Making homemade yogurt not so tart!
I made yogurt for the first time with one of those machines and was expecting it to be lush, creamy and delicious. It was sort of creamy and super super super tart. I guess that is because it is unsweetened like commercial brands, so:
Does anyone have favorite recipes/tips for how to make homemade yogurt creamier and tastier? I'm not one for the super tart/sour yogurt. I know I can mix in fruit but are there any other suggestions?
Thanks!
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

10 Comments:
I wouldn't know where to begin to help you, but we eat in an Afghani establishment in Old City Philly and they make their own yogurt and it one of the best tastes I have experienced. They serve it on their salads.
Maybe you have someone or an eatery in your neighborhood that would apprentice you.
janaatwg at 11:09AM on 08/09/09
Do you usually eat plain yogourt with nothing in it? I don't find homemade yogourt to be more tart than plain natural yogourt from the store. Industrial yogourt is another story they use all kinds of milk by-products and other additives to modify the texture and taste. I eat plain yogourt for breakfast five days a week and I can't eat it without adding some sort of sweetener. My standby is honey. You don't need a lot to cut the tartness. You could certainly add jams, jelly, preserves, maple syrup, cane syrup, raw sugar or brown sugar. Whatever tickles your fancy. I think most cultures where yogourt is traditional eat it either sweetened or salted. Only hippies eat there yogourt plain.
SqueezeBottle at 12:02PM on 08/09/09
full fat milk and a shorter curing time make for less tang.
cybercita at 12:18PM on 08/09/09
I am made of bad grammar. I apologise.
SqueezeBottle at 12:27PM on 08/09/09
The longer it sits, the more tart it becomes. If you stop the fermenting sooner, it will be less tart. Also, it depends on the yogurt culture you're using. Some are more tart than others.
Personally, I find that homemade yogurt has an tart/astringent quality that I don't like for plain eating, until I strain it. Which makes it much thicker and creamier and that astringent taste goes away. I used the whey strained from the yogurt when I make bread, so it doesn't go to waste. Maybe that's part of what you're tasting?
dbcurrie at 1:42PM on 08/09/09
I agree with DBCurrie--I've strained mine to get rid of the whey and it loses its tartness completely. That being said, when I've drained mine, I lose a LOT of the original yogurt content. What's left is thick and DELICIOUS, but know that you will lose a significant amount of yogurt by doing so.
Enjoy!
luswim06 at 3:00PM on 08/09/09
My family encounters the same problem when making yogurt at home. If you shorten the fermenting time, it comes up thinner. If you use whole milk, the fat content goes up a good bit. I try to avoid using whole milk because of this. Instead, we add a couple Tablespoons of nonfat dry milk powder to each batch and it helps with the thickness. The milk powder increases the... "milkiness" (??) while keeping the amount of liquid the same and the amount of fat low.
I havent done much straining, so I cant say how much it helps the tartness. I plan to try it, and make some yogurt-cheese too. :]
engmcmuffin at 3:22PM on 08/09/09
@squeezebottle, very interesting statistic about hippies and plain yogurt. where do you get your information?
cybercita at 10:30PM on 08/09/09
Thanks everyone. I will try using a shorter time period, straining and also someone suggested testing different starter yogurts (I had used the dried stuff that came with my yogurt maker).
Thanks!
shaofan at 10:38PM on 08/09/09
@shaofan, i've tried adding milk powder to my yogurt as suggested by alton brown. it turned out to be a really bad idea.
cybercita at 10:42PM on 08/09/09