Ideas for a mint substitute in juleps?

I enjoy doing juleps in honor of the Kentucky Derby (or, of course, just because they're tasty). I have a sensitivity to fresh mint- it has always given me a raging sore throat. Dried mint tea and peppermint oil flavoring are not a problem for some reason, but fresh mint and I do not get along. Last year I found a great 1840's julep recipe involving port and cognac that seemed like it could play well with other herbs. I tried substituting thyme in one cocktail and basil in another, but they lacked the freshness and crispness of flavor that the mint had. I stole a sip of my husband's cocktail using mint and it's 500% better. Any clever ideas for something with an aromatic punch and brightness of flavor on par with fresh mint?

Serious Eats Newsletters

Keep up with our latest recipes, tips, techniques and where to eat!


Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment: