Breakfast, the most important meal of the day? Really?
I have heard this my entire life and I agree. But why? Is it really the most important? If so, is there a type of food that is more important than another? Are you supposed to have high carbs to burn throughout the day? High sugar, for a quick burst of energy? Citrus? Protein? Should it be a big meal since you haven’t eaten in hours or a small meal since you haven’t eaten in hours?
Does anyone know anything about what is BEST for us first thing in the morning?
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

27 Comments:
I think the idea is that breakfast gets your metabolism going in the morning so it's the most important from a health standpoint. And you tend to be more lethargic without breakfast.
But I'm not a doctor or anything, so maybe I'm way off.
As a sad aside, I can't eat ANYTHING for at least an hour and a half after waking up. I dunno why...my body doesn't seem to work early in the morning.
lawofmurphy at 11:20AM on 09/09/09
huh... I have to eat as soon as possible... if I don't, I won't wake up till lunch.
happyeats at 11:31AM on 09/09/09
By the time breakfast comes around, you haven't eaten for 12 hours. That is a long time. To maintain a healthy metabolism and avoid drastic changes in blood sugar, one should eat something every 3 - 4 hours. So, it is particularly important to break your 12 hour fast. Every cell in your body needs energy. Your cells make energy (in the form of a molecule called ATP) from glucose (found in all food). ATP is important for your brain to function properly as well. You'll be more alert and think better. Additionally, if you are starving by lunch because you skipped breakfast, you'll tend to overeat or make poor food choices. Sort of like when you've been drinking. You're just so hungry you don't care what you put in your mouth or how much.
As far as what to eat. High sugar should never be an option under any circumstances. It is bad in more ways that I am willing to type here. You should have a balance between carbs, fat, and protein. Perhaps an egg sandwich with tomato, oatmeal with walnuts, yogurt with fruit and granola, multigrain waffles with fruit and milk. Even cereal will do or a smoothie if you have to run out the door.
I am not a doctor, but I am a biologist. We tend to know more than doctors because they don't necessarily know the biology behind bodily functions. Don't believe me? Ask your doctor about how your cells make ATP. Note: Your endocrenologist may know this.
Barbieri13 at 11:43AM on 09/09/09
@Barbieri13
I believe you! Please don't hurt me :P
lawofmurphy at 12:03PM on 09/09/09
Breakfast is definitely very important. It gives your body its first fuel of the day. It doesn't have to be a big breakfast or even breakfast food but you should put SOMETHING in your stomach before embarking on your day.
Are you familiar with "famine mode"? It's the defense mechanism utilized by the body when there is a calorie deficit. It means that people who try to accomplish weight loss by skipping meals and going hungry force their bodies to slow down and utilize less calories (and thereby fat). The body says, "Oooooh there's no food around so I'd better conserve what energy I have." Breakfast not only prevents famine mode and the eventual hunger you will feel by 10:30 but also the subsequent danger of gorging at lunch.
therealchiffonade at 12:35PM on 09/09/09
Breakfast allows you to stockpile your energy for the day!
Personally: Lunch is my biggest.
I try to eat the smallest supper possible since I tend to hit the hay shortly after and you do not burn those calories.
Interestingly enough: western society has this all wrong. I grew up in a German-influenced household and we always had coldcuts, cheeses and grain breads for breakfast; large meal like a stew, roast or pasta at lunch and then the coldcuts, cheeses and grain breads again for supper
hungrychristel at 12:37PM on 09/09/09
A ham sandwich with cheese on whole wheat bread would be a great breakfast! Protein, fat, and carbs. I'd add a tomato and have a fruit with that, however.
Barbieri13 at 2:29PM on 09/09/09
I work all night and wake up everyday around 11 or 12 ( alright, sometimes 1 p.m.). Since I completely skip breakfast time altogether, what should I eat?
I'm generally not hungry when I first wake up and instead opt for a glass of juice or water (alright, sometimes Diet Coke). I cook a serious meal and eat around 3 p.m. and then don't really eat again, except maybe for a small snack like yogurt or peanut butter toast later in the evening. Is this incredibly bad?
PumpkinBear at 3:29PM on 09/09/09
If I eat breakfast though I eat all day.
chardonnay at 3:44PM on 09/09/09
I lived in Northern Europe for a while and I used to LOVE having deli meats and cheese sandwiches for breakfast!
yayfood at 3:59PM on 09/09/09
Everyone is different but from my own personal experience running a breakfast blog for the past 2 months the mornings when I go for oatmeal, smoothies or have a yogurt parfait with berries & granola I feel the best.
I still love donuts, bagels and egg sandwiches which I find in moderation with exercise works fine for me.
http://eagle-eye-breakfast.blogspot.com
breakfast_fool at 4:10PM on 09/09/09
I'm glad I'm not the only one that likes having sandwiches for breakfast (ham and cheese or pb&j on a bagel or toast or an english muffin). It's just such an easy option. If I don't eat breakfast then I get really hungry around mid morning and I'll shove some sort of fattening pastry in my mouth during my break. I find it easier/cheaper/healthier to eat some cereal or something early in the morning.
gingercookiewithlime at 6:06PM on 09/09/09
Sorry, it may be wrong but I just am not hungry in the morning. If i'm not hungry, i'm not going to eat. It's that simple. I'm not overweight and do not gorge myself from hunger when I do get hungry around 12:30, 1pm. Also, every so often when I do want something early, I eat. So far I'm fine! (Knock on wood).
sassy at 7:34PM on 09/09/09
People of the past and still who do/did physically hard work in all sorts of weather conditions would eat a big breakfast for energy. Now more and more people have desk jobs really don't need to have such an huge breakfast unless they do some sort of vigerous work out before work. I do love breakfast (the hearty kind) but I do not like to eat it in the morning, so I have breakfast at dinner lol. For me in the morning all I want is chai tea latte.
pjracz10 at 7:41PM on 09/09/09
@chardonnay - are you eating carbs for breakfast? This is a common problem when carbs are the first food eaten. Try protein in the way of an egg dish, or yogurt - or try a "smoothie" that has yogurt, ice, and fruit. I sometimes put bran in my smoothies but you'll be looking to scrape it off your teeth with your tongue. I have to sneak bran in any way I can (sigh). I generally eat oatmeal but if I find it sets me on an endless hunger throughout the day, I'll switch off to protein for breakfast for a while.
therealchiffonade at 7:54PM on 09/09/09
It happens to me too, I love breakfast (not always eaten around 6-9 am though), irrational love for pancakes perhaps. I'm not a doctor, biologist or anything of that sort. I will tell you though that I'm generally in a better mood and more focused on classes since I started eating something in the morning (a few times it's actually pancakes).
mtgall at 9:06PM on 09/09/09
For at least 40 years, even the idea of breakfast before being up at least two hours made me sick; eating it made me sicker - my digestion just plain didn't work. Now things have changed a little, and if I'm hungry after I've been up a while (minimum of an hour), I eat - usually leftovers from yesterday's dinner. If I'm not hungry, I save them for lunch. Coffee, however, is necessary upon awakening, and I have always thought of that as my breakfast. Other people, other practices - it all depends on what works for you. It's silly to follow a rule just because it works for someone else.
Likeswords at 9:28PM on 09/09/09
i usually start with a big cup of coffee (cafe con leche) and that holds me over for about an hour .... then i try to eat protein ... usually a fritatta with the night before's leftover vegetables.... if find that usually keeps me until late afternoon. then i'll have a cup of tea with a piece of cheese or something.... we tend to eat dinner late. a no-no.... bad habit after working for years in the food business. but i agree with the "if you eat breakfast thing you won't go crazy eating the wrong things during the day" camp.
pooch at 10:04PM on 09/09/09
Ooh, I NEED to eat breakfast! I can sleep in with the best of them but if I start to get hungry my body won't leave me alone until I put something in it. Usually some variation of hot or cold cereal (lately oatmeal or Cheerios) with fruit and soy milk, along with my giant cup of gunpowder tea. It definitely helps my metabolism throughout the day. My breakfasts are never high in protein but I'm a vegetarian who loathes eggs and no longer buys fake meat so there you go.
VerySmallAnna at 10:32PM on 09/09/09
I'm another of those who can't eat upon awakening. My stomach doesn't wake up till a couple hours after I do. When I was working an office job I used to take both breakfast and lunch bentos. By the time I arrived at the cafeteria, half an hour before work, I was hungry enough to eat.
gentlyferal at 10:49PM on 09/09/09
If I eat a healthy breakfast, I eat healthy all day. If I eat a pastry, the next thing you know I'm devouring Snickers and fries. For me, that's why it's the most important meal.
sorahatch at 11:31PM on 09/09/09
I get wayyyyy too hungry if I don't eat breakfast. I got an office job a few months after finishing school, and I've needed three meals a day ever since.
joyyy at 11:54AM on 09/10/09
I usually wake up starving and head to the gym that way. When I get back, I'm really super starving, so breakfast is never optional. Usually it's steel cut oats with a fried egg and sriracha, mini babybel cheese on the side. On weekends, breakfast burritos.
And 2 cups of coffee with milk. Also non-optional!
bitchincamero at 12:22PM on 09/10/09
I love breakfast and it's probably my biggest meal of the day. I don't eat meat, so I make sure to get lots of protein at breakfast and it energizes me for the whole day. By the time dinner rolls around, I'm tired from a long day and just not that hungry. I usually cook dinner for my husband and me and end up saving most of mine for lunch. I would personally rather eat a light meal at night so I'm not uncomfortable all night long and wake up hungry. But, I guess it's to each his own.
MeganCochran at 2:40PM on 09/10/09
Protein is important at breakfast. Your brain need protein to function properly. School children need a healthy breakfast to help them through the day, brain food is protein. So foods rich in eggs are always a good choice for breakfast, cheese, milk, lean meats, whole grain breads and cereals and a little fat won't hurt to stick to your ribs.
The reason you are hungry all day after a carbo laden starter meal is that your body processes them quicker and leave you hungry again. Not so with protein. Same at night with a snack before bed - eat cheese and crackers or some protein like yogurt or egg and you won't wake up famished either.
lurah at 1:57AM on 09/11/09
2 beers!
daemon at 11:12AM on 09/11/09
I eat whole grain oatmeal every weekday before heading to the gym. Without it I find my exercise more difficult. When I leave the gym my stomach always wants food again - I usually eat one or two hard boiled eggs and a piece of fruit (usually a banana), which fills me up good. If I don't eat anything I don't wake up and I can't concentrate until after lunch.
I do have sausage, egg and cheese on a toasted bagel every once in a while after the gym. Tasty! And eggs sunny-side up with toast on the weekends is a must.
EliEats at 1:15PM on 09/11/09