Get to Know a Serious Eater.

Makanmata's Profile

Website:

Location:

About:

Favorite foods:

Last bite on earth:

The Ten Most Recent Comments By Makanmata

From Slice

It's Not Pizza Napoletana if You Don't Follow the Rules

American's should realize what is going on here, and that this is not something to celebrate as being in the best interest of pizza or pizza lovers. The Associazione is nothing but a trade group of medoiocre pizza makers trying to restrict competition and protect their turf from superior competitors through bureacratic regulations administered from Brussels. It is an outrage that a tourist trap like Brandi (you will hear more German and Japanese spoken there than Italian) should be in a position to tell true artisans such as Da Michaele (which does not comply with the new Rules but serves a vastly better product) and others what they can call their pizza. In fact, its really an outrage that Italy has reached the low point of abdicating its sovereignty to Europe in allowing bureacrats in Brussels to dictate how pizza -- or anything -- can be made in Naples.

From Serious Eats: New York

A Meal at Szechuan Gourmet: Your Weekend Eating Assignment

My only quibble with the post is that Grand Sichuan is no longer any good, and hasn't been in some time. They are now coasting entirely on reputation.

Sichuan Gourmet is the only place in Manhattan to make a proper Water Boiled Fish (they call it something different in English, ask for shui zhu yu), which is excellent.

From A Hamburger Today

Openings: New Pop Burger in Midtown

Pop Burger is in my opinion exceptionally poor. Instead of being troubled to cook you fresh burgers when you place your order, they instead pre-cook them, and throw them back onto the grill to reheat. The result is an overcooked and tastless hockey puck. The other slider place that engages in this practice, and ruins their burgers as a result, is Burke in the Box at Bloomingdales (is that place even still there). In any case, both of these places are amongst the worst in the City and give mini-burgers a bad name.

From Talk

Is frozen durian any good?

What you are seeing in your market are whole durians, which have been imported frozen, then thawed and sold. It is also possible to find whole thai mangosteens in markets in the United States (frequently in Chinatown in Manhattan) but these too have been imported frozen, and sometimes sold after thawing.

From Talk

Is frozen durian any good?

The frozen durians we get in the United States -- both whole and boxed -- are the merest shadow of the fresh fruit, particularly the more highly processed durian in the clear plastic boxes. They will give you a sense of what the fresh fruit is like, but no more than that. Many of the odor notes are entirely lost, and the pungency and taste in general are highly muted. Since part of the fresh durian experience is the extreme strength of these factors, you will of course not get this. Try it, but don't let your experience convince you, one way or the other, whether you like it or not.

Hopefully, irradiated fresh durians -- along with Thai mangoes and mongosteens -- might soon be allowed past the food police in the U.S., and we will be able to get the real thing here.

From Eating Out

Grom Gelato: The New Drug

B&J is junk, plain and simple, please don't get me started on that. Haagen Dazs is quite a quality product though -- at least the simple flavors -- and probably should be more appreciated than it is. But that's rather besides the point.

Its not that Grom is bad (I don't know whether it is or isn't), or not better to any number of alternatives like B&J. Rather, its sad to me that the quality of available foods in New York is such that we have to celebrate a place like this. This gelato might very well be fine, despite the fact that its made in a comissary and shipped long distances. But still, if that's the best available in this town, it doesn't make it any less mediocre, and its sad that we don't have better stuff available. It says a lot about our society and our values that nobody wants to take the effort to do better. I also find it dispiritting that a little song and dance from a PR firm can convince people that a product like this is somehow "artisinal." Flash has so overcome substance that I'm afraid that if a real artisan would appear, he or she would be unlikely to rise (DiFara-like) above the PR noise from the pretenders like Grom.

Your right, that fresh is not necessarily the best, but its no less true that a commercial product like this is virtually certain not to be the best. There is no reason not to enjoy it. There is though, ample reason not to celebrate it too effusively.

From Eating Out

Grom Gelato: The New Drug

I'm sure that the gelato is fine, but it seems to me more than a little sad that the food situation in this town has gotten so bad that people will wait on line, and get so excited, over gelato made from a mix (as per the NYT article, nothing is made on premises, but the mix is shipped from Italy pre-made). For me, this is the real story behind Grom. Its a new low, not a new high. A victory for happy mediocrity.

If anybody wants to support a real artisinal -- or at least something approaching it -- product, the guy selling gelato in Chelsea Market actually makes the stuff himself.

From Required Eating

Hispanic Flavors, Now In Your Grocery Store

I don't know if these are any good or not -- I wouldn't bet on it -- but I would like to point out that Dulce de Leche is not "Hispanic," but rather is more properly designated as "Latin." Americans forget that not all of South America speaks Spanish, and in fact the largest country in South America speaks Portuguese, and is not Hispanic at all. "Doce de Leite," as the Brazilians call this, should therefore be called a Latin flavor, and not an exclusively Hispanic one.

From Talk

Would you eat the meat or drink the milk from a cloned animal?

I absolutely do not care, and shame on Land O' Lakes for joining in the anti-science demagoguery. There is no rational basis which has -- or can be -- stated by anybody against cloned foods. No scientific evidence whatsoever exists to prove or suggest that such food would be harmful, and the speculative musings of Luddites should not be confused with scientific proof. Such anti-cloning, sentiments are based not upon intellectual examination, but upon subjective aesthetic preferences. People are of course entitled to whatever aesthetic preferences they have, but neither anti-cloning, vegetarianism, or any other subjective aesthetic preference should be imposed on the public at large, particularly as these preferences will have the necessary affect of increasing human suffering and starvation.

Cloning stands to revolutionize food production by greatly increasing the quantity of agricultural products. This is a serious threat to the established agro-industrial order, which Land O' Lakes and their ilk are looking to protect. I have no interest in allowing Land O' Lakes and the dairy interests to keep the price of dairy products artificially high, with the massive barriers they have created to insulate themselves from compeitition (do you realize that there are goverment imposed floors on milk prices in the United States to protect these interests?). Land O' Lakes move is just a cynical attempt to keep the present dairy oligopoly intact.

From Required Eating

Mid-Range Burgers

Fuddrucker's, in my opinion, is by far the best chain burger -- up there with the best burgers period -- and well above Red Robin. There used to be two in Manhattan, but they have unfortunately been gone for 10 years or so. The nearest one now is in Paramus. Its well worth the trip.

Responses to Comments by Makanmata

From Required Eating

Mid-Range Burgers

Dude, forget those above, they suck. Seriously though Ruby Tuesday's is the only chain burger that I have eaten that will not only serve it rare, the way meat was intended to be eaten. but it is also Prime. They also have one of the best salad bars I have seen.
If you ever make it out to western Montana try a place in Hamilton called Naps, they will also serve your burger rare. One of the best I have had.

From Required Eating

Mid-Range Burgers

@casmil226 - I agree, Logan's makes a great burger. I think it's the best thing on the menu.
Houston's and J. Alexander's also make delicious burger.

From Required Eating

Mid-Range Burgers

When you survey the remaining restaurants be sure to include Chili's! Chili's has excellent burgers! I can honestly say I've never had a bad burger at Chili's. Unfortunately Ruby Tuesday's depends on the location.........not very consistent between restaurants. I loved the food in Bessemer AL at Ruby Tuesday's but it was HORRIBLE at the one near Loudon TN.........
For fast food, Wendy's seems to be the best. For sit-down dining Chili's is my top pick........

From Required Eating

Mid-Range Burgers

I would try Max & Erma's. I know there are locations in PA but they are worth it. I am picky and while I like Red Robin you can't compare to Max & Erma's. The only other comparison was the Ground Round back in the day when they had like a WinSchulers soft cheese topping. They stopped doing it back in the late 70's and after trying them twice after the change I never would go back.

http://www.maxandermas.com/menu/default.aspx?category=Burgers

From Required Eating

Mid-Range Burgers

I don't know if there is one nearby, but oddly enough I think Logan's Roadhouse (it's a steakhouse) has excellent burgers. Ofcourse I don't think they would cook it MR, but I think they still kick toosh.

From Required Eating

Mid-Range Burgers

Please take time to review Fuddruckers. I am very picky about my burgers, and they have the best of all the national chains I've tried. You gotta love a place that actually offers a full one pound burger patty!

From Required Eating

Mid-Range Burgers

I too recommend Fuddruckers. I am not sure if this franchise is back east but Hamburger Hamlet is also a Red Robin level burger place.

I think its also important to add that at Red Robin you can order your burger Protein Style. They serve this as a low carb option (no bun wrapped in lettuce) and with a salad instead of fries.

From Required Eating

Mid-Range Burgers

I'm not entirely sure if there are other locations outside of california, but there are at least a couple lin the bay area It's called Kirk's Steakburgers. They have the most tender hamburgers i've ever eaten, and you only recieve the patty and the bun from the cook. You get to choose from a variety of sauces and condiments to put on your burger yourself.

From Serious Eats: New York

My Top 10 New York Ice Cream Scooperies

yes Eddies Sweet shop in Forest Hills! Are they still there? oh, for the good old days!

From Serious Eats: New York

My Top 10 New York Ice Cream Scooperies

I second the nomination for Chinatown Ice Cream factory. Their almond cookie ice cream is divine.