In step 7, you write "...we often recommend roasting on a wire rack set in a rimmed baking sheet, but the goose renders too much fat for this to be a safe option."
Then in step 8, you write "...transfer V-rack with goose to a rimmed baking sheet. "
HUH??? Am I supposed to dirty yet another piece of kitchen equipment? If so, why? Why not just continue with the already-dirty roasting pan?
I'm with most of the others: "...a Dutch oven isn't cheap, either."
I just bought a Tramontina Dutch oven from WalMart. It was on sale for about $40, but the regular price is less than $60. Mom had a Le Creuset Dutch oven for years, and guess what? The Tramontina is exactly the same, but it doesn't cost $300.
As for this preposterous device: You've got to be kidding me. Unitasker doesn't even begin to describe it. That would be bad enough; but it's small, it's heavy, and you need more skill to slide a loaf into it using a peel than you need to drop a loaf into a Dutch oven.
Hey, to each his own; but to me, anybody who parts with that much money for something like this is out of their mind.
First of all, @DrPaul is correct regarding the volume of liquid that can be produced when roasting. I'd rather not have to worry about overflow, or have to do a balancing act when pulling my turkey or chicken out of the oven. Never mind the difficulty of making gravy or pan sauce without the stuff sloshing out of the pan.
More importantly, I agree with the basic premise: You don't need to spend a lot of money on a roasting pan. The one I have now is pretty good, but it's got handles that swivel, and lay flat against the sides when in rest. Try grabbing those with an oven mitt on!
BUT: A disposable aluminum-foil roasting pan? No thanks. I made that mistake when I hosted Thanksgiving dinner right after I got married nearly 30 years ago. Those things will not hold up to the weight of something like a 22-pound turkey. The stupid thing buckled as I was taking the turkey out, and spilled hot juice all over the counter. It wasn't a total disaster, but I'll never use one of those things again.
"...the knife is going into my drawer..."
HERETIC!!! Knives go on a magnetic knife rack. Never in a drawer! ;-)
I used gas grills for years. Then one spring, I realized some critter had chewed through the rubber hose that transferred the gas from the canister to the burner. Hey, no problem, I thought--I'll just go to Home Depot or go online and order a replacement part! Alas, none were available. So the whole thing went in the trash. Bought a cheap charcoal grill in the meantime, and realized how much better the flavor was.
Fast forward a couple of years, and I started doing low-n-slow barbecue with a cheap cooker that had an offset firebox (so it could be used for grilling or barbecuing). Amazing results. That one lasted a few years, and was replaced by a similar (cheap) offset smoker/grill, which also fell apart way too soon. Still, great ribs, pork butt, etc.
This year I found out about the Pit Barrel Cooker (http://pitbarrelcooker.com/). Let me tell you something--this thing is a revelation. It cost me $300 (free shipping), and it has made the best ribs, pulled pork, chicken, and pork tenderloin I've ever eaten. It's virtually hands-free. You don't have to keep adding fuel or checking on the temperature; you don't have to flip your meat every so often; you don't have to spray apple juice on your ribs to keep them from drying out. I don't know how it works, exactly, but it is the BEST cooker I've ever owned. Check it out. (And no, I don't work for the company, and the owner isn't my brother-in-law.)
Sorry, guys, but given the preponderance of FREE video available online these days, there's no way I'm going to pay for a video on how to make a roast chicken.
And for what it's worth, I can't stand the new layout. I used to visit the site almost daily, but now it's more like once every 7-10 days. It's not nearly as user-friendly as it used to be.
@kenji: "Space constraints"???
It's a web page, dude, not a printed newspaper. You can have all the space you want. It's OK to admit you forgot to mention it in the article.
Is there a good substitute for the arrowroot starch? Can I use corn starch?
I bought my first smoker at Home Depot for about $125. It came fully assembled. That was a lot easier than this contraption. But hey--if it works for you, go for it!
Aside from the food, this sounds thoroughly awful. Hey, Kenji: Be sure to visit your doctor as soon as you get home.
Fat is SO important when it comes to sausage making. I learned the hard way, with my first batch of Italian sausage and my first hot dogs. I'm not averse to fat at all, but just didn't realize how much I needed to include. It's true--40 percent fat would make a lovely sausage. Anything less than 20 percent, and you've got a dry stick of meat.
Interesting. While I get that corporate would want to maintain a certain standard across all their stores, I would think they'd encourage a little creativity here and there. After all, that's how the Egg McMuffin and the Big Mac came to be.
Good for this guy, who's willing to keep things going the way they've been for decades.
What, no recipe?
"...if the bagel is hot and fresh out of the oven, butter. If the bagel has had a chance to cool, cream cheese."
I'm the total opposite. I like cream cheese on a hot (or warm) bagel. Butter is best on a cold bagel. To each his own, as my mom would say.
And the best place to get bagels is at home, using the Cook's Illustrated recipe. Been doing it for years.
@Lanier: "...homemade sourdough pancakes, made with a starter that is older than I am, cooked over a wood-burning stove, and served with real butter and maple syrup in the El Dorado National Forest."
Sounds like Heaven.
Dear God, this looks amazing. Thank you, Kenji.
I love this recipe, and I'm really glad it's baked and not deep fried. Don't get me wrong--I love deep-fried food. I just hate the clean-up involved. Can't wait to try it. Thanks, Morgan!
@Kenji: I've got homemade stock that's VERY gelatinous. Do I really need to add the gelatin to it? I'm concerned it's going to end up way too thick.
I toured the US about 8 years ago, and discovered Whataburger when we passed through Texas. I LOVED IT.
Of course, the best eating places were the non-chain, mom-n-pop places. But yes, fast food can do the trick, and you may as well get the best when you can.
Like Whataburger. Yum.
I've been coveting DeBuyer pans for a long time now. Really want to get a set of them.
Love Popeye's Chicken (and their biscuits are to die for!). And I love Shabu!
Morgan, I love you! ;-)
Great tip about bacon grease on potato skins. I discovered that trick a few months back, and it makes an amazing difference. Thanks for sharing this--I think it's going on my list of party foods!
I had my first bialy at Barney Greengrass, sometime around 1980. It was a revelation, toasted with butter. It's a shame you can't get them in the suburbs. I'll have to try making them from scratch.
I've made that red sauce twice. So good. I love recipes that take hours to cook.
(I'm making the incredible Bolognese sauce tomorrow. Thanks, SE!)
Kinchley's is a treasure; great bar pie, and a classic road-house atmosphere, especially at the bar.
But be forewarned: They don't take plastic. Cash only.