I'm going to a Mad Men party and need to bring food. Help!
So, I'm going to a Mad Men cocktail party, which should be pretty cool. I've been asked to bring an hors d' oeuvres. Thing is, the only thing I know that I think was a hit then is rumaki (though I could be totally wrong on this, time-wise) and I really hate rumaki. Any suggestions? The party isn't until the season premier, August 16, so I certainly have time to come up with something, but I have a feeling that left to my own devices, feeling so out of my depth, that it's gonna be something like a skewer with ham, pineapple and a maraschino cherry, which would be so wrong on every possible level.
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

15 Comments:
Here's a start; head on over to the Mad Men Menu and Entertainment Guide over at epicurious.com for their take on a somewhat modernized Mad Men menu.
dhorst at 9:13PM on 07/21/09
Also, Gourmet just did a spread on period cocktails (or rather favorite cocktails through the years) which might be a good resource for party drinks.
gingercookiewithlime at 9:28PM on 07/21/09
cheeseball!
andshewas at 11:00PM on 07/21/09
What about a chip and dip bc of that scene withe Pete? You can sub in whatever dip and "chips" of course
JacquelineS at 11:44PM on 07/21/09
Is the caramelized onion dip at epicurious.com supposed to be a fresh take on the Lipton onion soup California Dip? Gosh, I haven't had that for 20 years. I used to love that stuff with Ruffles.
Okay, so I'm probably the only person on this site who was alive in the 60s, so listen to the voice of experience:
Rule Number One: Garnish everything with canned pimientos.
Rule Number Two: Put a couple of eggshells into the percolator basket when brewing coffee.
Rule Number Three: Don't be afraid to put vegetables in your Jello.
Rule Number Four: If you don't have Tupperware, wrap everything with waxed paper.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Mix a small jar of grape jelly with a bottle of Heinz Chili sauce in a saucepan and heat gently, stirring until well-mixed. Stir in a package of cocktail weiners or some porcupine meatballs. Serve in a fondue pot.
Spread crustless white bread slices with cream cheese, sprinkle with chopped chives and roll up like a jelly roll. Cut in half and wrap each with a halved bacon slice held in place with a toothpick. Bake at 375 degrees on a rack on a cookie sheet with sides until golden brown and crispy.
Make a batch of Bisquick biscuit dough. Take a ball of dough and wrap it around a cocktail weiner or a halved hot dog. Bake at 400 degrees until brown. Serve with bowls of ketchup and mustard for dipping.
Fill celery with cream cheese, or better yet, homemade pimiento cheese spread. Yeah, baby.
Skewer cubes of canned ham (Spam is a very acceptable substitution) with chunks of canned pineapple and green pepper squares. Broil on all sides until golden. Serve with a sauce made of baby food apricots, soy sauce and brown sugar and a splash of white vinegar.
You could do lime Jello with canned pears or lemon Jello with grated carrots, but follow the instructions on the package for Jigglers and cut them into squares.
One of my mom's pinochle friends would contribute cheese globs, I mean cheese puffs--she used Swiss cheese in pate choux (cream puff pastry), which would've been tasty had she baked them long enough.
Two words: Finger sandwiches. Made with Underwood Deviled Ham.
For dessert, someone always brought chocolate oatmeal no-bake cookies, gingersnaps or blonde brownies. Always dry, always made with margarine.
betteirene at 3:36AM on 07/22/09
OMG bette! I am rolling on the floor!
GREAT ideas.
What amazes me is how many are still so popular!
I was not alive in the 60's, but I collect cookbooks from that era and just love the recipes--so many exactly like what you posted.
I worked as a cook in an assisted living and rehab facility and many of those types of foods would be requested, and the ladies would often show off the cookbooks they still had.
May I just say that Underwood deviled ham and cream cheese sandwiches on white bread were common when we were kids, as my mom loved them too.
A couple of my books have these as appetizer ideas:
*Sprinkle some parmesan cheese (the kind in the green can) over Club or saltine crackers. Wrap with a half slice of bacon and bake til the bacon is crisp.
*Bisquick made up into the drop biscuit dough, mixed with crumbled cooked sausage and American or cheddar cheese and baked.
Be sure all your platters have a nice layer of iceberg lettuce on them to garnish, and don't be afraid to toss maraschino cherries on everything sweet.
That party sounds like so much fun!
sadiepix at 4:10AM on 07/22/09
Don't forget Pigs in the Blanket. Still a big favorite.
bessfour at 7:11AM on 07/22/09
What betterirene said--I was there; I ate it all.
BobbieAnne at 8:22AM on 07/22/09
@betterirene I remember it well! at the thought of deviled ham sandwiches I actually threw up a little ewwwwwwwwww. I would definately go with pigs in a blanket too though
huneybumper at 8:52AM on 07/22/09
@ betteirene and bobbieanne - I feel for you! Haha. I'm sure many of those taste better than they sound.
lexophile at 8:52AM on 07/22/09
Thanks for all the nifty ideas. This is all reminding me of something my great aunt used to make.It was sorta like the vienna sausage w/chili sauce and jelly, but different. She used kielbasa, cut into 1 1/2 inch slices. She's mix equal parts chili sauce and grape jelly and leave it in the oven at a really low heat for hours. Then, about half an hour before serving, she'd uncover, up the heat to about 350-400 and cook until the sauce was super sticky and the kielbasa had little browned bits on it. It was really, really good. She's serve it with rice for dinner, but I bet I could just lay them out on a platter with ruffled toothpicks and a bowl of the stick sauce.
Also, I was alive in the early '60's, but my diet then was pretty much baby food.
@bettarine - I checked out the onion dip. I thought it was really interesting that they used masala in it as my newest kick has been using MDH's Raita Masala mixed with sour cream as a dip for chips. It's really good.
chisai at 6:49PM on 07/22/09
A carton of smokes and a bottle of liquor.
winkyj at 2:17AM on 07/23/09
I have cookbooks left from the 50s and 60s. It's interesting that, then, there were so many recipies for jello molds and geletine based salads using, not only fruits, but vegetables (remember perfection salad?). Nowadays, you rarely see recipies for jello molds.
SavtaShayna at 11:46AM on 07/23/09
Finger sandwiches. I've recently been on a finger sandwich kick - I can't explain it. Some weird throwback to my 60's-70's childhood.
Ham, turkey, bologna, chicken salad, egg salad, whatever on white (you can also use rye or pumpernickel) bread with your choice of condiments. Cut the crusts off and cut in four pieces - squares, triangles or long rectangles. The trick is to keep the filling relatively thin. If you make chicken or egg salad make sure everything is chopped up really finely.
Anyway, we had a heat wave last week (and I don't have a/c) so each morning I'd make up a bunch of finger sandwiches and eat them from the fridge over the course of the day.
RegrettableFoodie at 2:21PM on 07/23/09
do the rumaki!
i did: http://bonappetempt.blogspot.com/2009/08/homage-to-mad-men-gourmets-rumaki.html
bettydraper at 5:44AM on 08/16/09