Tarallucci E Vino's croissants, not the cornetti; the French style croissants are buttery, dense and rich and are my absolute favorites. Silver Moon's plain or chocolate croissant. The almond croissant at Georgia's Bakeshop. Chocolate croissant at Madeleine Patisserie; the plain ones there are too airy.
Another update: Il Cantuccio is finally open on Christopher Street in the West Village and is selling pane toscana.
The Trade Fair in Astoria also had bunches of papalo for $1.99 each. And I believe La Guadalupe Fruit and Vegetable had it as well.
Update: I've finally found a place that bakes authentic saltless Tuscan bread. I was dining at Locanda Vini e Olii in Brooklyn this weekend when I was caught unawares and nibbled on a piece of the pasty, saltless bread without any condiment to give it flavor. I found out the restaurant gets their Tuscan loaf from Sette Pani, which has two locations: one is in Harlem at 196 Lenox Avenue at 120th Street and the other is in Brooklyn at 602 Lorimer Street.
@brk212: Thanks for tip--good to know. Italian groceries are really everywhere; no matter what neighborhood you live in, you can find a good supplier. Agata & Valentina sounds great. I like the warehouse feel of D. Collucio & Sons and also seeing the local Italian-Americans who go there and to the places on Arthur Avenue and are on a first name basis with the shopkeepers. Very Italian.
Ava McAlpin hasn't favorited a post yet.