Checked this out yesterday and it's fantastic. I do agree that the burger needs to be done at medium because medium well (what they usually do) is just a little too far done. That doesn't mean it's not good I just agree that cooking it slightly less will make it a whole lot better. And the cupcake shakes are GREAT! Had a red velvet cupcake blended with vanilla ice cream.
just a heads up but there's one right across the hudson in jersey city so not necessarily in the state of ny but pretty damn close...it's about 5 minutes from the journal square PATH station
53rd and 6th is my personal favorite. Apparently the same for many people in the tri-state since a ridiculously long line could be found at midnight into the early morning hours
i just got back from there today and it is AMAZING
of all the flavors i liked the subtlety of the cereal milk the best. Fruity pebbles wasn't too bad either, but i like it simple