I wouldn't give up eating ___, even if I was allergic
Barring life threatening allergies, of course, what wouldn't you give up?
I ask, because I'm allergic to....something. Several doctors, medications, and tests later, and the doctors agree I have an allergy. But tests show that I'm not allergic to anything they tested for. Not even the things that people are very commonly allergic to. Better yet, the doctors don't agree as to whether it's something I'm touching, breathing, or eating.
It could be anything.
For a frightening few days, I suspected tomatoes as the trigger, but a second try with the same tomato-laden food produced no results.
I don't know if I could completely give up tomatoes. I could cut back, I could space out my tomatoy meals. But I don't think I could give them up completely. Winter isn't so bad, but when summer rolls around, I don't think I could give up fresh garden tomatoes. Chocolate would be easier.
So, are there any foods that you'd refuse to give up, even if you got itchy and blotchy afterwards?
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

30 Comments:
Not an allergy, but I had to cut back on coffee significantly because of GERD. It's probably better to give it up, but I simply can't.
When it was really bad I couldn't eat anything acidic (tomato included), spicy, or greasy foods. I really missed tomatoes and curry. It was a sad, sad time for a food-obsessed person.
I hope you'll be able to find the real allergen (hopefully not your favorite food!!)
hmw0029 at 1:02AM on 03/01/09
I'm pretty sure I would just take a Benadryl and go on.
I am also an avid gardener and I am allergic to Many things. I'm very allergic to rosemary and other herbs. And aromatic flowers like cosmos and salvia.
I can either ITCH and get a rash, or I can take benadryl and the like and go about my happy gardening.
Don't get me wrong, weeding cannot happen without it.
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 1:48AM on 03/01/09
@carol, I wish Benedryl worked. So far, the only thing that has any effect are the types of medications that you can't take long-term.
dbcurrie at 2:08AM on 03/01/09
I would NEVER stop eating cheese. I'd acturally rather itch and itch and swell and swell than not be able to consume cheese of any kind.
PumpkinBear at 2:35AM on 03/01/09
Bread. Wheat. GLUTEN.
One of my best friends discovered a little over a year ago that she has a gluten intolerance, and while she feels a heck of a lot better since she's become gluten, I'm pretty sure I'd starve to death and endure a very, very painful excruciating gluten-free (think of all the things with gluten..BROWNIES. COOKIES. CAKE. BREADDDDDDDD), death. So instead, I'd just cause myself serious tummy issues. Tummy issues, I can handle. Hunger pains, no.
machellebelle at 3:01AM on 03/01/09
I'm allergic to peanuts but didn't give them up for a long time, even after 3 weeks of hives. Now peanuts make me sick to my stomach for a whole day so I finally had to give em up. Thank god they make almond butter but I still crave peanuts!
thegirliscrafty at 3:32AM on 03/01/09
Blue cheese is the one I can't give up and just have to eat in moderation and take a pill. I'm allergic to mold, mildew, grass and tree pollens, so allergies are a year round thing here. Believe me, I love my moldy blue cheese, but I don't like the hives or stinging sensation in my mouth when I've over indulged.
@db~have you tried Zyrtec?
dhorst at 7:49AM on 03/01/09
I had to give up tomatoes almost entirely over the past year, because I developed a serious stomach problem that they aggravate (though interestingly, spicy chili peppers and coffee - one cup a day - don't hurt). I thought it would be really hard, but now I'm just not in the habit of eating them anymore, and when I think about eating them, I think about stomach pain, not their deliciousness.
@machellebelle - Folks with celiac may actually be slowly starving, because the gluten affects your body's ability to absorb nutrients - hence the association with chronic fatigue. The people I know who have it feel so much better after giving up gluten that the benefits outweigh the difficulty of dietary restriction. Though I have to admit, I love bread and bready things, so that would be a really, really hard one for me. (Sweets and quick-breads are actually relatively easy to make tasty and gluten-free. Things like bread, pizza crust, etc. are more difficult. And of course, going out to eat becomes a trial.)
producestories at 8:05AM on 03/01/09
we have a friend that cannot have anything gluten(Y) because of celiac. It makes cooking for him a challange, but something I actually look forward to. we all go camping 2 t 3 times a year plus assorted hunting trips, so being camp bytch, I have to comeup with tasty alternatives. I think its fun but getting to be more of a challange everytime. I'm allergic to dairy, not intolerant but actively allergic, to be able to eat cheese my favorite food in the world, I must consume 3 pills beforehand, well worth it!!!!!! I could give up many things but cheese NO
huneybumper at 8:56AM on 03/01/09
I would give up anything, if it was only one food. Nothing tastes as good as healthy feels, and for me my health is the most important thing. Even if something only makes you itchy and blotchy, it is a sign that you are doing your body damage and things could worsen--allergies can get worse and worse, if you are continually exposed to the substance in too high a dose.
You might want to consider going on an elimination diet, and slowly add things back, or at least cut down on foods high in histimine like dairy, which can exacerbate allergic reactions.
HeartofGlass at 9:09AM on 03/01/09
I have OAS (oral allergy syndrome - It's like hay fever in your mouth) and quite a few foods affect it. Mango, avocado, blue cheeses, the crusts of brie and so on. Mostly I pay it no mind. If it's something that makes me feel really itchy and mouthy hivey I just take a zyrtec an hour or so before eating.
That said, if my allergy went beyond the OAS or if the symptoms got worse, I'd give up whatever I had to give up. I'm pretty lactose intolerant. I can eat yogurts and cheeses and stuff, but regular milk will really affect me so I use lactaid in my cereal. If I couldn't get the lactaid, I wouldn't eat the cereal.
chisai at 10:11AM on 03/01/09
Seafood, salt, oils (particularly olive oil), butter. I like my food flavorful.
My friend was supposed to give up coffee because of ulcers and as far as I know he still drinks 4 cups a day.
ag3208 at 10:19AM on 03/01/09
wheat and dairy, oh how i love thee, and no amount of scolding by my personal trainer about how people shouldn't eat them will change how i feel.
cybercita at 10:42AM on 03/01/09
Chocolate and peanut butter (nuts) would be virtually impossible for me to give up. I might be able to cut back, but give it up permanently? No. Cheese, milk, and wheat would also all be incredibly difficult. I have a good friend who's allergic to strawberries, and I've always thought that would be really hard too....
kimberlymac at 10:48AM on 03/01/09
Dairy products. I'm approaching severely lactose intolerant, and I still, and then cope with the results. Why is cheese so tasty??
Skythe at 11:29AM on 03/01/09
Wheat gives me migraines....but I still eat it... i try and just curb how often i do have it. doesn't always work though.
Alm25 at 11:56AM on 03/01/09
My wife's been told she's allergic to shrimp, crabs and lobster (she can have other seafood/shellfish). Despite this warning, she's notorious for eating shrimp, especially. This results in hives and itching for a week. She's not learned, yet.
shaogo at 12:01PM on 03/01/09
Dairy products would be so hard for me to give up. I can't imagine going without cheese, in particular!
Tomato products would be hard as well. Tomatoes are one of my absolute favorite foods ever. Have been since I was a kid.
Sara
Naturally Recommended
Featuring organic and natural food/product reviews
NaturallyRecommended at 12:19PM on 03/01/09
Chocolate and peanut butter for sure... My dad is allergic to CHICKEN, I would be pretty upset if I developed an allergy to that.
ssultan23 at 12:21PM on 03/01/09
There's no way I could live without coffee or chocolate!!
caramel at 12:51PM on 03/01/09
It has always seemed to me that we crave the things we are allergic to. I am wheat and yeast intolerant just due to aging I think. If I will space out the offending foods and never ever eat them one day after another, I can manage to have a slice of pizza now and then and a cookie three days later. If I go on a binge, which I have been known to do, like today when there is a warm apple caramel cake on the counter, I take a couple of immodium and have a nap. Sometimes I have to go cold turkey for a couple of weeks to get back to near normal.
ocarol at 2:16PM on 03/01/09
I'd be most in trouble if I developed a gluten intolerance. I love bread and pasta, and the gluten free stuff never tastes as good. I'd also be in trouble if I developed a nut allergy. I love peanut butter, and I also love those energy bars that are always made on "machine that handles peanuts and soy products." So I guess I'd be in trouble if I couldn't have soy either.
cycorider at 4:52PM on 03/01/09
Even if it was a possible lethal allergy? Or are we not taking the question seriously? I just mean to say....
lemons at 5:01PM on 03/01/09
Over the past year, I have developed a bad allergy to a certain type of shrimp, or possible a chemical used in freezing them. I break out in hives from head to toe, and my throat gets all scratchy. My allergist has never been able to determine what sets the reaction off or what I should avoid, so I keep an Epi-pen (which I've never needed) and Benadryl with me at all times and eat shrimp with wreckless abandon. It's happened at 2 restaurants and twice at home.
During the allergy testing, my allergist did determine that I am MILDLY allergic to nearly everything, including dairy, peanuts, soy, and wheat. This explained why I have gotten 2 or 3 hives almost daily, but with no other symptons, since I was a kid. I can go on eating whatever I want, so long as my reactions don't get any worse.
nosillak at 5:10PM on 03/01/09
@lemons, in my case (and I'm the one who posed the question), neither of the current doctors is worried about lethal implications. It's not that type of reaction.
And we also tested for all sorts of other things that cause similar symptoms like leukemia and liver disease. All good. Except what the doctors agree is some kind of allergic reaction.
They disagree, however, on whether it's food or something else. One doc suspected a food source, the next doc said that food I'm eating is much less likely than things I'm coming in contact with. Which could be food, considering I'm the one that cooks, but in that case it would be the prep rather than the eating that's at fault. I could live with that. Or it could be something environmental that I have no control over.
At this point, both docs have said that it's unlikely we'll ever figure out what I'm allergic to, and the reactions could very well disappear just like they appeared.
Meanwhile, I was just idly thinking about foods and which ones I'd be willing to suffer (a little bit) for. I could give up coffee or chocolate, I think. Tomatoes or bread would be a lot harder.
dbcurrie at 6:02PM on 03/01/09
shellfish, hands down. could not give it up, even if I broke out in hives every time I consumed it.
I probably couldnt do without cheese either so I hope my body tolerates lactose for a long time to come...
mayoxqueen at 12:23PM on 03/02/09
Benadryl was invented just to protect me from too much shellfish.
Ever since I was a kid, food allergies have come and gone. Have always been lactose intolerant, but can eat cheese. I have some gluten reactions; I'm careful about eating bread and pasta and don't have much of a sweet tooth, so desserts aren't much of a temptation.
Sometimes, a hivey reaction to tomatoes from the garden (doesn't stop me however!) and as I said, shellfish in excess results in huge blotchy hives. Yea for Benadryl
duncan1205 at 1:05PM on 03/02/09
Due to irreparable liver damage, the hepatologist said I could no longer have red meat, white rice, and numerous other foods several years ago. Of course, I still eat red meat and white rice every day...so I'd have to say red meat and white rice.
Cassaendra at 1:40PM on 03/02/09
I love the flavor of hot peppers on sandwiches, don't think I could give them up! I'm worried I'll jinx myself though and soon experience an onset of acid reflux (as it's definitely in the family).
Hillary
Chew on That
Chew on That at 5:47PM on 03/02/09
I would have to say cheese.
pjracz10 at 10:46AM on 03/03/09