Zach Brooks’s Profile
Recent Comments
Save Prime Burger, A Burger Shop With Real Character
Hey Nick... don't forget to mention you hated the french fried onions too!
See more comments by Zach Brooks »
Recent Posts
Fancy Restaurants Should Implement an Early 'Baby Seating'
Posted by Zach Brooks, March 23, 2009 at 3:00 PM
Can We Retire the Word 'Toothsome' Already?
Posted by Zach Brooks, January 22, 2009 at 4:04 PM
News Spread: Thanksgiving Blog; Kosher Hung; Buttermilk Channel
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 26, 2008 at 5:30 PM
Week in Reviews: Best Bites
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 26, 2008 at 10:00 AM
See more posts by Zach Brooks »
Recent Favorites
In Defense of Chef Chris Cosentino's Foie Gras
Posted by Erin Zimmer, March 9, 2009 at 12:45 PM
Food T-Shirts at Brooklyn Kitchen
Posted by Erin Zimmer, December 18, 2008 at 1:00 PM
See more favorites by Zach Brooks »
Recent Polls
Zach Brooks hasn't answered any polls yet.
Recent Quizzes
Zach Brooks hasn't taken any quizzes yet.
Recent Comments | Response to Comments
Why Mario's Closing the Enoteca at Del Posto
I've only eaten at the enoteca, so I can't compare it to the main dining room- but it sounded to me like it was about the kitchen, not the critics. The enoteca was a different menu, which also changed pretty often (daily?)... so my guess is they're getting rid of it so the chefs can devote more of their time and energy to the food on the regular menu.
Save Prime Burger, A Burger Shop With Real Character
Hey Nick... don't forget to mention you hated the french fried onions too!
Serious Eats Finds New York's Best Bagel
So basically the conclusion of this post should be "the best bagel in NYC is the one around the corner from your apartment."
Which is my case is the H&H Factory on 46th and the West Side Highway... every fresh/warm bagel I've ever had from that place has been beyond amazing.
Three Chinese Dishes, Five Dollars, One Lunch at Sushi Osaka
Don't get too excited Joe. These places are for those of us who can't travel out to Flushing (or even NYC Chinatown) for lunch on a weekday. I don't think I would travel *into* Midtown from Queens for this stuff...
When Is It Socially Acceptable to Share Food?
I can't for the life of me understand couples who order the same dish at a restaurant.
On TV Tonight: 'Nightline' Takes a Look at Rockstar Butchers
Any report on "Rockstar Butchers" that features Josh Ozersky, but leaves out Tom Mylan is a joke!
All You Need to Know About Di Fara, 2009
One more question (he asks as he imagines Adam's head exploding)...
Is there any place around there where, say, your wife and kid could go hang out for an hour or two near DiFara's while you wait in line, push your way to the counter, hold off locals, and snag your pizza...?
Snapshots from Greece: Loukoumades from Krinos in Athens
omg, those look amazing. so jealous of your entire trip!
Best Bites: RUB BBQ Burnt Ends
"Of course if you're fat-phobic you probably wouldn't have walked into RUB or any other barbecue joint in the first place."
It's actually shocking how many people say they "love" BBQ, only to cut the fat off their brisket. (It's shameful, I know!)
Recommendation for Conference Lunch in Midtown NYC Needed
Todai still exists, but it's called Ichi Umi now. It's a giant sushi buffet, and could probably easily accommodate your party if you book in advance.
Le Relais de Venise L’Entrecote: A Parisian Steakhouse Makes Its U.S. Debut
wtf. that looks *amazing*. definitely breaking the Midtown Lunch $10 price cap for this one...
Table 8: Inconsistent and Overpriced
haha... nice. well, if I held every restaurant to the standard of a Midtown Lunch- I would hate Momofuku for being wildly overpriced! (And you know that is not the case.) It's all about expectations...
but yeah, as far as Table 8 goes it's pretty clear we just got super lucky with what we ordered. i don't doubt that most of the dishes you ate might have been overpriced or too small for the price, or just not tasty. RG echoed much of what you said, although it sounded like Platt hated it more because of the *type* of place it was rather than specific dishes being bad. but all this just proves how visceral eating out is. We were there on a Saturday night, prime time, and the place was loud and hopping. (And possibly firing on all cylinders?)
we started with two items from the salt bar that were both excellent, and downright cheap for the portion. (the foie gras and lamb terrine) i haven't read anything bad about either. so in our minds, the meal not only started off great- but it seemed like a bargain.
we also ordered two of their cocktails, which were really awesome (something that RG and I did agree with.) One was a gin mojito that I really liked, and the other was a basil infused vodka drink that was awesome (if you like basil.)
we followed that with the asparagus soup, which was delicious- and I've seen good things written about.
then we each had a half order of pasta, both under $10 (a complete bargain for the portion). my wife didn't love the linguine as much as I did, but she liked the sweetbread pasta with the morels (as did I.) Personally I love citrus the way it was used in the linguine- so I really enjoyed that pasta. But maybe it's not for everybody?
By the time we got the filet (which we split) we were both pretty full- and felt that for $29 it was incredibly reasonable. We rarely (if ever) order a filet- so I don't know how many ounces it was, but I'm guessing it is in line with what other similar restaurants charge for their filet. It was super tasty. We both enjoyed it.
We also partook in the side dishes- which only complemented the main course. The $4 portion of hen of the woods mushrooms were tasty, and also a bargain (compared to how much you'll pay at a place like Craft.)
We ended the meal with the coffee parfait- which we both agree was delicious. So you can see how our experience could differ so much from the one described above.
Lke I said, I consider myself really lucky!
Table 8: Inconsistent and Overpriced
Then again, maybe I should just stick to eating gross food off of carts! :-)
Table 8: Inconsistent and Overpriced
Nick... you should stick with burgers! :-)
My wife and I ate there last week and loved it. Although admittedly we only ordered one main course (the filet, which at $29 we thought was a complete bargain.) I guess we got lucky, avoiding the stingy and not so tasty other main courses? My hunch is if you stick with half orders of the pastas (only $7 and $9), and the salt bar you can make an amazing meal on the cheap. Did you try the lamb terrine? Or the foie gras with cacao nibs? Both delicious! And for $6 each we got much more than we expected. Also loved the white asparagus soup.
Sure it's trendy, bordering on annoying, but we loved the food. Can't believe it's getting panned by everyone (Restaurant Girl agrees with you!)... but especially by Serious Eats, which gives every restaurant a B or higher.
All-Star Sandwich Bar in Cambridge, Mass.
Those sandwiches look awwwesome... although I can't see why anybody would get the beef on weck, when Kelly's Roast Beef is right up Route 1!
http://www.seriouseats.com/2007/07/serious-sandwiches-kellys-roast_beef_revere_massachusetts.html
Oh Kelly's how I miss you...
Hell's Kitchen Food Festival
It's this weekend... May 16th & 17th
Delivery Showdown: Goodburger Versus Stand
I have to commend you... not just on a great head to head review- but also on the fact that you ordered these burgers and paid for them yourself, rather than having them delivered by a Midtown steakhouse.
:-)
Mario Batali Launches a Children's Foundation
Wait a second... am I to understand that I could bring my baby to Babbo!?! :-)
Fried Chicken Emergency
It's funny... I walked by there today and all you can smell is collard greens! The thing about PoC is this... it's not blow you away good. But almost everything is good enough, and you won't find a cheaper option in Manhattan (I'm guessing)
Burger Throwdown at R.F. O'Sullivan's Tomorrow!
Ah... Slummerville! brings back memories...
Why Mario's Closing the Enoteca at Del Posto
"What if we earned a Michelin star and no one showed up to enjoy the food?"
I can understand professional ambition, but am not sure how having a less casual place attached impacts food quality, unless the pace or volume of serving food in the more casual Enoteca impacts the ability to serve high quality food at Del Posto (doubtful). So basically, he's upping the snob appeal in hope of recognition. It seems like it might backfire - if anything, Michelin seems willing to recognize places that are more casual in atmosphere but excellent in food.
Serious Eats Finds New York's Best Bagel
Personal Favorites:
Brooklyn: Montague Street Bagels
Manhattan: Ess-a-Bagel
Favorite used to be Bagel Zone (Ave A between 3rd St & 4th St), until they changed their name and stopped baking their own. Was the perfect bagel -- crisp on the outside, soft and bready on the inside...I'd pay a ridiculous premium just to taste one again.
Why Mario's Closing the Enoteca at Del Posto
I've eaten at both more than once; he'd have been better off to have closed the "main room", which is pretentious, overpriced and a little oppressive in tone, and whose food isn't outstanding enough to justify the attitude. The Enoteca had excellent, inventive food at reasonable prices, served by friendly people who didn't take themselves (and you) so seriously that you spent more time worrying whether your tie was on straight (the main room is that kind of place, even if you are not wearing a tie!) than enjoying the food.
Why Mario's Closing the Enoteca at Del Posto
I am so NOT a fan of Batali - especially hate his attempts at 'regular guy' behavior & this only confirms the depths of an ego which is more bloated than his physique...
True, I've never ate at Babbo - just Del Posto, Otto & Casa Mono, and I found that every one of them fell far-short of the cheaper, non-celeb chef, alternatives that abound in NYC.
Still, the nail-in-the-coffin for me was his unctuous, insufferably smug performance on that god-awful 'On the Road: Spain' program - perhaps the single worst thing I've ever seen on TV. And no, you can't blame it all on Gwynneth! Whoo - did Batali stink-up the screen...
OK - rant over.
Why Mario's Closing the Enoteca at Del Posto
I only ate at the Enoteca as you always have to wait yonks to book a table in the main room. So that's that then.
Why Mario's Closing the Enoteca at Del Posto
sounds to me like Mario is more interested in the acclaim than his customers...The guy is an Iron chef how much more back patting does he need? So the regular slobs who'd like to try some of his food are SOL...you should be ashamed Batali....
Amazing 66: A Truly Amazing Menu in Manhattan's Chinatown
Another small bone to pick, following that of the Rebbetzin: Japanese pumpkin is kabocha, not to be confused with kombucha (the ubiquitous seaweed-based health food store tea so popular in trendy NY nabes these days). Kambucha seems like it would be some autumnal fantasy drink for Park Slope yoginis that combine the two.
PS. I live in Park Slope and I love it. Not hatin'.
Amazing 66: A Truly Amazing Menu in Manhattan's Chinatown
yum...i am booking flight to NYC soon!
Lady M Cake Boutique Cheesecake: The Last Cut Is The Deepest
Perhaps it would have been okay if you had just asked her not to slice it. Then done it yourself.
That is really bizarre. I suppose they eat the extra slivers themselves. I can't imagine what else they might do. Maybe collect enough slivers to start making full slices? Yeah right.
Amazing 66: A Truly Amazing Menu in Manhattan's Chinatown
Roast Chicken with Garlic/Preserved Vegetable is one of my faves! Great review! You got a lot of the dishes my family and I would've ordered. I gotta try that fried chicken stuffed with sticky rice.
Amazing 66: A Truly Amazing Menu in Manhattan's Chinatown
This already has me racking my brain to come up with a way to create the Crispy Chicken Stuffed with Sticky Rice...I want to make this dish...
Amazing 66: A Truly Amazing Menu in Manhattan's Chinatown
so excited for my next trip to nyc. kicking myself for not finding it when i lived there! amazing.
Serious Sandwiches: Zagi's Meatball Sub
Gone and I never managed to get over there!
Amazing 66: A Truly Amazing Menu in Manhattan's Chinatown
We go here whenever my parents are in town. The chicken stuffed with shrimp (one of my mom's favorites) though never had a pre-order requirement. The golden prawns over twin rice and the straight-up roast chicken with garlic are definitely two of my favorites. I end up putting those soyed-up garlic bits on everything that touches my plate.
Amazing 66: A Truly Amazing Menu in Manhattan's Chinatown
Danny Ng's, formerly on Pell (now, I believe, on Bowery just below Canal) was serving that pumpkin dish way back when.
P.
Amazing 66: A Truly Amazing Menu in Manhattan's Chinatown
mmmm.. yummy.
i also love that shrimp with mayo. it seems all higher classed chinese places will have it.
Amazing 66: A Truly Amazing Menu in Manhattan's Chinatown
Next time I am in the city I'm heading straight there!
Serious Sandwiches: Zagi's Meatball Sub
Just an FYI... I know this article is old, but with it being refreshed on National Sandwich Day 2009, I should point out that Zagi's has closed and is no more. Seattle mourns their loss.
Serious Eats Finds New York's Best Bagel
I agree that Daniels in Murray Hill is pretty good. My all time Manhattan fav though, is Jumbo Hot Bagels on 56th and 2nd Ave. They are boiled, baked and delicious just like a bagel should be.
On Banning Photography from Restaurants
I just got back from Corton. The website asks guests to refrain from using flash photography and cell phones. I accept that gladly. You quote Drew here as saying,
"No, we're not going to stop people from taking photos," Nieporent said. "We'd just like people to be considerate of the other people in the restaurant.""
So why, when I entered, was I told that no photography was permitted. I asked nicely and was told, "no". The host asked the chef and reiterated that it was not permissible. I explained that I would not use a flash. I explained that I would not use the photos online nor for any commercial purposes. Still, my request was refused. I feel lied to based on the website only saying that "flash photography" was not permitted and also the quote here from Drew. So Drew, why is this?
The food at Corton was good but, just like Momofuku Ko, I won't be back. I see no reason to reward restaurants who don't consider my desire for a permanent memory, valid. They can make any policies they like but I still get to chose where I dine. I also chose to deal with people who advertise honestly. Drew said that, "we're not going to stop people" but that is just what they did. That to me is deceptive.
In the interest of full disclosure, the host did comp a round of drinks for us because of this. Still, it, (please, please, pardon the pun, leaves a bad taste in my mouth.
Lady M Cake Boutique Cheesecake: The Last Cut Is The Deepest
(Actually, looks more like 5%, if the pic is accurate!!)
Lady M Cake Boutique Cheesecake: The Last Cut Is The Deepest
As perfect as we'd all like our food to look, in the end, it is for EATING, not for SEEING, unless your eyes are inside your BELLY.
I would have estimated how much it was she took off (2%?) then reduced my payment by exactly that much.
"Well, looks like you took away about 2% there, so I'll only be paying 98% of the agreed upon amount. Have a great day, and I'd advise you that what you did there was not only illegal, but rude."
On another matter, PLEASE describe that crepe cake! Is it, as I imagine, stacked sugared crepes?? Sounds like that could be amazing.
Save Prime Burger, A Burger Shop With Real Character
Ate there today. We ordered as per above. Burgers were one degree over-cooked. Onions were good. Burgers were small but I was glad to not be too full afterwords.
I rate them as fine if you are in the area but not worth a trip.
Lady M Cake Boutique Cheesecake: The Last Cut Is The Deepest
I go to school right by there, and once I stopped in out of curiosity. I ordered a slice of something or other, and after it was cut, on it's way to being transferred to a place, it fell on its side rather than staying upright. The woman behind the counter actually threw the slice away and tried again to be sure I would be presented with a slice standing up!! Seriously. So I don't know that we can blame the people behind the counter. I think it must be policy, and it's not their fault if they have to follow it.
Lady M Cake Boutique Cheesecake: The Last Cut Is The Deepest
the Mille crepes cake isn't hard to make. Recipe on internet. I made it last Christmas, after cleaning off the rust from my long -not -used crepe pans.
Not every crepe has to be perfect, you can bury the less than good ones in the middle layers.
and very much cheaper than buying it!
Recent Posts
Fancy Restaurants Should Implement an Early 'Baby Seating'
Posted by Zach Brooks, March 23, 2009 at 3:00 PM
Can We Retire the Word 'Toothsome' Already?
Posted by Zach Brooks, January 22, 2009 at 4:04 PM
News Spread: Thanksgiving Blog; Kosher Hung; Buttermilk Channel
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 26, 2008 at 5:30 PM
Week in Reviews: Best Bites
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 26, 2008 at 10:00 AM
News Spread: The Palm Smells; Free Coffee; Free Soup
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 25, 2008 at 5:15 PM
Smörgåsboard: Kuma Inn; Huitlacoche, Ravioli
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 25, 2008 at 9:00 AM
News Spread: Allen & Delancey; SLA; Setagaya
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 24, 2008 at 5:15 PM
Smörgåsboard: Cupcakes; Majarete; Tortelli
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 24, 2008 at 9:00 AM
News Spread: Fish Tacos; Ago; Thanksgiving
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 21, 2008 at 5:30 PM
Smörgåsboard: Rouge Tomate; Belcourt; Diner
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 21, 2008 at 9:00 AM
News Spread: Gael Greene; Kyotofu to Go; Jive Turkey
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 20, 2008 at 5:00 PM
Smörgåsboard: Mitzy's Macarons; Hot Chocolate; Cafe Select
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 20, 2008 at 9:00 AM
Sugar Rush: Mudslide Cookie from Jacques Torres
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 19, 2008 at 6:00 PM
News Spread: Kurve; Benoit; Bouchon Bakery
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 19, 2008 at 5:45 PM
Week in Reviews: Best Bites
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 19, 2008 at 10:00 AM
News Spread: Vendy Catering; Creme Brulee Dougnut; Pizza Happy Hour
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 18, 2008 at 5:30 PM
Jamie Oliver Will Come to Your Thanksgiving
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 18, 2008 at 1:00 PM
Smörgåsboard: Baked Eggs; Dirty Candy; Chinese Thanksgiving
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 18, 2008 at 9:00 AM
News Spread: John Dory; One if By Land; Atomic Wings
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 17, 2008 at 5:30 PM
Momofuku Bakery and Milk Bar Madness
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 17, 2008 at 11:30 AM
Smörgåsboard: Kalbi bones; Pizza; Strudel
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 17, 2008 at 9:00 AM
News Spread: Table 8; Village Pourhouse; Del Frisco's
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 14, 2008 at 5:15 PM
Everything Ed Levine Ate This Week
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 14, 2008 at 10:45 AM
Smörgåsboard: Irving Mill; Bún; Frankie's
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 14, 2008 at 9:00 AM
News Spread: Momofuku Bakery; Txikito; Enoteca DiPalo
Posted by Zach Brooks, November 13, 2008 at 5:15 PM
Recent Favorites
In Defense of Chef Chris Cosentino's Foie Gras
Posted by Erin Zimmer, March 9, 2009 at 12:45 PM
Food T-Shirts at Brooklyn Kitchen
Posted by Erin Zimmer, December 18, 2008 at 1:00 PM
Polls
Zach Brooks hasn't answered any polls yet.
Quizzes
Zach Brooks hasn't taken any quizzes yet.
About Zach Brooks
Website: http://www.midtownlunch.com
Location: New York, NY
About: "Fat man, likes food" sums it up. You can find me eating lunch in Midtown Manahattan and posting about it on my site midtownlunch.com.
Favorite foods: I discriminate against no food. Although I am partial to the Asian cusines... and pork. Combine the two, and I'm in heaven (which explains my obsession with the Momofuku restaurants here in NYC.)
Last bite on earth: A pill that makes you keep living? Barring that, I would probably want to eat at some sort of Asian all you can eat buffet- but if you are literally talking about one last bite, it would probably be a perfectly cooked piece of crispy pork skin

I've only eaten at the enoteca, so I can't compare it to the main dining room- but it sounded to me like it was about the kitchen, not the critics. The enoteca was a different menu, which also changed pretty often (daily?)... so my guess is they're getting rid of it so the chefs can devote more of their time and energy to the food on the regular menu.