Cincinnatus’s Profile
Recent Comments
Coal-Oven Alert: Fired Up, Palm Bay, Florida
I went on my second visit today to "Fired Up", home to the only coal-fired pizza oven in the wilds of Central Florida.
This is a comfortable place, with booths and tables. Most seats have a view of the aforementioned oven. The service is quick and friendly.
My pizza maven son and I ordered the 16" pepperoni pie ($11.99 plus $1.99 for the topping - reasonable).
The pie had a nice char and leopard spotting , but the corniccione and crust were weak and thin, and tasteless. Perhaps the dough needed more time in the refrigerator to rise ?
The pie was swimming in rendered grease from the pepperoni. The tomato sauce was acceptable , but the cheese was forgettable.
I'll visit this place again in a few months, but right now I wouldn't expend the effort/fuel for a pilgrimage (40 miles) anytime soon.
For those who may be visiting East Central Florida soon , these are my own personal pizza picks for this area :
1. DiLorenzo's, Cape Canaveral
2. Baci's , Rockledge
3. Brooklyn Pizza and Pasta, Viera
Coal-Oven Alert: Fired Up, Palm Bay, Florida
OK, folks. I made the "pilgrimage" to "All Fired Up" this Saturday with my wife and mother-in-law.
I'm a nice guy (really). So , I want to give this joint a second chance.
First off, the restaurant was jammed with 5 little girl soccer teams. The din was amazing and all-consuming. I give the pizzaiolos credit for being able to concentrate and do their jobs.
We ordered a "garbage pie" : large pizza with onion , pepper, half-pepperoni, and half sausage. Hey, I had guests who ordered to suit their palates.
Yes, there is a coal-fired oven. Yes, the pizza was nicely charred and "leopard-spotted". The corniccione was weak tho...
I saw the dough balls being carried from the coolers. They looked perfect. The pizzaiolo tossed and stretched the dough until it was almost transparent. The pies baked miraculously quickly !
Except - the dough was tasteless , and the sauce was almost lacking. This was not a great pie.
I am going to give this restaurant a break , and reserve my final judgement until I can get down there at a less busy time .
All the same, I welcome the concept, and the presence of a genuine coal-fired pizza oven in the wilds of Florida. Bravo.
My Pizza Oven: Mark Wilkie, Windsor Terrace, Brooklyn
Nice job ! I applaud your effort. Great post, and thanks for sharing.
See more comments by Cincinnatus »
Recent Posts
Cincinnatus hasn't written a post yet.
Recent Favorites
Cincinnatus hasn't favorited a post yet.
Recent Polls
Cincinnatus hasn't answered any polls yet.
Recent Quizzes
Cincinnatus hasn't taken any quizzes yet.

Bravo ! Go get 'em Paulie.
You have the passion motivatiion, and skills.
I WILL visit next time I'm in "Greenpernt".