Keith W.’s Profile

Recent Comments

From Slice

Delisi's Pizzeria & Bar: A Fully Restored Neighborhood Institution

If you look at the posts from "two pizzas," the overwhelming majority of them are bashing Chicago style pizza. He clearly brings value to the community. :)

From Slice

Do You Put Ranch Dressing on Pizza?

Cassaendra's comment makes me nostalgic for the pre-Serious Eats days. A post on "Slice, America's Favorite Pizza Weblog" should never start with "I can't stand pizza to begin with..." :)

From Slice

Slice vs. Vice: Stone-Coal WRONG

I'll admit that I clicked on the tag "truth hammer" hoping to see other examples of Adam meting out justice, and was sad to find that this is the only one.

From Slice

Dear Slice: Una Pizza Napoletana Ain't All That

Going to a place you've never been before with a group is always a mistake. As for my girlfriend and me, we went to Una Pizza a few weeks ago and it was divine. Perfect blend of everything. Definitely didn't miss the toppings! Though I will say that Franny's in Brooklyn (thanks, Adam, for the recommendation!) gives Mr. Mangieri a run for his money.

See more comments by Keith W. ยป

Recent Posts

Keith W. hasn't written a post yet.

Recent Favorites

Keith W. hasn't favorited a post yet.

Recent Polls

Keith W. hasn't answered any polls yet.

Recent Quizzes

Keith W. hasn't taken any quizzes yet.

Recent Comments | Response to Comments

From Slice

Delisi's Pizzeria & Bar: A Fully Restored Neighborhood Institution

If you look at the posts from "two pizzas," the overwhelming majority of them are bashing Chicago style pizza. He clearly brings value to the community. :)

From Slice

Do You Put Ranch Dressing on Pizza?

Cassaendra's comment makes me nostalgic for the pre-Serious Eats days. A post on "Slice, America's Favorite Pizza Weblog" should never start with "I can't stand pizza to begin with..." :)

From Slice

Slice vs. Vice: Stone-Coal WRONG

I'll admit that I clicked on the tag "truth hammer" hoping to see other examples of Adam meting out justice, and was sad to find that this is the only one.

From Slice

Dear Slice: Una Pizza Napoletana Ain't All That

Going to a place you've never been before with a group is always a mistake. As for my girlfriend and me, we went to Una Pizza a few weeks ago and it was divine. Perfect blend of everything. Definitely didn't miss the toppings! Though I will say that Franny's in Brooklyn (thanks, Adam, for the recommendation!) gives Mr. Mangieri a run for his money.

From Slice

Una Pizza Napoletana Reopens Tomorrow Night

@ pizcajj: I went to UPN on Saturday night for dinner, I paid $21 for a small pizza, and I did not feel cheated or ripped off in the least. I look at it like this. If I go to a casual chain restaurant, I pay that much by the time I'm done and I didn't get the quality of food I got at UPN. It was simply amazing food.

I can get perfectly good pizza delivered to my home where I live in New Jersey for around $12 for a large pie, from several different places. They don't follow Anthony Mangieri's strict adherence to old Italian recipes, but they are good in the great-pizzeria-up-the-street way that those who grew up in the NY-NJ area are used to.

I guess what I'm saying is that there is a place in the world of pizza for "gourmet" pizza as well as great slice joints. Just keep an open mind.

From Slice

Una Pizza Napoletana Reopens Tomorrow Night

As far as expense goes, it doesn't seem like it's that insane compared to places like it. Franny's margherita pie is something like $16 for what I'm guessing is a similar portion. Expensive for pizza, but not expensive for a good meal.

From A Hamburger Today

Hungry Jack's Quad Stacker Sparks Outrage

I actually assumed that by "no salad" they meant "without lettuce and tomato"... but I'm not really up on my Aussie slang.

From Slice

John's Pizzeria, a Familiar Taste

I don't care what anyone says, my girlfriend and I love John's. It's not fancy-pants pizza, it's just great. Same with Vinny Vincenz, that place is another of my NYC favorites.

From A Hamburger Today

A White Manna / White Mana Pilgrimage Revisited

I didn't love White Manna (Hackensack) the first time I went, but at the urging of a co-worker we headed there for lunch on Friday. I definitely liked it a lot better the second time around, due in part to the fact that this time I got doubles instead of singles. In my opinion, the doubles have the superior ratio of bun to meat. Also, I found the burger more enjoyable if I let it sit for a bit; the rest allowed the burger some time to solidify and not be a pile of mush like it comes off the grill (albeit a tasty pile of mush).

From Slice

Between the Bars: Kinchley's Tavern and Star Tavern

Looks like I'm a little late to the dance, but I had to weigh in here. Star Tavern is... all right. The flavor is very good, and the atmosphere is awesome in that small-town-dive sort of way, but it's just too damn greasy; the cheese-to-crust ratio is way off. I enjoyed it, my girlfriend (who is more sensitive to grease than me) did not; but like it or not, it's definitely not the best in the area. It's just okay.

From A Hamburger Today

Shake Shack Branch Coming to Upper West Side

Maybe, but it's not like the burgers don't stand on their own; Shake Shack burgers are totally amazing. I for one applaud the expansion as long as they keep the quality level up.

From A Hamburger Today

White Manna in Hackensack to Appear on Food Network

Not too big on White Manna, to be honest. I have the same problem there as I do at White Castle; I like to feel the texture of meat when I bite into a burger. :)

Diners Drive-ins and Dives is a great show, though; I love the shows like that and Feasting on Asphalt that focus on local family-owned places as opposed to the the bigger restaurants. Also, Guy Fieri is a great addition to the Food Network; the network really lucked out that the audience voted for him over that Reggie guy.

From Slice

'Off the Broiler' Visits A Mano in Ridgewood, New Jersey

My lady friend and I visited A Mano on Friday after reading this article... the pizza really was fantastic. Had the Regina Margherita with buffalo mozzarella and it was just delicious. Great crust, great cheese, etc. My only possible gripe was with the dispersion of basil; it seemed like my pie had very little and it was all clumped into one spot, whereas her basil was better distributed.

From Slice

Tough Pizza Critics on 'The Office'

"And, the writers may have rightly sensed that nobody would believe that, say, Domino's or the Hut had better pizza than a local establishment. It's been my observation that no matter how bad a local place is, it's almost always better than a chain."

Actually, where I went to college in Towson, MD, the local places were on the whole far worse than the chains. I ordered from Papa John's and Pizza Hut far more often than from any local place.

From Slice

Which City Has the Best Pizza?

New York is the best.
I've also had New Haven and Chicago.
New Haven: went to Frank Pepe's was amazed at how unimpressive the pizza was. Just really unremarkable and greasy.
Chicago: have only had deep dish. I'll go with Ed in his book where he says that Chicago pizza is tasty but it's not "pizza."

From A Hamburger Today

Union Square Goodburger Opens

Hope this isn't considered off-topic, but I braved the infamous Shake Shack line on Saturday. It was long, but it moved quickly enough and it was a nice day (albeit slightly cold) to sit around outside. And I was definitely impressed with the burger (a double shack burger) and fries. The burger had a nice salty crunch you don't find everywhere.

From Slice

A Slice of Heaven: Chain Pizza

It's interesting, the point about chains keeping cost down. I live in New Jersey, and I called Papa John's the other night before calling my regular place (Villa Victoria in Montclair) to do a price comparison. (I was also, pizza gods please forgive me, considering ordering from Papa John's if the price was right... in my defense, I was at the end of my budget.) I discovered, however, that a large pie at Papa John's was $13, the same as my local place! Plus at my local place I can talk to someone who actually speaks English! Forget the chains!

From Slice

Do You Put Ranch Dressing on Pizza?

How do you get a white trash girl to suck your d**k?

Dip it in ranch dressing.

From A Hamburger Today

A White Manna / White Mana Pilgrimage Revisited

Went to White Manna today... wow.

Fantastic chocolate milkshake as well!

From Slice

Do You Put Ranch Dressing on Pizza?

I don't put ranch on anything! Gross tasting stuff.

From Slice

Do You Put Ranch Dressing on Pizza?

Amen "omnomnom"! (I'm from Mich, too. Same area)

From Slice

Do You Put Ranch Dressing on Pizza?

I absolutely love ranch on my pizza. Granted, I am a middle-school student (though homeschooled), and got the idea from my (middle school, homeschooled) friends after we started dipping French-Fries in Ranch (that's justified in Mich--here most of the fries are way too greasy or way too dry). We decided to try it on our pizza--and it's great. Only Hidden Valley (tm) works though. Deep dish pizza doesn't need it, fortunately. A group fave for us is cayenne pepper, fresh black pepper, ranch, and tabasco sauce. I agree, if it's good pizza, it doesn't need condiments, but (1) pizza in metro-detroit isn't that good, and (2), it doesn't matter if it needs it--if ya want it, I say put it on unashamedly!

From Slice

John's Pizzeria, a Familiar Taste

I moved to nyc in late june and have been to some pizza places. so far co. takes the prize.

the best pizza I have ever had in my entire life was at pinocchios off harvard square in cambridge ma

From Slice

John's Pizzeria, a Familiar Taste

i went to john's last night after reading so much about it all over the internet. I was utterly dissapointed. the pizza was below average by a huge margin. the crust was as plain as cardboard. the tomato sauce tasted like nothing (which is the case with bad canned brands) the ricotta and mozzarella tasted like nothing and the meatball was bland as well. even the onions were kind of tasteless which leads me to the conclusion that he probably got really bad ingredients from his providers recently or jus has bad providers. big dissapointment

From Slice

Do You Put Ranch Dressing on Pizza?

I have NEVER heard of this culinary habit of ranch dressing on pizza until I read this in the Wash. Post:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/05/27/AR2008052700821.html

It just seems like such an incongruous flavor or condiment to add to a pizza.

From Slice

Do You Put Ranch Dressing on Pizza?

Nothing is better than Ham & Pineapple pizza dipped in Ranch.


I hated pizza until I tried it with ranch. Any type of pizza goes great with ranch really except Mexican style, I usually dip that in sour cream.

From Slice

Tough Pizza Critics on 'The Office'

Rudy's had good calzones. We used to order those on Thursdays nights when I worked the copy desk at the Daily Kansan.

From Slice

Tough Pizza Critics on 'The Office'

I never ate at either Pizza Shuttle or Gumby's. I have fond memories of Rudy's but I think that is more because of atmosphere than quality.

From Slice

Tough Pizza Critics on 'The Office'

Allenb: I'd say anything along the lines of Pizza Shuttle and Gumby's, in retrospect. Though to a drunk, poor college student, they were good. Rudy's was basically just a thick hunk of dough with some plasticy cheese and too-sweet sauce.

From Slice

Tough Pizza Critics on 'The Office'

Adam: what places would you consider bad in Lawrence? Because I might have missed those when I lived there.

From Slice

Delisi's Pizzeria & Bar: A Fully Restored Neighborhood Institution

"Why did you pick Chicago. What about the rest of the East Coast. Boston, Philly, D.C., New Heaven, and New Jersey are all better pizza regions. Every thing from Chicago looks like poop." -two pizzas

then you either havent been here or you eat at Pizza hut and Dominoes. Where you from? obviously somewhere out east with that dumb statement you made. Not only are we an amazing pizza region but its so serious that we have three different types. Get familiar so you dont make yourself look like a fool anymore. Ive been to all those places you mention. try Zaffiros in Milwaukee too while your at it.

http://chibbqking.blogspot.com/2008/09/best-pizza-in-world.html

From Slice

Delisi's Pizzeria & Bar: A Fully Restored Neighborhood Institution

Chicago is a huge pizza city, with its own style that you can't find elsewhere. All east coast pizzas from the areas you've mentioned are by and large about the same as a NYC pizza. What's the fun in only including reviews from the same types of places over and over? Also, if you care so much about pizza that you need to repeatedly bash Chicago reviews, you seriously need a new hobby.

From Slice

Slice vs. Vice: Stone-Coal WRONG

Love everyone's enthusiasm on the topic. The correction or maybe more a distintiction (wasn't being harsh, just playful) I was making was that the oven @ Lee's is a brick oven. It is absolutley gas lined with bricks, that is correct. You guys are terrific fun. I thought by the mention of "standard gas oven" you didn't realize it was brick. The smack down is all yours. Enjoy. :)
LOL

From Slice

Do You Put Ranch Dressing on Pizza?

Hey there EatersRegret, I live in the UK and if I can get Ranch dressing here in Wales, I'm jolly sure you can get in in London! My local Tesco has one by Paul Newman. Never had it before so can't compare it with any other makes...bet you can get to a nice deli that would sell it, too!

NO NO NO NOT ON PIZZA!

From Slice

Do You Put Ranch Dressing on Pizza?

What a bunch of snobs. Don't put Ranch on pizza!! Eat whatever you want on pizza.

From Slice

Slice vs. Vice: Stone-Coal WRONG

Yeah. I peeked into the kitchen on Saturday, and saw the same set-up in the BnT Club set of photos. A standard gas-oven, lined with bricks, I'm sure.

From Slice

Slice vs. Vice: Stone-Coal WRONG

It certainly looks like a standard deck gas oven in the Bridge and Tunnel Club shot of their kitchen. If they use an additional brick oven, it's surely not to be found in those photos. You'd think they would have captured it. Perhaps as Ed Levine suggests in Slice of Heaven, they place a brick in there.

Ciao,

Paulie Gee

From Slice

Do You Put Ranch Dressing on Pizza?

I just looked up ranch dressing and DID throw up in my mouth! Never heard of anyone dipping pizza crusts in any kind of dip, never mind what sounds like is probably some mass-produced, salt and fat-fest. You crazy Americans and your food mutilations. I need to cheer myself up by looking at a bird getting eaten by a spider.

From Slice

Slice vs. Vice: Stone-Coal WRONG

@pizza321: Trying to whack the Truth Hammer, are you? ;) I called Lee's and talked to them. They said they do not have a coal-fired oven. They may have a brick oven, but it's not fired with coal. There's a difference. You can have a brick oven fired with gas, wood, or coal -- or even oil in some rare instances. But Lee's said they did not have a coal oven.

From Slice

Do You Put Ranch Dressing on Pizza?

I grew up in OK, but I have lived all over: KS, MO, NC, UT, CA and I have noticed that people eat different things based on where they are from and how they grew up. I don't think its fair to persecute one another for something we've never tried...all great combos had to start somewhere...ie: biscuits and gravy, sweet tea, chicken and waffles, etc. I personally LOVE Ranch or Garlic Dipping sauce on the crust pieces of my pizza, but only on the crust. One thing that I love to do with leftover pizza is top it with cottage cheese and a little black pepper! Call me crazy, but I also believe, its my pizza I can do what I want with it.

From Slice

Do You Put Ranch Dressing on Pizza?

OMG, I think I just threw up a little in my mouth.
Never mind ranch alone, but the thought of ham, pineapple, and ranch ? My goodness, what a sacrilege to the almighty pizza.(NY style of course)
Well does any other really even exist?

I'm a Northern transplant here in the south (NC)
This is where I first discovered people using ranch as a condiment rather then the ones I had been brought up around such as Grated cheese or crushed red pepper .
C'mon, everyone knows if the pizza is good you don't need anything else besides napkins!
Come to think of it, some of the pizza I've tried to choke down here in the south might have actually tasted better with a jar of ranch for dipping!
Now it's starting to make sense.
I finally found a great pizza joint here without having to disgrace the almighty pizza pie!
And I can't stop laughing about Keith W 3:33 10/21/08 comment !

Recent Posts

Keith W. hasn't written a post yet.

Recent Favorites

Keith W. hasn't favorited a post yet.

Polls

Keith W. hasn't answered any polls yet.

Quizzes

Keith W. hasn't taken any quizzes yet.

About Keith W.

Website: http://www.jerseybound.com/

Location: Keith W.

About:

Favorite foods:

Last bite on earth: Two words: Shake Shack. Specifically, a double shack burger and cheese fries.