Serious Eats - seriouseats.com

I loved Adam. I have watched his new show several times. His humor is fun and he is great on camera but I would definitely like to see him do a cooking show. He is like Guy in that his real appeal is as a personality. I think he will be another star like Guy and will be one to watch- I am sure that Will Work for Food is just the beginning.

I have to agree about Aaron. He just isn't that interesting on his show- I have seen it several times and am just not that impressed or interested in watching it again. He still feels stiff and forced on camera to me and doesn't really have anything compelling to teach as far as food goes. He is another FNS dud like all the others execpt Guy. I think they have had a hard time picking the right winner every season but the second. JAG should have won Season 3 but he took himself out. I would still love to see him get a show on FN. I would like to see Lisa get a real cooking show too. She actually knows food and would bring a different element that is currently in short supply on FN. Aidia, Sonny, Aaron-- all duds

Drama major? No wonder he is so comfortable in front of the camera. So far, the show doesn't suck.

Sorry I'm late ... sorry to Serious Eats, I should say, not sorry to Food Network. I slid by Food Network last night and saw that Adam had a show. I thought it was new! I had no idea he'd won it last summer! Tells you how much I watch FN anymore. First though, good for Adam. Anyone lamenting the fact that Lisa didn't win should look at the current offerings and realize that Lisa cannot save FN with her haute cuisine. If FN wants to fill their schedule with the umpteenth version of "Follow That Food with Gordon Elliott" so be it. The focus is no longer on recipes, at least in primetime where we get to watch people Work For Food, Follow That Food and ask the seemingly endless query How Did That Get On My Plate? +YAWN+

I'm not surprised that Adam got his own show. He was the only one of the final three who had actual personality. It's PAINFUL to watch Aaron's show - regardless of whether he can cook well or not. Aaron has all the perosnality of a limp carrot. Lisa.... same deal, but at least she had personality in her promo show. Aaron's promo showed that even when he's trying to have personality, it's forced. He doesn't have any original ideas - even the idea for his promo show was mainly thought up by others. His vegas 'commercial' was the easiest of the final three - almost as if the people making the contest realized he had no personality or acting talent so they gave him something where you didn't need much to begin with. He should have been dumped from the Next Food Network star back in Vegas when he was hands down the worst contestant, even according to all the 'Vegas' people trying the food. But the judges had a lovefest with him so... eh. One of them saying "The runner stumbles, do you remove him?" Yes. Yes you do - it was a competition - he lost. He should have been dumped.

With Adam, being comfortable in front of the camera seems to come naturally. He's sort of like Guy Fieri. You just -want- to watch him, regardless of whether he's cooking or not. And according to the people in Vegas, he seems to be a good cook as well (according to the Winn chefs). But guess what... you can't transmit taste through the TV. What remains? Personality.

I can't wait to see his show - it's like Dirty Jobs...but with food. Now if they only would realize they chose a dud as the winner. Congrats Adam! And congratulations Food Network on partially fixing your mistake. Finish it by not renewing Big Daddy's Kitchen... House... whatever.

Yawn. Another stupid FN show. I'd watch if Martha Stewart guested. It would be fun to see the horrified look on her face again if Adam serenaded her.

Lisa and Shane - I'd watch.

I think food network is becoming kind of like Microsoft, very bottom line thinking and forgetting to innovate, but rather playing to large market segments ... foodies are ignored ... I would have watched Lisa, I could have learned something from her ... Aaron can cook, but I probably won't watch ... Adam fits the Rachel Ray mold of TV cook, they'll give him a cooking coach and if anyone watches, before long maybe he'll be demo-ing someone elses recipes

that guy wouldn't last two weeks as a line cook on my street in NYC and he got a show on national tv.

I thought Lisa was really talented and really seemed to know her food well. And Adam's show, from the sound of it, doesn't seem to involve actual cooking. The way I figure, both Lisa's and Adam's pilots in NFNS involved actual cooking, which is not something the Food Network seems to be interested in showcasing a lot of these days.

Those bastards over at The Food Network ripped off Adam's pilot idea he had for the finale of TNFNS. Ask Aida? I watched that crap. . .really? It was ridiculous. I am so close to writing off The Food Network for awhile. I'll just blog instead of watching crappy, cranked out food shows. I don't think I will watch Adam's new show in September. If there's no cooking, I don't watch. Too bad. . .

@suthungirl: I completely agree with you.

I actually wanted Adam to win, and felt like he was just overall *better*. His concept was completely original (though as Tahitinova said, we'll never know which came first, Adam or Aida - my money's on Aida), and he made me want to watch, and made me feel like if I wanted, I could be a part of his show.

On another, similarly related topic: what did everyone think of Aaron's show?

I didn't think it was bad per se, but, it seemed kinda choppy in the beginning, with lots of quick camera cuts and edits. Also, I just don't think Aaron has found his groove yet in the show, but, it was also his first episode.

Btw, this is the preview I was talking about seeing:

http://www.foodnetwork.com/food/show_ai/

Ask Aida

I don't mind Adam getting a show (I think he did have an appealing "on-air" personality), I just wish it would have been a COOKING show. This sounds like "Dirty Jobs" for foodies.

And I really hope Lisa gets a shot, too. FN may be 'dumbing down' somewhat, but I think there's a lot of people who would tune into a real 'cooking' show. I think Lisa would be great to fill that missing Ina/Nigella niche.

I'm not surprised, and I don't see a problem with it. The winner gets a show as specified in the contract (a cooking show, x number of weeks, x number of dollars) and any other contestant has the opportunity to get a contract for a different show -- just like anyone who didn't compete can try to get a show. It's not like the whole network is staffed entirely by contest winners. The difference is that the contestants have an "in" with the FN people, so it might be slightly easier for them to get a show. This happens with other reality shows, where the winner gets the stated prize, but the others have a better chance than the average person to snag a contract for something else.

Also -- remember that there was that online vote for your favorite contestant. If Adam scored high on that, it would be silly for FN not to offer him something. Why throw away a person that the target audience has expressed a fondness for?