Why Fish and Red Wine Don't Mix
It's iron! from Science news.
I think citrus have natural iron chelators (that masks iron), though.
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

8 Comments:
So what does that say about pinot noir and salmon, one of the classic combinations?
lemons at 3:37PM on 10/23/09
Don't try to put that big fish in the blender without cutting it up first. LOL
tusti at 4:06PM on 10/23/09
neet.
In my wine training during my time in the service industry we were always told that it was a bit 'pasé' (sp?) or faux-pas to say that you HAVE to drink a white with fish and red with red meat (etc.) because we were told that people will choose the colour before anything else and that its not the colour that "pairs" with the food but the environment the grape was raised in. And people who like red; just drink red kinda-deal.
Not sure I ever really believed it but the chemical reactions between the two is much more of a sound explaination to me. Interesting...
hungrychristel at 4:36PM on 10/23/09
There are many reds that are great with seafood. I love Pinot with oily fish, but a lightly-chilled Cote de Rhone, Rioja or Valpolicella is great with anything from the sea; just nice, soft fruit that doesn't overwhelm delicate flavours in the dish.
I had a roommate who was obsessed with wine, yet knew nothing about it. When he learned red wine is supposed to be served 'warm' (meaning cellar temperature) he started keeping bottles on top of the radiators or on the back of the stove. He was stupid for a lot of other reasons as well, but I'll never forget that. Cheap red wine, served at the temperature of a comfy bath.
NotAmerican at 5:35PM on 10/23/09
@NotAmerican - wine on the radiators?!?! here comes the roflcopter
joyyy at 5:40PM on 10/23/09
@NotAmerican...That is so funny, I can't stop laughing!
"He was stupid for a lot of other reasons as well.."
Hilarious!!
Silvia at 6:18PM on 10/23/09
@lemons-
from the original paper (they tasted a varieties of wines but don't know if they included pinot noir..):
"Thirty-eight commercial full- and medium-bodied red wines from France, Italy, Australia, Chile, Japan, Spain, the United States, Argentina, Hungary, New Zealand, and South Africa, 26 commercial dry and semisweet white wines from France, Italy, Japan, the United States, Germany, Spain, Chile, New Zealand, and South Africa, 2 sherries, and 1 each of port, madeira, and botrytized wine were purchased in Kanagawa, Japan. A red wine containing 8.0 mg/L of iron was selected from wines additionally purchased."
and iron contents vary in wines:
"In daily life, it is difficult to predict the iron content in a bottled wine without opening it. It is a still a problem for the customer because the content of iron is not related to wine type (Figure 1A,B) or the country of origin. In fact, iron content depends on the winemaking process, that is, the iron content of the soil, the dust on the berry, contamination during harvesting, transportation, and crushing, and absorption or adsorption by yeasts during fermentation."
I was surprised they got away with saying "fish and seafood" by testing only scallops.
Because mollusks use hemocyanin (copper) instead of hemoglobin (iron) as an oxygen carrier, their study's conclusion may be totally different when using, say, tuna/jack- which contain a lot of iron!
hmw0029 at 7:40PM on 10/23/09
I think it depends on the preparation of the fish. I cook a lot of fish and I love red wine. I like to pair lighter reds with creamy fish dishes and more robust reds with fish prepared with tomatoes and fresh herbs.
yayfood at 10:38PM on 10/23/09