Master Cookbooks
I was looking into purchasing a cookbook. Not just nay cookbook but one of those big,almost encyclopedic ones that have recipes for seemingly everything. I have the old version of The Joy of Cooking that my mom received as a graduation gift in 1981, but other than that most of my books are of the new/trendy vaierty. I want a book that I will refer to again and again (or cook the recipes enough that I memorize them).
I was considering Mastering the Art of French Cooking by Julia Child and How to Cook Everything by Mark Bittmann. What are your opinions on these two and do you have any other suggestions for which book I should get?
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

29 Comments:
The Better Homes and Gardens Cookbook (http://www.bhg.com/bhg/store/product.jsp?catid=cat120006&prodid=prod590004) is a great place to start. It has instructions on basics like kneading dough and poaching eggs, as well as guides to cheeses and cuts of meats.
Another great starter book in the same format is the Betty Crocker Cookbook (http://www.cookbkjj.com/college/betty_crocker.htm).
Both the BHG and BCC are intended for beginners with instructive pictures of how do things, so you'll become familiar with the basics. The entertaining thing is that they change with each edition based on food trends. I have a couple of each, including a first print BCC from the 50s and it's hysterically funny to read what they did with vegetables back then. Like, "Boil asparagus for 15 - 20 minutes"
yayfood at 11:30PM on 07/31/09
On Food and Cooking, the Science and Lore of the Kitchen... its the greatest food reference book ever, no formal recipes but a wealth of information.
GinaPet at 11:42PM on 07/31/09
OH NO! She's becoming one of us! Should we tell her that it doesn't stop at one cookbook?
Julia Child taught me more from one book than I learned in my first 10 years of cooking, not just about French cooking but also about techniques that could be used with any style of cooking. She's thorough and funny and will gently strong-arm you into doing hard labor. She'll make you proud of yourself.
I usually give Mark Bittmann's book as a bridal shower gift with some kitchen tools. He covers more territory than Julia.
Alton Brown's "I'm Just Here for the Food (Food + Heat = Cooking)" is an excellent reference cookbook. (Get the 2.0 version.) Alton doesn't include tons of recipes, but there's a recipe for every scientific technique he explains. His other book, "Food x Mixing + Heat = Baking," is also good.
Dorie Greenspan's "Baking" is a wonderful book--I've made probably 90% of her recipes and have not had one failure.
I pull out my James Beard books and the all-purpose BH&G cookbooks (I have two red plaid editions, a pink plaid and the white baking book) a lot.
"The Joy of Cooking" is a solid book, and I own it, but it's kind of boring and I don't feel it lives up to its title--I don't feel the joy when I read it or cook from it. It's probably the least used cookbook in my collection.
My mother was the original open-heat-eat cook, while my friends ate wonderful foods like beef stroganoff and ravioli that you could smell a half a block away; I wanted to cook like my friends' moms. So a long, long time ago, when I was about 10 (right after the dinosaurs died), I'd check out cookbooks from the library. By the time I turned 12, I was the family cook. My mother was so proud. . .and very grateful.
After using a library cookbook for two or three weeks, you get a good feel for it. The ones I really, really liked, I'd ask for as birthday or Christmas gifts. If you start now, when you're almost 60 like me, you'll have more than 100 cookbooks you've received as gifts, plus another 50 or so you've bought for yourself, plus all the "Cook's Illustrated" magazines and such; your life partner and your children and grandchildren and neighbors will love your cookies and the way your home smells and the memories of learning to cook with you, and they'll borrow your cookbooks all the time, but jeez, they will complain no end when it comes time to move.
Be warned: One cookbook is not enough.
betteirene at 1:17AM on 08/01/09
The New Best Recipe (the America's Test Kitchen cookbook) is my favorite "encyclopedic" cookbook
palmsey at 1:17AM on 08/01/09
How to Cook Everything by Mark Bittman
fiftycenthotdog at 2:00AM on 08/01/09
@yayfood, the BHG cookbook has all the cookie recipes that my family uses. If you want to find a sweet taste from you childhood it is probably in the BHG cookbook.
I have gotten away from buying new cookbooks for the most part. Lots of googling for recipes. Recently though I did buy Nancy Silverton's La Brea Bakery cookbook. I needed details on the care and feeding of the grape based sourdough starter.
I am also really digging on the versatility of "The Flavor Bible". It is the kind of reference that more fits my style of cooking. Looking more for concepts rather than recipes.
climbhighak at 3:58AM on 08/01/09
I have a suggestion--go you your local library, take them all out, and see what would be most useful to you. Or better yet, use the library, and save shelf space, especially since you're still young and developing as a cook.
HeartofGlass at 5:26AM on 08/01/09
I vote for the All New Good Housekeeping Cookbook - out of print the last I knew, but available on ebay and other sites.
Lots of good information besides recipes, and lots of full color pictures, which I'm a sucker for. I have a lot of cookbooks, but if I had to be reduced to one this is it, and I give it for wedding gifts.
This has the classics in several versions, and new classics in various ethnic cuisines. The food you eat every day is in here, and you would never run out of good food if you cooked only from this book.
But I second Heart's suggestion to check out the library.
lemonfair at 7:58AM on 08/01/09
Everything mentioned above. Plus I really like Cookwise and Bakewise by Shirley Corriher.
annet at 8:46AM on 08/01/09
@betteirene haha its funny because i'm a 16 year-old boy (not that you would have any way of knowing that)
foodieteen at 9:01AM on 08/01/09
and I, too have become the family cook. I have quite a few cookbooks but I'm looking for someting that really has everything
foodieteen at 9:03AM on 08/01/09
I've found both "Everything" and "Joy" to be indispensable. I use "Everything" more for entrees, appetizers and sides than "Joy," which I prefer for baking, breakfast/brunch.
I second the recommendations for Shirley Corriher's Bakewise and Cookwise, as well as for Dorie Greenspan's Baking: From My Home To Yours. Martha Stewart's Baking Handbook & Cookie books are also great.
Another favorite is Craig Claiborne's original New York Times Cookbook (the blue cover) - you might be able to get an old copy on eBay or Amazon. It's loaded with classic recipes and very comprehensive.
MMinNYC at 10:37AM on 08/01/09
James Beard's American Cookery is encyclopedic; some of the recipes are archaic, but it's got lots of good basic recipes. The Martha Stewart Cookbook is good, especially for appetizers.
FoodieSearching at 11:36AM on 08/01/09
I'm with @HeartofGlass: Go check out said cookbooks from a local library and give them a test run before you buy. I renewed Julia Child's The Way to Cook so much I kept it for the better part of a summer. When I was looking for vegetarian cookbooks, I checked out Bittman's How to Cook Everything Vegetarian and renewed as much as possible, which was a sign to me that if I was using it that much, it was worth the money to buy.
Any cookbook I've bought without test driving it from the library or a friend first ended up not getting used - including The Joy of Cooking.
joyyy at 12:52PM on 08/01/09
Oh, and I wouldn't start with Mastering the Art of French Cooking. It would be interesting, but French cooking as Julia wrote about it is fairly unfamiliar these days. You're not likely to go to these recipes "again and again" unless you become a professional.
Rereading what you're looking for, I think the ideal book for you is Alton Brown's "I'm just here for the food," because his approach to cooking is so useful, (and his writing so enjoyable). You'll learn the techniques that you'll use again and again, and that with experience will lessen the need for any recipe at all. All his techniques are illustrated with recipes. He basically organizes the book by how we use heat to cook. It's a great book, just as informative as "good eats" is.
lemonfair at 5:27PM on 08/01/09
Dang it! foodieteen, please forgive me. I can't believe I did that. You know what the first three letters of the word "assume" are? ME!
I am so sorry -- of all people, I should have known better. One of my six sons cooks for 100-150 people at an assisted living facility; another of my sons was a hospital cook for years and does all the cooking and grocery shopping at home -- his wife and daughters always thank me for teaching him to cook, and now he teaches them. Come to think of it, he hasn't returned the last few cookbooks he's borrowed. I should call him and tell him that his mother's such an idiot.
I was at amazon.com looking up Shirley Corriher, whose books I don't own--I'd seen her on "Good Eats" and kept meaning to look her up but never did. Thanks for the gentle nudge, @annet and @MMinNYC.
betteirene at 8:02PM on 08/01/09
@betteirene - no harm done... I just found it funny. I understand that there aren't that many other people my age and gender interested in food and cooking.
I just love cooking so much and try to do it as much as possible and was looking for a very general book in which I can go to when i need either a recipe or a description of a specific food/preparation. I already have 2 Giada books, one from Ina, one from Rachel, plus about twenty others (most of which were originally my mom's) and read Bon Appetit, Gourmet and FN Mag cover-to-cover when they arrive. The magazines can keep me up to date on the trends, but something like Alton's book will really help me when I need either a basic recipe or an explanation.
I think I'm going to see if they have t at a local library. Thanks for the suggestions everyone!
foodieteen at 9:53PM on 08/01/09
@foodieteen-- all of the above suggestions are great. Particularly Heart's suggestion of hitting the library first and then building your collection. At your age it's often hard for grandparents/parents to figure out what to buy for birthday and holiday gifts. By checking them out from the library you can figure out what you might like to put on your wish list.
My faves, How to Cook Everything by Bittman, and if you want recipes plus illustrated techniques try Jacques Pepin's Complete Techniques. Pepin's book shows and guides you through many different basic and more complicated cooking preps.
dhorst at 10:09PM on 08/01/09
Try Julia's The Way to Cook, or Marion Cunningham's Fannie Farmer; I also often reach for CIA's The Professional Chef. They all have good recipes with technique and food facts. I second betteirene's suggestion of Dorie's BAKING, I got it by mistake from a book club and kept it once I saw the recipes; it never fails when I need a killer dessert.
ride&cook at 7:21AM on 08/02/09
I really like Julia's the Way to Cook. It is very instructive and has lots of recipes that are basic and then built upon to be more complicated. So you can learn basics very well.
I bought CIA's professional chef and almost never use it; for one thing the recipes are for 10 portions each and you have to have your calculator nearby for conversion for a family meal.
mrsadm at 8:23AM on 08/02/09
I love Mark Bittman's book. Very inclusive. I also love to bake, so I am really enjoying Baking Illustrated. Good luck!
mollykate678 at 9:50AM on 08/02/09
Don't discount the idea of getting used cookbooks, particularly for the ones you're going to use and maybe get dirty. In that case, a creased book jacket isn't going to make much difference.
I always browse cookbooks at antique and thrift stores, and there are a couple used bookstores nearby that I check out as well. Now and then there are some real gems.
And of course, if you are looking for specific used cookbooks, Amazon has some, and I always check out Alibris.com as well. Prices vary, depending on the booksellers and the condition of the book, but you might be able to get 2, 3, or 4 used cookbooks for what you'd pay for a new copy at a bookstore.
dbcurrie at 1:15PM on 08/02/09
After 42 cookbooks and swearing off ever buying or requesting another one for a gift years ago, I still find myself referring to Joy of Cooking time and time again. I always take it on vacation, just in case I find myself in a place with a kitchen. I love all my cookbooks but Joy of Cooking is indispensible.
P.S. I only bought/received three cookbooks this year.
2fussie at 2:30PM on 08/02/09
I have an old beat up copy of Better Homes and Gardens that I probably open more often than any other. Mostly, though, I'm looking at it for approximate cooking times for different cuts of meat. I like the way the chart is laid out, and it's always fairly close to reality. There are also some cookie recipes that I've made for years from that book.
But I don't know if I would call it my favorite. I've probably cooked more recipes from other individual books.
My favorite tends to change depending on my whims of the moment. Sometimes I want a comprehensive book, and sometimes I want something with a narrow focus, like a particular ethnic cuisine or a particular technique or ingredient.
Sometimes I'll go to one of the standard books (BH&G, Joy, etc.) to see what the basic version of a recipe might look like, and then I go to the ethnic/regional books to see what flourishes might be added. Or, if I think a recipe I found online looks wacky as far as quantities/proportions of ingredients, checking one of the standards tells me whether the 1 cup of butter is a typo or not.
Since you already have Joy of Cooking, browse through How to Cook Everything, and then check out Alton Brown's books as well. And although I don't have it, Cooking by James Peterson also looks like a good choice. If you want something more instructive, On Cooking is a book that's used in some culinary programs, so you get a lot of education and technique along with the recipes. The CIA books offer the same style of instruction, as well.
If you browse through those books, you'll probably find that you're drawn more to one style of book than the others.
dbcurrie at 3:14PM on 08/02/09
I have to second palmsey on The New Best Recipe - it includes recipes for every "basic" dish you can think of (think: eggplant parmesan, beef bourguignon, breakfast dishes, baked goods) with explanations about their choice of ingredients and technique. It's a great guide for someone who's starting out but wants the flexibility of being able to tinker with recipes later on (Bittman is also wonderful for this). So far, their vanilla ice cream, pie crust, and high-roasted chicken have turned out perfectly for me.
GirlFromJetCity at 12:30AM on 08/03/09
I gotta agree with posters who say On Food and Cooking, the Science and Lore of the Kitchen by H. McGee. Read it through at least twice and refer to it often. For big assed books packed with knowledge and recipes, Le Guide Culinaire, A. Escoffier. MA GASTRONOMIE, by Fernand Point. CIA PRO Chef 8th edition., and Larousse Gastronomique. The latter being most used and referred to besides On Food and Cooking.
GO OUT AND GET THEM........DO IT, DO IT NOW!
Pavlov at 10:32AM on 08/03/09
There are three books I go to again and again. My favorite is Escoffier, but I wouldn't recommend it as a first cookbook, or a second, or maybe even fifth. It's not a 'step one, add this; step two add that' sort of book. A fantastic second book is Silver Spoon, which is a large Italian book with mostly easy-to-follow recipies. My choice for best first cookbook is Alma Lach's The Hows and Whys of French Cooking. I think it's worth it for the section on sauces alone.
MarvinDog at 11:32AM on 08/04/09
I really like having Joy around becuase it's just so reliable. Just about everything you might need is in there.
missjess at 3:42PM on 08/08/09
Pssstt... Foodieteen, get or borrow the edition of "How To Cook Everything" that was published in the 1990s. In the back pages is Bittman's list of "Fifty Cookbooks He could Not Live Without." Many of them have been very useful to me and have become great favorites.
The more recent editions of "How To Cook Everything" do not have this list. On Chowhound, someone asked him what other International cookbook he would reccomend, and MB referred him to his own international cookbook. What a modest guy, huh?
Pavlov reccomends "Ma Gastronomie." Ever since reading about F. Point in AJ Liebling's "Between Meals," years ago, I've been looking for this book, bought the new American edition the day it came out, but the recipes are fussy and require many expensive ingredients. His legend will live forever, but writing cookbooks for home chefs was not his strong suit. But judge for yourself; you may find it inspiring. Better chefs than I revere "Ma Gastronomie" so what do I know.
I have "Mastering the Art of French Cooking" in two volumes, and would not part with them, but frankly, I don't use them that much. Maybe 6x a year at most. The French cookbooks that have been more useful to me are Richard Olney's "Simple French Food" and Elizabeth David's "French Provincial Cooking." Neither of them claim to be encyclopedic, and the authors aren't so enthusiastic about desserts, although they do present a few, but you would still learn a lot from these books.
Ortolan at 4:25PM on 08/08/09