Best Strawberry Shortcake in NYC

Hi - just following up. I ended up going old school with Veniero's and it was a hit at the party. The whole cake was gobbled up and all our guests were commenting on how fresh & flavorful it was.

Thanks everyone for the tips!

Best Strawberry Shortcake in NYC

My father's favorite cake is Strawberry Shortcake. I'd like to order one for his birthday next weekend. Any suggestions on where I can order the best?

I read a post here on Serious Eats NYC from back in 2008 touting the following:

Cafe Zaiya
Panya Bakery
ChikaLicious Dessert Club

Do these still hold up and does anyone have any other suggestions?


BKGnome hasn't favorited a post yet.