered edges. cons: too soupy in the middle, completely flavorless crust. i also had their funghi. the funghi's crust was also not just insipid, but dry (i'm like goldilocks... too soupy, too dry—i'm just missing the third one) and kind of tough in that jaw-exhausting, difficult-to-bite-through way. maybe it was just an off night, but given the hectic environment and the wait for a table, i'm disinclined to give it another shot.

From Slice

Portland, Oregon: Apizza Scholls

the last time i was at scholls was in march. i had a barfday gathering. we had a reservation, but still ended up waiting for a little over an hour, which given the circumstances wasn't so bad—our group ballooned from 9 people to about 16, which was technically over the limit for a reservation. the servers seemed somewhat nonplussed by the size of the group, especially since the place was already jam-packed with customers. the pizza was great though.

the waits are somewhat prohibitive on the weekends though, and i haven't actually been back since then... which i am ashamed of... this will have to be remedied.

From Slice

Openings: Paulie Gee's, Greenpoint, Brooklyn

if everything goes as planed, i will meet your pizzas in january.

best of luck to you!

From Slice

Street Food Profiles: Wy'east Pizza, Portland, Oregon

hands-down they are the nicest people in pizza. and their pizza is great too!

From Slice

Portland, Oregon: Ken's Artisan Pizza

@pizzafreak & L.A. Pizza Maven

Far be it from me to invite myself to a gathering, but if y'all are looking for a Tour du Portland Pizza and want a third wheel, I'm always down for Ken's, and I can help guide you to the city's other char-y hot spots.

wifain gmail.com

From Slice

Portland, Oregon: Ken's Artisan Pizza

fennel! i'd guessed a little bit of anise, but fennel makes more sense for some reason... maybe it's the association of fennel sausage w/pizza.

for those who end up swinging through PDX, ken's is the place to go. scholl's is quality, but ken's crust puts it over the edge. to by-pass the crowds, i generally swing in on a week night and get a margherita and root beer to go and have curb-side feast across the street.

From Talk

Which pizza stone should I buy?

my guess is that you'd be fine with most any baking stone on the market as long as you let it sit for 45 minutes or so to heat up.

i use a stone that's about a 1/2" thick, and if i'm baking one or two pies, it's fine. when i end up baking more, i place few clay bricks on the rack below to hold heat. this vastly reduces any time i would be need to wait for my oven to reheat after baking the first two.

From Slice

Nomad Pizza Co.: Notes from the Field

that charring pattern is totally appetizing.

From Slice

A16, San Francisco

my A16 experience was less than stellar. the crust was just bland. dead in the flavor department. toppings were pretty good, but the funghi was too dry, and the crust on that one was also tough getting near the edges. as a man who generally just can't help himself from cleaning up the table when it comes to food scraps—especially pizza—i couldn't bring myself to finish it.

there seem to be plenty of other pizzerias in SF to head to these days. pizza nostra, delfina, gialina, and the new one with every variety of pizza known to man on the menu...

From Slice

Bicycle That's a Combination Beer Hall, Pizza Delivery Vehicle, and DJ Booth

it's a wicked idea. too bad their pizza blows. wouldn't even pass muster as a corner slice.... on the other hand their beer is phenomenal. their root beer is also nothing to scoff at.

they should've hired me. i could've made 'em pizza champions.

From Slice

If I Could Only Eat at One NYC Pizzeria (Other Than Di Fara), What Would It Be?

Lombardi's or Grimaldi's are always safe bets in my book. Yeah, they aren't exactly secrets and there's often a bit of a wait, but there's a reason for that. The pizzas are top notch. And at Lombardi's you get to eat a little bit of American pizza history.

From Slice

Opportunity Knocks, My Friends

"weaving a killer net of blogs"

"hitting homeruns with SEO"

i hate job descriptions that try and make things sound exciting by adding ridiculous qualifiers and metaphors. at least they avoided the dreaded "rock star" label (e.g., "looking for an EXPERIENCED, ROCK STAR LINE COOK"). also—and as someone who isn't punctuating or capitalizing correctly, i understand i'm sitting in a glass house right now—shouldn't "homeruns" be two words?

From Slice

Frank Bruni on the Great Artisanal Pizza Boom

i guess it's diff'rent strokes for diff'rent folks or just how the random sampling turns out. or both! either way, i'd be happy to have any of the pizzerias Bruni wrote about in my neighborhood. sadly, my neighborhood is 3000 miles away.

From Slice

Frank Bruni on the Great Artisanal Pizza Boom

I generally agree with pretty much everything Bruni wrote in this article concerning the pizzerias I've visited. Kesté turns out a fine pizza, but it's not great. Mine, at least, was too heavily topped with both sauce and cheese. UPN's pizzas are like the freakin' platonic ideal of a neapolitan pie. Yes, they're wet. But they aren't overly topped. They're balanced and remarkably delicious.

From Slice

Is It a 'Plain' Slice, a 'Regular' Slice, or Something Else Entirely?

depending on what's waiting in the window, i always qualify my order. normally it's "a slice of plain" sometimes "cheese" or "regular" slips out, but then i almost always get two slices with the second one being a pepperoni slice, so distinguishing what i want seems appropriate.

when ordering a whole pie i used to say "plain pie" or "plain pizza," but since i now pretty much solely frequent places that have "Margherita" specified on the menu, that's what i say.

From Slice

Stephen Starr's Philadelphia Pizzeria to Be 'Brooklyn-Style'

"thick, doughy pizza?" maybe he's confusing Brooklyn with Chicago? or maybe square slices, which i do not believe is a style that originated Brooklyn. i'd like to know what the sources are for his research...

From Slice

Slice Poll: How Often Do You Eat Pizza?

it so depends on the week. there are some weeks when i don't eat pizza at all and then some weeks when i'll eat it four or five times (especially when i make my own). also, this doesn't really take into account how much pizza one consumes, e.g., someone who has a slice six days a week still eats roughly the same amount of pizza I eat in one sitting.

From Slice

Pizzeria Mozza Just About as Good As You've Heard

does anyone know what the wait tends to be like around lunch time? i'll be in LA in a few weeks and i was hoping to drop in with a couple of friends. i personally don't mind waiting two hours for some amazing pizza, but i don't want to subject my not-so-pizza-obsessed friends to such things.

From Slice

What's the Longest Wait You've Had at Di Fara?

a couple summers ago i clocked my wait at just under 2 hours and 30 minutes, give or take a couple minutes. a couple of friends and i got there at around 12:30 and we got our pizza around 3pm. i had my order in a few minutes after joining the scrum. somehow our order was forgotten about. these things happen.

di fara's has hands-down the best pepperoni ever.

From Slice

Kenji Alt's Homemade Pizza Hack

My oven only has a top element and I set it on the high broil setting (which I'm guessing is about 550-600). So far with the stone, placed in the middle of the oven, I've had some pretty good luck. I've tried placing it higher, but I because of the heating element being above, the tops of my pizzas would cook faster than the bottom and I'd end up with a burnt edge and caramelized cheese and a blonde bottom.

With the stone at mid-level, I used to have a kind of double-bake process where I'd bake the crust with the sauce first, just til it's blonde, then top it with the cheese, etc. As I found that because of the length of time my pizzas were in the oven (5-8 minutes), the cheese would burn before the crust was done. I remedied this by just placing larger, but fewer hunks of mozz.

I also found that by placing some tin foil on my other oven tray and putting it in the slot below my stone, I was able to essentially create a smaller oven space, which seems to help my stone retain or replenish its heat more quickly for quicker bake times and less wait between pies. As it is, I'm able to get a decent pie done in 4-5 minutes when my stone has absorbed its max amount of heat.

You can see the results here: http://egadman.blogspot.com/search?q=pizza

It's certainly not ideal, but i still like to claim status as the 3rd best pizza in PDX.

From Slice

Dear Slice: 'Barring Di Fara, Where Should I Go for Pizza on My NYC Visit?'

Thanks everyone for all your great feedback, Josh S. here. I will fully admit that I don't know the difference between Naples and Neapolitan so forgive me if I made things confusing. I had narrowed down the list to these 3 based upon proximity to other items that I will be nearby.

As I had mentioned I just don't think that Di Fara is truly and option for me. With my schedule it looks like the only day I could potentially make it, is Monday and well I know they aren't open on Monday or Tuesday.

Based upon everyones recommendations and comments I think I will be choosing Motorino for my choice of pie. While I am all for history, I will be more certainly impressed with the taste of the pie rather than the history. Depending on a couple of factors I might be able to make it to Lombardi's if anything for comparison and completeness.

From Slice

Dear Slice: 'Barring Di Fara, Where Should I Go for Pizza on My NYC Visit?'

Sorry, when I made my post about Luzzo's I was under the impression that he was going to three pizzerias, not just one.

If you're going to just one of those three I don't think it is a question, Motorino is the best. Only question is Manhattan/Williamsburg location, idk, has there been any consensus on which is better or are they pretty much the same?

Di Fara is definitely worth the trip but he already said he doesn't have time for that. Although if he did that would be the place to go.

From Slice

Pizza Madness 2009: I Left My Heartburn in San Francisco

Thanks for the write-up. I'll be in the bay area on Saturday.

From Slice

Dear Slice: 'Barring Di Fara, Where Should I Go for Pizza on My NYC Visit?'

I'd have to agree with Sean. The DiFara experience is worth the trip. DiFara's probably isn't my favorite pizza (here I go - not succumbing to 'groupthink'), but Dom is probably my favorite pizzaiolo.

And when you tell people you had pizza in New York and someone raises the eyebrow and asks, "but did you go to DiFara?" your response can be a Gary-Cooperish "yup."

From Slice

Dear Slice: 'Barring Di Fara, Where Should I Go for Pizza on My NYC Visit?'

Go to Di Fara. The way you phrased your question it seems like Di Fara is your #1 choice.

Co., Motorino, and Lombardi's are all likely to be there when you return but I wish I could say the same for Di Fara. Make it work. Go at an off-peak time (late lunch before they close to prepare for dinner). It's 40 minutes from Times Sq by subway. Otherwise you'll come and likely enjoy any number of great pizzerias but you won't have been to Di Fara. If you have time for a second choice, then consider those others, but if I were you, I'd pay a visit to Dom.

Hope you like NY!

From Slice

Dear Slice: 'Barring Di Fara, Where Should I Go for Pizza on My NYC Visit?'

Pizzasnob: No need to apologize. I didn't take it as a flame! I think you were right on about what you said. As for Luzzo's, that one, I've come to learn over the years, is a love it–don't get it situation and probably does come down to the crispness/thinness issues you mention.

From Slice

Dear Slice: 'Barring Di Fara, Where Should I Go for Pizza on My NYC Visit?'

btw - just re-read my post. might have come off more critical than i thought - no flame intended (but this pun? for sure!). sorry bro.

anyhow - i thought i'd branch out from his list to give him more options.

From Slice

Dear Slice: 'Barring Di Fara, Where Should I Go for Pizza on My NYC Visit?'

@pizzasnob: We'll have to agree to disagree here on Motorino-Luzzo. That's fine. Just wanted to jump in here re Lombardi's. I would in no way recommend it above Patsy's (East Harlem), Totonno's, etc., but, as I pointed out, given Josh's list above, that's what I had to work with. If he wanted to do coal-oven and time/travel were not a factor, I'd send him to Patsy's or Totonno's Coney (if it were open). I haven't been to Totonno's UES in a while so can't vouch, but Totonno's 26th/2nd was not worth sending someone to. I'd go to John's Bleecker Street or Arturo's before Totonno's 26th.

Artichoke on square might actually be a good suggestion for a taste of Di Fara.

From Slice

Dear Slice: 'Barring Di Fara, Where Should I Go for Pizza on My NYC Visit?'

i've always had the exact opposite sentiment with adam's luzzo-motorino comparison - even did a same-afternoon comparison on my birthday, and the general consensus definitely prefered luzzo overall. i can't exactly pinpoint why i do; i like its thinner crust style better.

as for the new york coal-oven - lombardi's? really? i'd happily take the original patsy's or possibly even one of the chain locations of patsy's or angelo's over it. I'd take grimaldi's over it, even if their inconsistent pies and tourist trap line get worse every year. i guess it works as a good tourist location due to its proximity to the brooklyn bridge. I'd take nick's and totonno's UES locations over it. ever since i first went to lombardi's in '02, i've always been underwhelmed by its hype--although i've always appreciated its history.

artichoke basille's may be overrated, but i believe their proximity to union square helps those that want to see what di fara's is like. "wha?!", you say? well, my fave di fara offering is his square slice, and i think the basille boys' square slice at least gives a hint to the uninitiated what dom's work may taste like without having to make a three hour minimum trip. it's not the same, but the cost/benefit ratio can be helpful to a tourist with a tight schedule. just don't bother with the artichoke slice.

From Slice

Openings: Paulie Gee's, Greenpoint, Brooklyn

Thanks very much for the kind word and support Za Man. I'm lookin' forward to having you stop in.

Ciao,

Paulie Gee

From Slice

Openings: Paulie Gee's, Greenpoint, Brooklyn

good luck paulie i have followed you on slice and flicker . the pictures of the pizzerias you visit are sensational. you are going to do great, i am looking forward to your opening. you can make a living and maintain the love of your craft. keep it simple and honest the public will get it .

From Slice

If I Could Only Eat at One NYC Pizzeria (Other Than Di Fara), What Would It Be?

If you haven't already left NYC, I recommend a place called Italia Pizza in the Bensonhurst/Gravesend area of Brooklyn. Like Di Fara, it is located on a street corner, but obviously not the same one. It's a family owned shop. Their ovens are made of steel as well. That's where the similarities end though. At Di Fara's, Dom is the only one making the pies. Not the case here, but it is still a great slice. Nor, do they finish the pie with fresh basil, oil, or more cheese. While Di Fara's looks like a hole in the wall pizza joint, the decor at Italia is much more modern and updated. You can get a regular slice, along with both, Sicilian and grandma slices. If I remember correctly, their hours are from 11/11:30AM to the earliest closing around 10PM.
If you're willing to trek out there, this place is on Kings Highway and West 6TH Street. To get there, you take the N train to Kings Highway in Brooklyn. If you are coming in from Manhattan, you would have to be in, or near the last car. From there, once you are out of the station, make a right, that corner would be Kings Highway and West 7TH Street. Walk down one more block, and you will find yourself on the diagonal corner of the restaurant. Their Sicilian slices are good, but grandma slices are phenomenal, if you like thin, crispy crusts for your slices. I usually get the grandma slices for $2.50.
Other than Di Fara's, that is the only pizzeria I would go out of my way for.

From Slice

Portland, Oregon: Ken's Artisan Pizza

I think that Ken's has a nice blend of the Neapolitan style with the bold American palate. Honestly, on pizzas like the margarita, I think the sauce tends to be too much and overpower the crust and cheese. It's when you put some spicy sausage and peppers on it that it works best (though then the crust begins to disappear). That's why it's my third favorite in Portland behind Scholls and Nostrana. I think those tend to be more balanced -- though all three have great ingredients and execution.

@LA Maven
You keep threatening to come up here and eat some 'za yet never do. Put our pizza where your mouth is. ;-) And email me if you do make your way.

From Slice

Portland, Oregon: Apizza Scholls

Unfortunately, the best pie in Brian's repetoire hasn't been on the menu in a long time: the clams casino -- the bacon bianca with littlenecks in shell. Yeah, yeah, it'd be easier to eat if the clams weren't in the shell, but then they wouldn't release their essence to the top of the pie, which is what made it so fantastic. Here's the version Bourdain had when he came:

http://www.extramsg.com/albums/album600/boudain_at_apizza_25.sized.jpg

From Slice

Pizzeria Gialina and a Summer of Super Slices in San Francisco

Thanks brasciole...now I know what those things were...what they're doin on a pizza, I dont know but.....by the way, love your handle...in my younger daze I was seen once passin out from an overdose of home-made brasciole..had i died then, i wouldve died with a smile on my face...

From Slice

Pizzeria Gialina and a Summer of Super Slices in San Francisco

"Though I still am not sure exactly what a wild nettle is"

Most likely the leaves of young stinging nettles which are edible and quite nutritious when cooked.

From Slice

Openings: Paulie Gee's, Greenpoint, Brooklyn

congrats paulie G! i'll be sure to hit it up. can i bring my camera?

From Slice

Openings: Paulie Gee's, Greenpoint, Brooklyn

Bravo ! Go get 'em Paulie.

You have the passion motivatiion, and skills.

I WILL visit next time I'm in "Greenpernt".

From Slice

Openings: Paulie Gee's, Greenpoint, Brooklyn

Hey so what are you gonna call the place then?

From Slice

Openings: Paulie Gee's, Greenpoint, Brooklyn

Congrats from London, England. Hopefully next time I'm in NY you'll have opened successfully and started serving some of your beautiful pies.

From Slice

Openings: Paulie Gee's, Greenpoint, Brooklyn

My family and I will welcome you to the hood by coming at least once a month. Looking forward to some decent competition to Motorino and Fornino and one that's within walking distance from us!

From Slice

Openings: Paulie Gee's, Greenpoint, Brooklyn

Wonderful news indeed.

You are some lucky SOBs in Greenpoint.....although luck had nothing to do with it.

Paulie, you know where my feelings are, but congratulations again on a dream come true. Now, make sure the pie is on point when I come up there! :)

Recent Posts

egadman hasn't written a post yet.

Recent Favorites

egadman hasn't favorited a post yet.

Polls

egadman hasn't answered any polls yet.

Quizzes

egadman hasn't taken any quizzes yet.

About egadman

Website:

Location:

About:

Favorite foods:

Last bite on earth: