Fraudulent Charcoaling?

Adam recently linked back to a post that mentions going through 3 or 4 chimneys worth of charcoal.

That reminds me of a question -- do the amounts of coal used on TV shows match your reality?

The America's Test Kitchen demos always show surprisingly small amounts of coal in use -- their cookbooks are similarly frugal, with advice like "3/4 of a chimney" during long and slow cooking.

But in practice I've found that unless I really fill my (big Weber brand) chimney to the point where the coals form a dome and start overflowing, I don't really have enough coals to either (a) completely cover the grill or (b) last more than a cycle or two of grilling. It doesn't matter if the coals are to be "banked" to one side either. I'm using regular old Kingston brand.

Does this match your experience?

Serious Eats Newsletters

Keep up with our latest recipes, tips, techniques and where to eat!


Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment: