Thanksgiving Day Appetizer Suggestions
My dad is flying in fairly late--arrival at 5:45--so dinner is not going to be until 7:30. I am having three or four other people over probably starting around 3:00 or 4:00. What can I have around for people to nosh on that isn't going to interfere with the feast to come?
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

21 Comments:
chicken liver or foie pate and croutons! autumnal and preview of luscious meal to come.
emilytaylor at 10:34AM on 11/06/09
i'm a big fan of mushrooms in puff pastry- chop and sautee some wild mushrooms in butter with some salt, pepper, lemon juice, 1 clove of garlic, and thyme, remove from heat, mix in some cream cheese until it's evenly distributed, then spoon into small puff pastry shells and bake.
mr guy at 10:48AM on 11/06/09
We do a baked brie en croute with cranberry conserve and nice crackers, I put out nice cold grapes.
JerzeeTomato at 10:49AM on 11/06/09
I try to put some simple nibbles out that don't take much work or effort on my part because my focus is on making the dinner portion.
I usually put out a cheese platter allowing guests to experiment with different cheeses. I do put out some "safe" cheese too (mild cheddar, jack, brie, etc.) I add a variety of crackers, crisini, some honey or fig jam, fresh fruit and the appetizer is done.
I set out a plate of sausage bites with picks (salami or summer sausage) to nibble on. Some hummus or other dip with some raw vegetables, a salmon or smoked fish spread (mousse) too.
I fill a small bowl with little pretzel sticks and open a jar or make some honey mustard to accompany it.
I place little bowls of nuts around the room and on end tables.
That's plenty of nibbles for all.
I would put some shrimp and cocktail sauce out too, but the hub is allergic to shrimp.
CJ McD at 11:44AM on 11/06/09
Forgot to add-
Most of my family (mother, cousins, young children etc.) do not have adventurous palates, so I do try to serve foods they will eat yet get them to try a few new things too.
Some times it works....
CJ McD at 11:47AM on 11/06/09
I find that wrapping anything in store-bought puff pastry makes it "fancy" and a big hit. Whether it's caramelized apples, onion and fontina, sauteed mushrooms with cream cheese (as mentioned above!), chicken curry (not quite "thanksgiving", but delicious) or chicken sausage for a fancy pig in a blanket - most can be made a day ahead of time and popped in the oven when you're ready to serve.
Also: spiced pumpkin seeds are great nibbles, seasonal and super easy to make.
mookie at 11:55AM on 11/06/09
I love the idea of puff pastry or phyllo appetizers, but wouldn't work at house. Our oven is "taken" on Thanksgiving relagating additional items to microwave, slow cooker, Nescos, stove top, grill, etc.
CJ McD at 2:13PM on 11/06/09
Agree about the pastry. Try ground cooked sausage mixed with spicy tomato sauce and cheese baked in pastry rounds.
I also do mini-quiches a lot. Salmon, broccoli and stilton, in a small pastry pan, with the egg spooned over the filling. Top with a little cheese before baking (and keep an eye on them...the pastry will turn on you if you don't watch it.)
Kebabs are also good...maybe thick chunks of lamb with haloumi, plum tomatoes, mushrooms and onions. Cook in a hot pan with olive oil and garlic, maybe a few sprigs of rosemary. Keep the lamb pink.
I also really like seared strips of beef, served on a roasted tomato filled with horseradish cream. And batter-fried nuggets of shrimp and sliced fish fillet, with a selection of sauces (I'd go with aioli, cocktail sauce, and a lime mayo).
To end on a '70s classic, a whole wheel of Camembert with the yop rind sliced off, covered in sliced almonds, brown sugar and butter, chucked in a hot oven until melty and caramely, and served with fresh crusty bread.
NotAmerican at 2:20PM on 11/06/09
The pastries / mini quiches / baked brie should all work out in a decent toaster oven if you have one available. Just keep your eye on them since the temperature / timing isn't as reliable as a proper oven!
mookie at 3:02PM on 11/06/09
A simple soup, held in a slow cooker, served in mugs with some oyster crackers would stave hunger among the waiting famished but not be too heavy before the main feast.
CJ McD at 3:44PM on 11/06/09
We've always done crudites with a fairly light dip. Makes a real texture contrast with most of the Thanksgiving meal proper.
Also do the old Hellman's pine cone recipe. I use neufchatel & light Hellman's, and the original used 12 oz cream cheese to the same amount of herbs. Makes a great dip, or form into an airfoil and shingle pecans onto the surface at the last moment.
8 oz light cream cheese (Neufchatel) (Nuke for 30 sec or so)
~1/4 cup grated parmesan
~1/8 tsp garlic powder
~1/2 tsp dried oregano
lemonfair at 8:23AM on 11/08/09
I make my own version of boursin cheese and stuff the multi colored sweet mini peppers with them. Way better and cheaper than store bought, I use roasted garlic cloves and fresh herbs. I also like to make portobellos stuffed with chopped artichoke hearts, parm cheese and the above mentioned boursin.
I also use the boursin shmeared between stacks of salami rounds, then quartered and toothpicked.
MNLisaB at 10:55PM on 11/09/09
Not very gourmet, but a crowd favorite is pepperoni dip
Mix
1 brick cream cheese
Cut up slices of pepperoni
1 can Cream of Celery soup
in a small crock pot, stirring occasionally until well combined. Serve with crusty bread. People at our parties stand over this dish in delight!
sleepgh at 9:47AM on 11/10/09
thanks for all the suggestions. i am definitely looking for something that does not have to go in the oven and that can be made ahead so i can just stick it out and work on the rest of the meal. i do think the soup in the slow cooker is a great idea, also.
carriebwc at 9:55AM on 11/10/09
I do what my mom did back in the 1950's: celery sticks stuffed with cheese (either flavored cream or boursin style goat), pickle wedges and or/cornichons, black olives. Crackers and the cheese I pipe into the celery is also there for something a bit more substantial. My kitchen is tiny and I have no room to bake anything that isn't on the main menu. It all sits on the pass through so everyone can come eat what they want from little plates and I get to visit with them while I cook.
queenbleu at 12:00PM on 11/10/09
I think I am going to make the same soup that I made last year - it was a hit. Roast a Red Kuri Squash (or any other that strikes your fancy) the night before. You may need more than one squash depending on how many people - we had 4 and there was plenty of leftover soup. On Thanksgiving, scoop it out and put in a soup pot. Add 1-2 cans of light coconut milk, as much red Thai curry paste as you can handle. Buzz with a stick blender or put it in your blender until smooth and add water or broth to thin to your desired consistency. You can let this sit in a slow cooker all day. Serve with croutons if you want a bit of crunch and a dallop of sour cream or yougurt.
We also had the cheese/cracker/bread plate.
flamingo at 12:39PM on 11/10/09
I also like to put out cheese and crackers with a homemade chutney or jam. It'll be quince chutney and either manchego or goat cheese this year. I also like to serve soup, usually Rachael Ray's cauliflower soup, which is really good with a fresh head of cauliflower from the farmers market. Can be made a couple weekends ahead and frozen too.
Otabenga at 1:25PM on 11/10/09
bonappetit has a great recipe for pickled shrimp in the december issue that you can make ahead. it would also be really adaptable with any kind of seafood. i like the idea of something light like veggies or maybe an interesting ceviche. also one of my favorites is to use endive leaves as a wrapper for some kind of filling like crab/chicken salad etc.
oregonpinot at 9:44PM on 11/10/09
I do deviled eggs, some dips with veggies, and spiced nuts. You don't want to go too heavy.
karen r at 12:20PM on 11/11/09
I like to put some cranberry chutney on top of camembert or brie and bake it, then serve it with gingersnaps for a bit of a difference. I also just posted my Thanksgivign Popcorn, which is a great nibble with drinks or if you watch a game or the parade.
TheRunawaySpoon at 7:41PM on 11/11/09
The choice of appetizer often is determined by budget.
For an inexpensive option, deviled eggs are great and amp them up a bit by adding small, chopped salad shrimp to the yolk mixture for a tasty surprise!
Or for a fancier option, go with mini crab cakes or crab balls. I was served these before the big meal at a relative's house one year and they were delicious!
Just two suggestions that have worked for my family with great results!
jlewfoodie at 12:46AM on 11/12/09