Get to Know a Serious Eater.

Michael Nagrant's Profile

Website:

Location:

About:

Favorite foods:

Last bite on earth:

The Ten Most Recent Posts By Michael Nagrant

From Eating Out

Burnin' Down the House in Chicago, Pakistani Osso Bucco-Style

20080509-sabri-nihari.jpgIt seems like every year one of my favorite Pakistani restaurants burns down. Two years ago it was Khan BBQ, my favorite spot to grab green chili slathered charcoal tandoor fired chicken boti. The fire turned what was once a dingy smoky cabbie joint, thick with smoke from poor ventilation, into a relatively elegant peach colored banquet hall with a chandelier that would be at home in the Taj Mahal.

Last year, apparently due to faulty wiring, my other go-to spot, Sabri Nihari, burned down. Unlike Khan BBQ, the new incarnation, a narrow El car-wide corridor of a restaurant outfitted with more mirrors than a ballet studio, is a step down from the old, pure white Liberace-like garishness of the old spot. The owners assured me this was a temporary location, though it’s been open for over a year now, so maybe not.

Continue reading »

From Eating Out

Chicago's Best Dining Experiences

20080502-alinea.jpg

Screw the Michelin guide and its ilk. Like the SAT or personality tests, reductive rating systems that award mini constellations, forks, spoons, or pepper shakers can never see what's in a restaurant's heart.

The endurance of these systems often encourage readers to skip the meat of a review and go straight to the final number as an arbiter of whether they should call for reservations.

Some of these systems are just plain impossible. Consider the S. Pellegrino 50 Best Restaurants in the World. Did Gordon Ramsay U.K. really improve 11 spots in a year while its proprietor was out traveling the world berating and dehumanizing line cooks and restaurateurs? In one year, did Charlie Trotter's, which has been fine-tuning things for 20 years, really suck it up so bad as to drop from 31 to 38 and lose the title of Chicago's best restaurant to upstart Alinea?

Continue reading »

From Eating Out

No Chang in Chicago, No Problem: Pho Xua's Fried Duck Noodle Soup

20080502-nagrant-phoxua.jpgIn Chicago, we have not yet been blessed with a noodle god like Momofuku’s David Chang. We’ve instead had to settle for noodles from a handful of lower level deities, like Tony Hu at Chinatown’s Lao Szechuan or Vanna Gumtrontip at Spoon Thai. Last week, I discovered a new star to add to the mix. I may not actually know the star, as I didn’t get the chef’s name, but his fried duck noodle soup speaks quite well on his behalf.

Served at a new Argyle St./Little Vietnam storefront named Pho Xua, this bowl of soul is filled with a fresh nest of pliant egg noodles, a deep, rich ducky broth, and a fat, fried, crunchy-skinned duck leg, along with a garden of bok choy, scallions, and little earthy mushroom rafts. Slurping it down banished the seasonal mood swings I’d been indulging after a string of weeks of ubiquitous overcast, slate gray days of drizzle and chafing wind.

Continue reading »

From Required Eating

A Slice of Pizza Beer

20080425-pizzabeer.jpgThey say if you want people to pay attention all you have to do is put up signs that say “free beer” or “free pizza”. It seems the same holds true when you put pizza in your beer.

Walking around Chicago’s supreme liquor warehouse, Binny’s South Loop, I’d spotted a case off tri-color bottles labeled Mamma Mia Pizza Beer sporting the cheesy faces of a couple of floppy Chef Boyardee-style chef hatted folks dubbed Chef Tom and Chef Athena. Turns out Tom and Athena Seefurth are just as cheesy as their pictures suggest. A closer look confirmed this was an ale brewed with oregano, basil, tomato, and garlic. Intellectually, I wanted to wretch, but as a man who loves organ meat, I know you always find great eats in unexpected places.

Surely Chef Tom and Athena knew this, as the bottles were marketed as singles and not in multi-packs. For a $1.99, even if it tasted like Natural Light or Milwaukee’s Best, my wallet wouldn’t sweat it.

Continue reading »

From Eating Out

Traveling the World One Wing at a Time

"Each of the 46 flavors spanning the international scene, from Jamaica (Fire Jerk, Rum BBQ) to Italy (Parmesan, Tomato Basil Pesto), is a study in balance and contrast."

20080424-wings.jpgChicago's Wings Around the World is like the Baskin Robbins of Chicken Wings. When they opened in January of 2007, they had 34 flavors of wings. A year and a half later, another twelve have been added to honor their motto, “Flavors to Infinity”. Abeng Stuart founded the spot and concocted the sauces with his mother Lorna Greene and his manager Andre Palmer.

What’s crazy is that this isn’t some spot where they throw chicken in the deep fryer and haphazardly toss the half soggy/half crunchy overcrowded fried chicken with a drippy Franks Red Hot Sauce and margarine glaze. Each of the 46 flavors spanning the international scene, from Jamaica (Fire Jerk, Rum BBQ) to Italy (Parmesan, Tomato Basil Pesto), is a study in balance and contrast. The selection is a thoughtful cornucopia of glazes and seasonings spiked with the right amount of heat, sour, and sweet. The chicken itself is uniformly crunchy if deep fried, or soft, pliant, and smoky if you get the wings grilled. Of course, on this stretch of 35th street lined with a Churches, Popeyes, KFC, and a local JJ Fish and Chicken chain, you gotta bring the goods if you want to survive more than a year.

Continue reading »

From Eating Out

Serious Sandwiches: Rosario's Italian Sausage

20080411-nagrant-roasios.jpgRosario’s has a serious pig problem. There are little porky tchotchkes on the counter, statues of swine behind the counter, and a few huge piggy bank–looking porkers above the freezer case. Even the neon sign on the front of the building depicts a bunch of happy piglets jumping in to a grinder. Of course, I wouldn’t expect anything less from one of Chicago’s best Italian sausage makers.

Continue reading »

From Eating Out

Western Avenue: The Real Tastiest Street in Chicago

Last week, Good magazine named Chicago’s Broadway as one of the tastiest streets in the U.S. Good magazine’s criteria said a best street features “exquisite food you can actually afford." Haute cuisine is out of the equation. That said, as usual, a bunch of dudes writing from the coasts (this time L.A.) get it wrong. Broadway’s not even the tastiest street in Chicago.

It may not even be in the top five. Off the top of my head, I say 18th Street, Devon Avenue, Clark Street, Halsted Street, and Milwaukee Avenue, amongst others, might be better. My gut says there’s no question that the real tastiest street of all though, is Western Avenue.

Western Avenue, which runs 23.5 miles, is the longest continuous street in the city of Chicago, but its strength goes beyond length. There’s a density and diversity that just can’t be beat.

Continue reading »

From Eating Out

Getting Haute at the Hotel: Two Takes on Chicago’s Newest Hotel Restaurants

Mercat a la Planxa: Jose Garces, former protégé of Stephen Starr and Douglas Rodriguez, took a break from building his mini-empire in Philly to unveil some Catalan tapas-style love on his hometown of Chicago at the newly refurbished Blackstone Hotel. The mod space outfitted with gleaming hexagonal tiles and mirrors etched with organic (think birds and leaves) motifs and bare hanging bulbs is one of the funkiest dining rooms to grace our austere storied hotels. The term “smoke filled rooms” actually originated in the Blackstone, and it used to refer to the cigar laden atmosphere in which party bosses once chose Warren G. Harding as a presidential nominee. Today it refers to the smoky romanesco sauces and salbitxada served with deep fried peppers, or the grill-marked succulent lamb chops and head-on shrimp from the grill. The rabbit agnolotti with black truffle may be my favorite dish of the year, and the restaurant itself is one of the best openings of 2008.

Continue reading »

From Eating Out

Chi-Mex: A New Frontier

20080328-mexicaninn.jpgRick Bayless, chef/owner of Chicago's Frontera Grill and Topolobampo, has me brainwashed. Inspired by his example for the last few years, I’ve been telling everyone that you either go regional Mexican or you go home.

If the shadow of a Chipotle and their swaddled infant-sized burritos fell across my path, I’d consider taking a shower. Scarfing down Oaxacan moles and Yucatecan puerco pibil meant I was living right; chewing on chimichangas and noshing on Nachos Belgrande, not so much. Then a few weeks ago, I discovered Mexican Inn.

Mexican Inn is a 47-year-old corner joint located in the shadow of the Chicago skyway. It’s in a south side neighborhood called the East Side, an island of land separated from the rest of the city by the Calumet River and surrounded by behemoth factories with flatulent smokestacks. The East Side is closer to Indiana than it is to downtown. It’s a place most Chicagoans never stop for, though many drive through when the tollway gets backed up.

Continue reading »

From Eating Out

Serious Sandwiches: Hot Doug’s Citrus Burgundy Pork Sausage

When people find out I’m a food writer, they always ask me what my favorite restaurant is. I always respond that answering the question is like asking me who my favorite child is. I usually ask them what kind of food they’re looking for and give them a top three list of options for that particular cuisine.

Truth is, though, if some hungry felon held me up at gunpoint and needed to know my top five favorite spots, Hot Doug’s: The Sausage Superstore would absolutely make the list.

Owner Doug Sohn, a culinary school grad, brings his chops to bear on the humble hot dog. He serves the best Chicago style salad dog in the city. But, it’s not the basic dog I come for. It’s the duck fat fried French fries glistening with sea salt and the custom sausages with ridiculous luxury ingredients.

Continue reading »

The Ten Most Recent Comments By Michael Nagrant

From Required Eating

Early Returns on New Dining Survey Not So Favorable

Ed, I can't speak for Julia (though I'm pretty sure she's also just covering the ethics part out of a sense of what's right), but I can tell you, my criticisms of Steve and the dining guide have nothing to do with Chicago's placement in them.

While I'm certainly a supporter of the windy city's culinary chops, I never hesitate to call it like it is. Being a cheerleader never does any good. It doesn't challenge restaurant owners or chefs to improve and to truly rise to the top.

It's very possible that Alinea doesn't measure up to others in the list. The problem of course is that's it's tough to know, because Plotnicki gets too close to chefs. I think you have a point, he may not be an overt shill, but how do we know he's not a subconscious one? No matter how hard he tries to be objective, subjectivity is bound to creep in when you get so close to the system.


From Eating Out

Serious Sandwiches: The Marky B from Jerry's

Not at all. The iceberg arugula blend here provides a sharp crisp counterpoint and a peppery burst all at the same time.

From Required Eating

This Peanut Looks Like a Duck

I'd like to break it open and see if there's any foie gras inside.

From Eating Out

Where Alice Waters Should Get Her Tacos Next Time She’s in Chicago

Actually I do mean Humboldt Park in the sense that Cemitas Puebla is on the South Side of North Avenue, which puts it in Humboldt park. That being said, Humboldt Park is generally a Puerto Rican enclave as pointed out. Pasadita is excellent, their pastor and carne asada are spot on. Moran's adobado is very good, but it's not authentic pastor as the meat is grilled and not spit roasted. That being said, even if you consider it pastor, I'm willing to bet you they lose when compared with Taqueria Uptown. I agree with the BBQ assertions...amazing que in Chicago these days that breaks from the old school southside paradigm. Don't forget Barbara Ann's, Lem's, and Uncle John's though on the southside...

Responses to Comments by Michael Nagrant

From Required Eating

Early Returns on New Dining Survey Not So Favorable

Great article! If you're looking for good restaurants in the area check out www.foodjoker.com. Great selection of places to eat and great site. Available also in 8 languages.

From Required Eating

Early Returns on New Dining Survey Not So Favorable

Finally - I don't disagree with Steve about everything. We agree about Mr. Bruni. I dined at Michael's Genuine in Miami this week - Mr. Bruni's 4th or 5th best new restaurant of the year. Left me scratching my head. It's not a bad place - it's quite ok. But almost the best new restaurant in the US? Was about on a par - give or take a bit - with Bistro Aix here in Jacksonville FL (near where I live) - which serves similar food. Bistro Aix is a great Jacksonville restaurant - but I don't think anyone would confuse it with one of the best restaurants in the country. RobynG

From Required Eating

Early Returns on New Dining Survey Not So Favorable

Regarding rating restaurants - I personally did not rate any restaurant I haven't dined at within the last 3 years or so. What's the point of rating my meal at Troisgros when I dined there 20 years ago? FWIW - we were never told that our ratings would be weighted by the number of places we reviewed. If that were the case - I could have rated dozens. But again - what would be the point of rating a place where I dined from the 1970's through the 1990's? RobynG

From Required Eating

Early Returns on New Dining Survey Not So Favorable

The simple fact of the matter is that out of these 900 participants - a sufficient number hadn't dined at Dieter Muller or Vendome in Germany (both 3 star Michelin) to warrant inclusion in the guide. I fought hard to get them included - even if I was the only participant who had dined there - but I lost. So DM and Vendome are excluded - and Joe's Stone Crabs is in. RobynG

From Required Eating

Early Returns on New Dining Survey Not So Favorable

I would have to disagree with lostfourwords and say that Steve is a critic in the idealistic sense of the term, to the readers of his guide. He makes it clear that his goal is to get you the restaurants "A" game. If this is truly what he intends, then who better to provide reviews than a man renowned for getting the best out of restaurants. After reading his tips, he would expect you to get the best out of each restaurant, and he would therefore be the ideal critic, in the sense that you are now receiving the restaurant's "A" game, as well as him (like an ideal critic, he is reviewing what you are getting)

That said, I would much rather read a guide such as this, presided over by one such as Steve, over the Zagat guide.
Have you ever read those?
They're so boring!
I'm not planning however, on buying any of these guides. The blog posts are much more interesting.

From Required Eating

Early Returns on New Dining Survey Not So Favorable

"And in the rating system you use, their opinions wouldn't carry a lot of weight because they can't rate as many restaurants as others do."

But I just posted a list of people, some of whom make quite modest incomes, who rated more restaurants than people who have significant wealth.

From Required Eating

Early Returns on New Dining Survey Not So Favorable

This argument reminds me of my love-hate relationship with OAD: I enjoy living vicariously through SP's adventures with his Black Card, but he's no critic (in the idealistic sense of the term); and I certainly can't fathom how he could or would objectively collect and synthesize the opinions of others. That doesn't seem to be the strength of his blog--I mean, who was asking for this? Really. He was supposed to be Alan Richman--minus the ability to write in grammatically correct sentences--not Tim Zagat.

From Required Eating

Early Returns on New Dining Survey Not So Favorable

"While some of the people on the list are high income earners, there are also those who do not make a lot of money but who save in order to take two or three trips a year for the purpose of dining." And in the rating system you use, their opinions wouldn't carry a lot of weight because they can't rate as many restaurants as others do. There may be merits to the system you've come up with, but it does inherently favor the opinions of wealthy people who can afford to eat regularly at expensive restaurants, and it seems to me that the resulting guide is also aimed at them, for better or for worse.

From Required Eating

Early Returns on New Dining Survey Not So Favorable

Well your prior post made a snarky comment saying that it should be called, "The Rich New Yorker's Guide to Dining in the U.S. and Europe." Your last post tones that rhetoric down quite a bit which I appreciate. As to who actually practices this hobby, I took a look at the list of our top weighted participants which included exactly two wealthy businessmen from NYC (me included LOL.) Others professions on the list were:

Human resources manager in London
Project manager at a financial printing company in London
Investment banker in London
retired architect NYC and Paris
young attorney in NYC
professor in N. Cal
psychologist in NYC
professor in Chicago
Nuclear Arms expert in Wash DC
Political writer in London
Accounting clerk in London
eBay seller from Canada
Fashion model from Paris
Actuary from California
Housewife from California
Computer consultant from London
Computer executive from Northern Cal.

While some of the people on the list are high income earners, there are also those who do not make a lot of money but who save in order to take two or three trips a year for the purpose of dining. You have also twisted around a comment of mine when you said,

"And while experience with fine dining might be necessary to be an authority on high-end restaurants, I'm not convinced that experience alone necessarily makes one an expert."

Nowhere have I made that claim. What I have said is that experience is a fundamental component of being an expert on any topic, and by offering a blended opinion of people who might qualify to be experts, the results are more reliable than other guides on the market.


From Required Eating

Early Returns on New Dining Survey Not So Favorable

I have, in fact, read the book (not cover to cover, but I've looked at it pretty closely), and if you can point out any inaccurate statements I've made I'll be happy to correct them. Out of the top 50 North American restaurants in the book, 32 are either in California or New York state, 15 of them in NYC. Seven are located somewhere besides the east or west coast, two of those in the midwest.

As far my notion of who the book is directed at, it's taken directly from the cover, which says it's "the ultimate guide for destination diners." In your intro, you define this as "someone who plans weekends and vacation travel around dining out." I didn't say there's anything wrong with that--it makes sense to me, actually--but it does take money, especially to eat at the kinds of places listed in the guide. And while experience with fine dining might be necessary to be an authority on high-end restaurants, I'm not convinced that experience alone necessarily makes one an expert.