Weekend Lunch for 10 people in November

I had such great results from my last query, I am counting on ya'll in Talk to help me out with a harder request. Have 10 college mates coming to NYC in mid-November for an annual get together. They have been enticed to leave the tri-state 'burbs and visit NYC for lunch, and since I am the only native left, the decision of where to go lies with me. However.... I need to work around the following preconceived notions:

- NYC is very expensive - I've eaten in their towns, the difference is negligible!

- There is too much "weird" food - This includes sushi and Thai, and probably un-Americanized Chinese.

- Scared/unable to navigate complicated subway directions - it must be off one line originating near Penn Station.

This is a lovely group of people but I am stumped. Otto is typically my large group fall-back, but I'd actually like to try someplace else if anyone has good ideas!

Serious Eats Newsletters

Keep up with our latest recipes, tips, techniques and where to eat!


Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment: