Cooking and Baking

Molasses Spice Cookies - AMT Recipe Question

In the attempt to bring some fall cheer to my roommate and classmates tomorrow, I decided to try the America's Test Kitchen Molasses cookie recipe. I tried them once before, made by a friend, and they were amazing! I was hoping to replicate his fantastic results.

So, the problem: the cookies didn't crinkle! They are supposed to crack/crinkle, according to the picture, but mine didn't - and I'm trying to figure out why.

Changes I made to the original recipe:
- No stand mixer in this kitchen, so I did everything by hand [although the recipe calls for a stand mixer]
- I doubled the recipe

The recipe does mention that cookies baked on the top shelf of the over will crack, while ones baked lower in the oven will stay smooth. I did try moving the rack up, and there was slight crinkling, but definitely not the same amount as the pictures.


Talk is closed, but that doesn't mean the conversations have to stop!

Check out this post for a more thorough explanation, and jump onto our Facebook page or our Twitter feed to keep the conversations going!


Comments are closed