Get to Know a Serious Eater.

Banannah's Profile

Website:

Location:

About:

Favorite foods:

Last bite on earth:

The Ten Most Recent Comments By Banannah

From Serious Eats

David Foster Wallace's 'Consider the Lobster'

Hey Adam, et al. My initial reaction - posted for all to see - reads harshly, and I apologize. I shouldn't have written that. And, I agree with you. Referring to DFW's body of work is certainly a worthy tribute.

However, my comments stem from what I saw as DFW's tragedy in contrast with what I read as a glib post. It's been my experience that other obits on Serious Eats have been written differently and with appropriate sensitivity, even for a site devoted to exclusively to food goodness. This post seemed... off the mark.

Serious Eats is a site that I read often during day. Adam, your posts are among some of my favorite. Please keep up the good work! I am and will remain a fan.

From Serious Eats

David Foster Wallace's 'Consider the Lobster'

Um, the guy just killed himself, and the only thing you have to say is that we should go read his articles and book? Hello? Did I miss something here?

From Serious Eats

How Do We Save Starbucks?

jcherry, I agree.

Honestly. Must we save Starbucks?

While I agree that it's a great place to meet, have a little coffee and relax, it hardly compares to local coffee houses. Why not support the small business guys and gals in our own towns? In many cases, they're sourcing good, fair trade coffee, too. Many have FREE wi-fi. Plenty make breakfast sandwiches in-house that are excellent. They often buy their pastries locally, too. And, if you're really lucky, some even roast their beans on-site. You'll know for sure if it's burnt or just dark-roasted, because you can ask the person who did it!

Besides, have you ever been to a Starbucks (or McDonalds) where you were able to request a new item on the menu or a small change in service and see it actually happen? Small businesses can do that. Corporate chains? Probably not.

From Serious Eats

Pigging Out at Fergus Henderson's St. John Restaurant, London

Oh, marrow! I am so jealous right now. So Jealous. So very, very jealous. It looks lovely. Thanks for posting this one. Especially the marrow. (I'm going to the butcher now.)

From Serious Eats

Cook the Book: 'Savory Bread From the Mediterranean'

The best after-school snack Ever was toasty pita bread with crunchy peanut butter on top. Definitely not authentic, but the memory remains long after my school years school ended.

Responses to Comments by Banannah

From Serious Eats

David Foster Wallace's 'Consider the Lobster'

It's a bummer that Consider The Lobster is getting so much attention on food sites, because it's really kind of reprehensible. --And Mr. Wallace had a ton of writing that was much, much better. Check out The Haphazard Gourmet Girls, to hear what's really going on in Consider The Lobster:
http://haphazardgourmet.blogspot.com/2008/09/supposedly-fun-thing-well-never-do.html

From Serious Eats

David Foster Wallace's 'Consider the Lobster'

Harper's has made public all of his articles for the magazine, in memoriam, here:
http://harpers.org/archive/2008/09/hbc-90003557

From Serious Eats

David Foster Wallace's 'Consider the Lobster'

pourgirl - slightly agree with you. I went to university where Wallace taught, and though many of my English major colleagues worshiped him, I also thought Wallace was extremely self-righteous (and as for self-referential, well, he footnotes himself in his books). However that is part of his genius - almost like Hemingway, a person I would never enjoy being around, but whose writing I like precisely because of this.

From Serious Eats

David Foster Wallace's 'Consider the Lobster'

that is an amazing article. i can't remember if i've ever read anything of his before, but reading that article about lobster, it felt like i had. Perhaps that's because his writing is simply good, and like other good essay writing, draws one in with elegance, intelligence, and challenging ideas. Thanks for posting that.

From Serious Eats

David Foster Wallace's 'Consider the Lobster'

I was sorry to read of this author's death. But if we're discussing his writing, I thought that "Consider the Lobster" was a self-righteous, self-referential slam of the Maine Lobster Fesival. I'm not from Maine and almost never eat lobster, and I came to the piece (which ran in Gourmet) with an open mind. But it seemed like Wallace had no affinity for the event he was supposedly covering, and his contemputous attitude left me with no interest in reading anything else that he wrote.
HIs death is a tragedy, but I can't join the universal acclaim for his writing.

From Serious Eats

David Foster Wallace's 'Consider the Lobster'

"A Supposedly Fun Thing I'll Never Do Again" is perhaps one of the funniest, sharpest essays of the twentieth century. As he usually did, Wallace took an essay about cruise ships and turned it in to a commentary on American life, selfishness and excess. His passing saddens me and I wish hi Godspeed to his next destination.

From Serious Eats

David Foster Wallace's 'Consider the Lobster'

@Banannah: No apology necessary. I didn't take it too harshly. You're probably right. I think because I was writing quickly, I didn't treat DFW with as much thought as I probably would have with more time on my hands. I've hardly read any DFW (but just purchased A Supposedly Fun Thing ... and am catching up), but what I wanted to get across was "Here is an amazingly renown American literary talent who passed from the scene far too early. I assume there are many DFW fans among the readers of Serious Eats, and I know how it feels when a favorite author dies. I wanted to acknowledge his death here and highlight his food-related works—as a reminder to current fans and as a starting point for food-minded, would-be DFW readers." Thanks for taking the time to comment. I'm sorry this seemed glib.

From Serious Eats

David Foster Wallace's 'Consider the Lobster'

Hey Adam, et al. My initial reaction - posted for all to see - reads harshly, and I apologize. I shouldn't have written that. And, I agree with you. Referring to DFW's body of work is certainly a worthy tribute.

However, my comments stem from what I saw as DFW's tragedy in contrast with what I read as a glib post. It's been my experience that other obits on Serious Eats have been written differently and with appropriate sensitivity, even for a site devoted to exclusively to food goodness. This post seemed... off the mark.

Serious Eats is a site that I read often during day. Adam, your posts are among some of my favorite. Please keep up the good work! I am and will remain a fan.

From Serious Eats

David Foster Wallace's 'Consider the Lobster'

@ArtoriusRex: You're right. I should have linked to DFW's Wikipedia page and an obit in a newspaper. I was in a hurry to get this blogged and get on with my weekend, as you guessed. Anyway, after seeing your comment, I linked to his Wikipedia page and the obit, which I believe is enough background for Serious Eats. If properly linked (and I admit this item was not properly linked when you first saw it), you have the option to click out and gather background outside the scope of the SE post, if you are just coming to the story for the first time. We are primarily about the food, so we are going to blog something like this from a food angle (as we have in previous obits). We do like to acknowledge what's going on in the world at large and pay tribute to people whose work we've enjoyed—as long as we can tie it to food.

@Banannah: See above. I think cheeseburger, thatgrrl, and NYminknit give the reaction I would have given. I could have been more sensitive in the copy and expressed condolences, but apart from that, we don't really go much into cause of death, etc. Our operating principle in our "obits" is to highlight the food goodness that the decedent brought to the world.

From Serious Eats

David Foster Wallace's 'Consider the Lobster'

Thanks for mentioning his passing. I've read DFW's fiction, but somehow I've missed his nonfiction. I've got several books of his books, including Consider the Lobster and Other Essays, on order now. I'm looking forward to reading it, although it's really sad that it took his death to bring me back to his work.