The Old Foodie’s Profile
Recent Comments
Let's talk pie...
Meat pie, with gravy and mashed potatoes, but then I'm an Aussie.
Online Historic Cookbooks
Oh Dear. I knew my technical ineptness would let me down. I thought I was pretty clever even working out how to convert the spreadsheet into a pdf file. Does it still work if you cut and past the url?
If anyone would like the Excel spreadsheet I started with, please email me and I'll send it - that way you can make it dynamic and your own (I have a master list with all my other historic cookbooks - real, facsimile, whatever - included as well)
email is theoldfoodieATfastmailDOTfm
See more comments by The Old Foodie »
Recent Posts
See more posts by The Old Foodie »
Recent Favorites
The Old Foodie hasn't favorited a post yet.
Recent Polls
The Old Foodie hasn't answered any polls yet.
Recent Quizzes
The Old Foodie hasn't taken any quizzes yet.
Recent Comments | Response to Comments
Ed McFarland Holds a Press Conference: Life Goes On
Ed is right - any psychologist will tell you this - this is not about intellectual property. This is about " a violation of trust, resentment, and betrayal ". When we feel hurt and betrayed we all are inclined to go out on financially and emotionally exhausting campaigns which make no sense commercially.
Let's talk pie...
Meat pie, with gravy and mashed potatoes, but then I'm an Aussie.
Online Historic Cookbooks
Oh Dear. I knew my technical ineptness would let me down. I thought I was pretty clever even working out how to convert the spreadsheet into a pdf file. Does it still work if you cut and past the url?
If anyone would like the Excel spreadsheet I started with, please email me and I'll send it - that way you can make it dynamic and your own (I have a master list with all my other historic cookbooks - real, facsimile, whatever - included as well)
email is theoldfoodieATfastmailDOTfm
Ed McFarland Holds a Press Conference: Life Goes On
So why, can you tell me, why has this garnered three articles here when there is NO new information? Get on with it till there is actually something new to report!!!
Ed McFarland Holds a Press Conference: Life Goes On
Not to me it isn't. What if Rebecca wins, this changes everything. What if there was only one place in NYC where you could experience a "seafood shack".
Exactly. I think IP rights have been pushed too far already (a copyright term of life plus 75 years?), and a victory by POB could have serious consequences. Everyone steals from everyone else -- that's how ideas and art (and cuisine) evolve. Allowing someone to own the right to a restaurant concept could really stifle creativity and innovation.
Maybe McFarland violated her trust. Maybe he's a worldclass jerk. But IMO she crossed the line when she filed the lawsuit.
Ed McFarland Holds a Press Conference: Life Goes On
"This fight is not about diners enjoying unfettered access to delectable lobster rolls and Caesar salads. It's about a violation of trust, resentment, and betrayal behind the counter and the stove at a couple of restaurants in New York."
Not to me it isn't. What if Rebecca wins, this changes everything. What if there was only one place in NYC where you could experience a "seafood shack".
Not fair, not right, I demand unfettered access to lobster rolls!
Their squabbles are nothing to me. Violation of trust? Should he have just stayed there the rest of his life, working for her?
Ed McFarland Holds a Press Conference: Life Goes On
I agree with Kim Nyland; jumping on any possible, theoretical hint of bias is just far too easy, especially in this all-about-taking-sides situation.
Ed McFarland Holds a Press Conference: Life Goes On
I think the people who invented the buffalo wings have a huge case. Since they serve them virtually everywhere. People copy food and recipes all the time. Hell I use one of Emeril's fried chicken recipes (one of 100's) and call it mine. I also agree that I feel bad that the trust issue was breeched.
If I were Ed I would make croutons out of something else and put my own mark on the world.
Ed McFarland Holds a Press Conference: Life Goes On
This is also about free publicity. Mary's Fish Camp, which has not been mentioned, should be furious.
Let's talk pie...
Lemon Meringue is my favorite. I also like Apple Pies
Let's talk pie...
I was somewhere recently where a piece of lemon meringue was forced on me. The meringue had started to fall apart and there was what seemed to be water between the lemon and the meringue. Yuck.
I like the idea of pies- used to love, love, love apples pies- but haven't been able to find a crust that does't get soggy or fall apart on me. I now make apple crisp with blueberries. I serve it warm with soy vanilla ice cream. So good, it almost makes me forget it's soy ice cream.
Let's talk pie...
Lemon meringue pie, hands down. But it's also one of the foods that I am terrified to make at home. I've tried twice but one time the curd was too runny and sloshed out of the pan and on to my feet and the other time the meringue was too soft and flopped over so the whole pie looked kind of sad and pathetic. Thus, I try to order a slice whenever I see it on a menu.
Let's talk pie...
I don't love pie either, forrester... not huge on sweets, and never have been thrilled with the crust. However, I live with a pie fanatic, so I do bake them fairly regularly. Oh, and I need to a add this to the ashamed thread -- I use frozen crust because in thirty years of trying, I never have mastered pie crust ::blush::
When I do eat pie, I like pumpkin (my own is the best). Actually, I like custard pies in general -- banana cream and key lime (this should NEVER be made with meringue) rate highly.
Let's talk pie...
My favorites are Olallieberry Pie when it is in season. If you've never had a slice you are missing something wonderful. My other favorite is a slice of rhubarb pie when I'm in Silverton, CO during their rhubarb festival.
Let's talk pie...
I love pie! I work for a gentleman who makes fantastic pies- so far my two favorites are his Tollhouse cookie pie (sans baking powder, everything is the same as the cookie) and red raspberry cream. The cream filling is TO DIE FOR...I made it once but was told I had to forget the recipe. So I did 'cause I respect him and would like to keep the job. :)
I like both somewhat chilled but not cold.
I dislike rhubarb, peach and citrus pies. Everything else is fair game!
Let's talk pie...
I'm with Liberty Lady - fruit pies only! Apple pie is my favorite.
Let's talk pie...
am i the only person that doesn't like pie?
Let's talk pie...
Not much into "sweets", but I do love Key Lime Pie when made properly.
And "made properly" means, to me, made with fresh Key Limes. If fresh Key limes are not available, we will grudgingly substitute "Nellie & Joe's" Key West Lime Juice (but it is NOT as good as the fresh stuff by any means).
Nothing else will do.
As for service, I like it served just above freezing on a chilled plate. Oh, and a generous sprinkle of lime zest.
Now bring on that chicory coffee!
Let's talk pie...
JerzeeTomato - I am intrigued by this ricotta pie. Is it a bit like a cheese cake? Could you give us some more information.
Let's talk pie...
Fruit pies only, for me. Strawberry-rhubarb, peach, fresh raspberry - all homemade. I guess I know what I'll be doing this weekend! It's time for pie!
Let's talk pie...
Glad you asked. I just learned how to bake pies last year and really enjoy my own rather than anything bought. Here are some of my pies. The best crust I've found is at Elise's Simply Recipes. I use her all-butter crust with almonds, and substitute agave nectar for brown sugar. It's wonderful, as her recipes tend to be.
The best combination of fruit I've tried was blueberry nectarine. That was such a huge success, people ate it for breakfast.
Let's talk pie...
Best pie I ever had was a very tall fresh raspberry pie from Helen's Restaurant in Machias, ME: couple inches raspberries, two to three inches real whipped cream. Unreal!
Let's talk pie...
Ricotta pie (with 1 pkg of cream cheese added) drop of orange oil and sweet pastry crust. Some chopped bittersweet chocolate.
Online Historic Cookbooks
Lilartist, you just gave me a great idea. The next time I am in Cold Spring, I will go to the antiques market there and see what they have to say. I was looking at places on the UES, but they are soooo specialist! Thanks!
Online Historic Cookbooks
Well, no problem, just a thought. I have a local market. And several of the antiques dealers there either had information on such things, or have dealt with them in the past. Any good antiques dealer will know, or know how to get that information. I was able to get a value on my cookbooks from the 1800's from such a source.
Online Historic Cookbooks
Lilartist, I'm looking for an expert in cooking ephemera; an antiques dealer has not got the expertise in this area. Thanks, though.
Online Historic Cookbooks
BaHa - any local antiques dealer will be able to tell you, or can find a value of it for you!
Recent Posts
Recent Favorites
The Old Foodie hasn't favorited a post yet.
Polls
The Old Foodie hasn't answered any polls yet.
Quizzes
The Old Foodie hasn't taken any quizzes yet.

Ed is right - any psychologist will tell you this - this is not about intellectual property. This is about " a violation of trust, resentment, and betrayal ". When we feel hurt and betrayed we all are inclined to go out on financially and emotionally exhausting campaigns which make no sense commercially.