Must eats along road trip from NYC to New Haven, CT?
Going with two friends for a road trip this Thursday from NYC to New Haven to end with pizza. Where are the must eats along the way?
I love food, it's the simplest pleasure in life. My goal is spreading the word on my favorite affordable places throughout the city. Check out my website for some great photos and reviews.
Court street grocers are amazing. Maybe its because i don't get there too often but every time I do go I'm so excited. Their sandwiches are all so well calibrated and executed it's pretty hard to have a bad experience there. And what I really like about their style is that a lot of their sandwiches are regional odes so while there's something super NYC about the whole place (rugelach for sale at front counter, I mean, c'mon!) it embodies the spirit of the quintessential sandwich shop for many different cities. Has anyone tried their Friday night dinners?
Chubby Mary's, Artichoke's new classic Italian hero shop that replaced Led Zeppole on 1st and 14th, is legit. Been rocking it pretty hard since it first opened and have been happily stuffed for great value every time. This is the type of Italian hero shop that the East Village (and Manhattan in general) can really use more of. Since they're associated with Artichoke, you're going to get some really rich and hearty sandwiches - there's only a few cold Italian heroes where cold cuts are the star - but everything is fresh and delicious.
The key is that with every type of cutlet/parm hero, the "meat" of the sandwich (chicken, veal, eggplant) is fried to order, making the sandwich hot and crispy every time. The bread is always fresh and offers that perfect amount of heft and chewiness an Italian hero needs. And the provolone is dry, sharp and shredded, no processed perfect circle slices here.
The veal cutlet with broccoli rabe and provolone (ask for some tomato sauce too) has been great each of the three times I tried it.
The chicken cutlet with provolone and vodka sauce is super rich but delicious.
Had the "Mean Streets" Italian meat hero the other day and it was pretty tasty despite having very few veggies (my ideal hero is more like Faicco's featuring Italian meat plus lettuce and tomato to balance out the salty meat). Just a mountain of fluffy, thinly sliced Italian meats topped with fresh mozz, garlicky slices of roasted red pepper, oil, red wine vinegar, and a healthy dose of black pepper for spice.
@max This really is an incredible sandwich. Love the New Mexico green hatch chile (and I discovered that at Shopsin's). I don't know if people realize they're probably the only restaurant in the five boroughs who has real New Mexico green hatch chile year round.
Another key to success for this sandwich is how crispy they get the bread because the cheese, hatch chile, brisket combo is so tender and juicy, you need that airy ciabatta to soak up the juice and provide sturdy textural contrast.
@mh330 I'm happy to hear you say that. No one who loves Shopsin's would want you taking a seat away from someone who really appreciates and understands how great the restaurant really is.
@james boo great video. what's the goal of this video series? just covering your favorite spots with one minute videos highlighting what makes their places special? what's going to happen over the next year?
This is just terribly disappointing. I was talking with a friend the other day about why Burger Joint would even bother to expand down to West Village without ensuring the burgers were JUST AS GOOD if not better than the original. The only saving grace for a place like the downtown Burger Joint will be to stay open late and steal business from Corner Bistro. Can't find a website so not sure if they'll be taking advantage. I still need to get down to the new one myself and make sure that things are as grave as it is indicated here. Standby...
These bagels were one of the best things I ate at Smorgasburg two weeks ago and Melissa is so sweet. Check out a photo of the onion bagel with cream cheese on my Instagram @nycfooguy and follow me if you want a constant stream of food porn.
Awesome post.
Pequod's is so freaking good. Had giardiniera and pepperoni, unreal. As you said, exactly what you wanted from your Chicago pizza experience.
i love pambazo. I'm fairly certain I was the first one to write anything about it in the NYC blog world with my post back in 2009: http://nycfoodguy.com/2009/04/06/sunset_park_brooklyn_mexican_food_tour/
Next time get the wood oven-grilled bread covered in gorgonzola dulce and truffle honey. Unreal. They also do a pretty solid happy hour every day (food and drink). Good spot.
This place is pretty solid, good for the neighborhood slice scene, but not going to reinvent the wheel for you. Had a reheated margherita slice one night and was happy to taste what seemed like decent cheese and olive oil, crust had a nice faint charred flavor. Would definitely have it again if in the 'hood and in need of a slice.
@howdini
I've only had those three slices and they've always satisfied. But I've also only had them when they're relatively fresh. I've definitely walked right in and right out of Iggy's a few times after seeing some pies that looked like they'd been hanging out for a while.
@howdini
I've only had those three slices and they've always satisfied. But I've also only had them when they're relatively fresh. I've definitely walked right in and right out of Iggy's a few times after seeing some pies that looked like they'd been hanging out for a while.
Definitely a HUGE upgrade for the neighborhood's "middle ground" authentic NYC slice.
Five other East Village/Union Square spots that deserve mention on this list outside of Stromboli (overrated IMHO) are:
Mariella's - 3rd ave and 16th street - Plain (always) or Sicilian (when fresh). They are always pumping out fresh pies so its a good bet you can get a fresh slice or warm slice (the latter of which is even better when you're on the go).
Muzzarella - Avenue A and 14th street - Plain, Sicilian, Lasagna slice (ricotta, meat sauce, mozzarella), Foccacia slice with marinara and pesto (very garlicky). Open until 2am most weeknights and until 5am (or when they're out of pizza) on weekends. Great alternative to the line at Artichoke.
Iggy's - 1st Avenue b/t 10th & 11th St - Awesome Grandma, solid plain, great Buffalo chicken slice, spinach and cheese pinwheels (make sure to ask for Buffalo and pinwheels HOT if you get them re-heated). Don't know how this place, right next to Momofuku Noodle Bar, has not received more attention.
Solo - Ave B b/t 2nd-3rd st - Serious Eats has given love to this place for their plain slices and I concur. Especially a solid Alphabet City late night option, open late weekends.
Johnny's - 1st Ave at 15th st - This place gets NO love - ever - but it makes some pretty solid authentic NYC plain slices. Have not had any other slices there but their pies got me through Hurricane Sandy.
Anything I missed?
@Max,
Good work man. Love me some pambazo.
@Carey!!!!
I ate this sandwich over two years ago at Xochimilco and it was the most memorable part of my Sunset Park Taco tour. There were some other highs but I have not enjoyed a Mexican sandwich as much as this one since I first had it. To quote myself, it's the "everlasting gobstopper of Mexican Sandwiches."
If you want to see the rest of the Sunset Park taco tour, check it:
http://nycfoodguy.com/2009/04/06/sunset_park_brooklyn_mexican_food_tour/
Forget Ozersky, can we talk for a second about the fact that this is the best content the Hungry YouTube Channel, Google's big online food TV station, can put together? The editing is out of sequence and the shooting is terrible. Is this the best Google's wallet can do for the future of online food programming?!
Hey Max,
Fun post.
If someone reads this post and decides to try Joanne's based on it, they should know that Joanne's slices are pretty underwhelming if you don't get them fresh. They key is ordering a Buff Chicken mini pie or a whole fresh pie and digging in immediately.
I grew up in Great Neck and discovered Joanne's Buffalo slice while working as a counselor at nearby Shibley Day Camp over 10 years ago. It was love at first sight.
Two years later, we upped the ante as counselors at Pierce Day Camp, ordering personal Buffalo mini pies from Joanne's. Later I discovered the BBQ chicken slice and would order fresh pies, half buff, half BBQ. I've never looked back since.
As for NYC Buffalo slices, the best I've found in the East Village thus far is at Iggy's on 1st Ave b/t 10th and 11th. When it's there and fresh, it's great. Their grandma slice is also pretty solid as are their pinwheels when heated sufficiently. Where have you found good ones in NYC?
Awesome story, this pizza looks seriously delicious.
The burger at Rowdy Hall are all about the seeded bun and the fried onions. The onions are like old school Donovan's of Bayside style (before they were bought and renovated). Sweet and crisp, burnt around the edges, but still melt-in-your-mouth.
Astro Pizza in Amagansett is also good for a quick, simple pizza pie or slice fix. And if you play your cards carefully you may run into Alec Baldwin there. Seen him there several times.
And to add some more wood to the fire, take a look at this fun soul-killing app:
http://cheazza.com/
What are some of the best "plain" New York slices (at ordinary slice joints) in the 5 boroughs? Let's get a definitive list going to prove to ourselves that the old school New York "plain" slice is still alive and well.
Here's some food for thought (in no particular order):
Joe's Pizza, West Village
Sal and Carmines, Upper West Side
Gino's, Upper East Side
Mariella's, Multiple locations in Manhattan
Prince Street Pizza, SoHo
Luigi's, Park Slope, Brooklyn
DiFara's, Midwood, Brooklyn
Nunzio's, Staten Island
New Park Pizza, Queens
Louie and Ernie's, Bronx
Keep adding names to the list...
@Kenji,
So is Mission Chinese now the most authentic Szechuan food in NYC?
Question to all.
I really enjoy Szechuan food. But I have never tasted Szechuan more pronounced on the peppercorn front than at Mission Chinese in NYC. Is this what "real" Szechuan is supposed to taste like or does Bowien just have a heavy hand with the Szechuan peppercorns? Is there something to be said for balance? I enjoyed the mapo tofu at Legend in Chelsea better than the one at Mission, you could taste other things besides the peppercorns.
Thoughts?
I'm so happy you wrote about the Sicilian. I was scrolling down the story and getting worried you didn't try it. One of the better Sicilian slices I've had in NYC.
You need to review Valentino's Thing & Crispy next. Make sure to ask for the owner and main pizzaiola John Fruente, I've met very few people who are as passionate about pizza and the craft as him.
Going with two friends for a road trip this Thursday from NYC to New Haven to end with pizza. Where are the must eats along the way?
NYC Food Guy hasn't favorited a post yet.
GREAT VIDEOS. Could all be a full minute shorter, but still, great videos. Love the static shot of the sandwiches being built, especially in the Northern Spy video when the egg pops and the yolk explodes everywhere (too bad the chef moved the sandwich).