A Salt and Battery or Gray's Papaya?

Weird topic, I know.

I'm going to be in New York Thursday afternoon/evening before an event at Columbia, and I will be able to consume only *one* meal (plus, of course, dessert). I spent a lot of time in the city last year and have been to most of the restaurants on my "must eat" list, but these two (among others) have yet to be visited. I'll be back in a month or so (I live in Cambridge), but if you had to pick just one for dinner, which would it be?

Additional information: After fish and chips at A Salt and Battery, I would likely be obtaining a toasted marshmallow shake at Stand. After hot dogs at Gray's Papaya (duh), I would procure a concrete at Shake Shack.

Help me out!

Serious Eats Newsletters

Keep up with our latest recipes, tips, techniques and where to eat!


Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment: