It ain't as good as my mama's!
Alright, let's have it!
No matter how many times you make it, what will never be as good as your mom's?
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

47 Comments:
My yeast rolls. Just not the same!!
Laurel E at 9:42AM on 02/02/09
Pancakes. She makes the best ever. I don't even try anymore, I just wait until I go visit to have hers. Sadly, that's only about 4-5 times per year...
kimberlymac at 9:52AM on 02/02/09
Home fries. I just can't get that brown crust like she can.
FoodieSearching at 9:55AM on 02/02/09
Eggs Saratoga - I never get my cream cheese in at the right time like her.
MaresyDotes at 11:07AM on 02/02/09
Not my mom. My Gram. It is impossible for anybody to make biscuits and gravy as well as she did. I don't even bother trying anymore. On the other hand, she'd been making them most mornings for at least 65 straight years by the time I tasted 'em, and she only got more and more practice as time went on.
chisai at 11:31AM on 02/02/09
Oxtail stew, chawanmushi, ashitibichi...other Japanese and Okinawan dishes that I can't think of right now, ranging from consistency to the depth of flavor. She took her recipes to her grave. Oh well...
Cassaendra at 12:00PM on 02/02/09
Dinner rolls. I don't know how she does them, but they are melt-in-your-mouth wonderful. She only makes them for special occasions, like Easter and Christmas. I haven't even attempted them yet.
Pancakes. Here's the worst part: I *know* that she uses a mix. But, there must be something that whole "made with love" aspect of cooking, because no matter what, hers just always taste better.
Chicken and dumplings. Again, I don't what she does, but it's amazing.
Pizza. Okay, on this one she has had some really *bad* experiences, but that was years ago, when I was a kid, and now, WOW! So good.
Traveller at 12:14PM on 02/02/09
I will echo @chisai - not my Mum so much as my Gran. Among other things, she used to bake this scrumptious almond cake with dulce de leche filling... Sadly, I don't have a recipe for it, and no matter how many times I try to recreate it, nothing comes close to hers.
brooke29 at 12:16PM on 02/02/09
Her beef vegetable soup and yeast sticky buns.
lakeloverhh at 12:18PM on 02/02/09
Strudel of any sort
Chicken parikash
Goulash
Eggs
Butter cream frosting
stuffing
Sacher torte
A steak gravy she used to make
Kuchen of all sorts
her cookies
chicken soup
the list is never ending
pjracz10 at 1:05PM on 02/02/09
My dad - I can't get my spaghetti sauce exactly like his.....
My mom isn't a very good cook anymore....can't remember too many really memorable things she cooked when we were young...she is a pretty plain cook.
mepolo at 1:11PM on 02/02/09
I've got most of it recreated, but there was a weird fruit soup she used to make that's still sort of a mystery. Once, when I asked her how she made it, she told me she forgot.
dbcurrie at 1:33PM on 02/02/09
My dad - I can't make pizza dough, or bread, like he does. It turns out perfectly every time.
Junie at 1:36PM on 02/02/09
Banana bread. She had a killer recipe which everyone loved but her memory is going and when I asked her for it she didn't remember where it came from or where it was. Sad )-:
smallblondemom at 1:57PM on 02/02/09
my moms chicken soup, or her mashed potatoes. I have her recipe and it just isn't the same!
mhurst826 at 2:41PM on 02/02/09
Mom- meatballs!
Dad- turkey and bean chili, tuna salad, french toast.
KtMc24 at 3:12PM on 02/02/09
It's my grandma's Swedish Oatmeal Cookies and Swedish Fruit Soup....ooooh so good!!
And my dad's Minnesota Chicken Wild Rice Soup, just the mention of it makes my mouth water!
jmfors at 3:17PM on 02/02/09
My mom was never very domestic, but my nana makes flour tortillas that are the best. I know it comes with decades of practice. Everything else I can replicate, but to get those tortillas so thin and so round, impossible.
blankplate at 3:33PM on 02/02/09
Dad's mashed potatoes, Mum's beef stew, Dad's chili, Mum's sugar cookies.
I even have the recipes (for all but the chili, which requires a pressure cooker), but I just can't duplicate them.
littlestcapy at 3:45PM on 02/02/09
My dad's homemade, 8-hour spaghetti sauce – even though my sister deduced the recipe by watching him (as I could have done, but never did), I'm not confident I'll ever get it right.
My mother's enchiladas – I'm pretty sure she started with canned enchilada sauce; but it was something altogether different by the time she was done.
My mother's chicken curry – she started with Swanson's canned chicken, too, but it was always hot and had mysterious depths of flavor by the time she was done.
@jmfors: did your grandma make the cold cream-and-fruit-purée kind of fruit soup, or the clear-sweet-broth-and-dried-fruit kind? My grandmother made the latter; it's basically a fruit stew with big pearl tapioca and lots of water.
gentlyferal at 3:47PM on 02/02/09
Meatballs and sauce. I politely request it everytime I visit.
savecara at 4:03PM on 02/02/09
stir fry, the lady does wonders, and does all the seasoning by eye. sigh..
machellebelle at 4:06PM on 02/02/09
Pesto. I know, its easy. But it just tastes better when she makes it.
Embackus at 4:31PM on 02/02/09
My mimi is the one whose food will always stand out to me. I wish I could make her meatballs my goodness they were good.
LizSherman at 4:33PM on 02/02/09
My mom was never much of a cook. Growing up we ate a lot of pre-made foods and vegetables were boiled out of a frozen bag. Yeah, it sucked. That being said, my mom has some kind of magic touch when it comes to sandwiches. She and I can both go into the kitchen at the same time and use the same ingredients to make a sandwich, but hers ALWAYS tastes better. It drives me nuts.
PumpkinBear at 4:38PM on 02/02/09
Honestly? Everything.
cochon at 4:58PM on 02/02/09
Anything Indian. Never tastes as good as hers :(
charm city cupcake at 6:39PM on 02/02/09
Her fried potatoes and onions. And her potatoes au gratin.
floridagirl at 7:04PM on 02/02/09
Yeast rolls and fried okra. Like FoodieSearching said, I can never get the crust right.
renee59 at 7:33PM on 02/02/09
This may sound mean, but I didn't realize my Mom wasn't a good cook until I got older. Being a little boy in a single parent household, I idolized my Mom.
It wasn't until I started experimenting in the kitchen did I realize that my Mom's cooking was horrible. So now, as a measuring stick, I make sure that all my dishes taste better than childhood. If they taste the same, I've got some work to do.
Carnal at 9:09PM on 02/02/09
Everything that she doesn't have a written recipe for. Meatloaf especially.
mikaque at 10:04PM on 02/02/09
@gentlyferal - she makes it with a whole lot of water, dried fruit, and then adds a tsp or tbsp of tapicoa and some other ingredients I can't think of at the moment. I've made it a few times now and it's close to what her's tastes like, but there's just something...it's just not the same. :-)
jmfors at 8:58AM on 02/03/09
Everything - Mom and Grandmother (her Mom). They didn't cook a lot from recipes, although my mother devoured cookbooks and watched Julia and Jacques and Pierre and the Galloping Gourmet and the Frugal Gourmet and Lidia and Maryann and other cooking shows from as long as I can remember. Her cookbook collection was divided among her 4 children and we each got a ton of great cookbooks. Lots of them were French. I grew up with amazing food and am known as a great cook, but I can't hold a candle to my blessed mother. She was a true talent and a true gourmet.
PerkyMac at 9:30AM on 02/03/09
@Perkz- I used to watch Graham Kerr on PBS. I guess it was re-runs. Anyways, I was like 6 years old and completely transfixed. My mom used to say how goofy he was. And, if fact, one time when we were at the grocery store, I asked my mom to buy a bench scraper b/c a) I had seen him use it on TV and b) it was his brand.
I still have it. :)
meg3j at 10:05AM on 02/03/09
my dads pancakes are the best...
and my mothers polenta with chicken in tomato sauce... Her roast chicken, potato salad and her rice. Plain, white and sticky, but amazing. i love it cold with leftover salad.
that being said, i'm a much more organized cook than my mother, and like to try new things. She cooks because someone must. Not the same thing.
sweetieBird at 10:19AM on 02/03/09
Mom called them "scrambled" eggs, but they are unlike any scrambled eggs I have had anywhere. She put the eggs in a pots, whisked them very gently, added a bit of salt, butter and milk (or cream) and gently stirred them on low heat - they were soft and creamy and moist - delicious! In the summer she would thinly sliced ripe garden tomatoes to go on top. Nirvana! I am too impatient to make these properly although I have tried so many times.
When I first realized that scrambled eggs to most of my friends consisted of cooking eggs in a frying pan while whisking, I couldn't believe it! When I was about 10, I watched a friend's Mom make them and I had the nerve to tell her she was doing it wrong!
bareneed at 10:28AM on 02/03/09
Stuffed artichokes. I come close...but not quite :(
therealchiffonade at 10:59AM on 02/03/09
Pasta e Fagoli and ravioli. I have made both according to her directions, but they don't taste as good. She said my dough was too thick, once. But that's not the problem.
Barbieri13 at 11:10AM on 02/03/09
Chili - I make mine with good meat, fresh vegetables, and several different kinds of chiles, but it will never top my mom's, made with cheap ground beef, canned beans, and tabasco. Tastes of childhood, and all that.
RBF0412 at 11:30AM on 02/03/09
@bareneed ~ I remember watching Julia Child when someone (I forget who, but possibly Jacques Pepin) taught her the art of scrambling eggs very slowly to make them creamy. As I recall, she buttered the frying pan, whisked the eggs with a little cream, cooked them at least 15 minutes, then stirred in more butter at the end. They still looked very wet. I have cooked them like that, but it's too slow for me and honestly, too creamy. I compromised and cooked them lower and slower than I used to and take them off the heat just before they look cooked. And, a little extra pat of butter never hurts. LOL
PerkyMac at 11:32AM on 02/03/09
@PerkyMac - I grew up on that, so I am used to the creamy consistency - I figured it is probably my Mom's British tradition showing again because I have never seen any Canadian or American make them the same way and what you said about Jacques Pepin, would fit in that it isn't a North American method. After about 10 minutes, I get really impatient and turn up the heat and spoil them - I always say I won't but I can't help it!
bareneed at 12:03PM on 02/03/09
My dad never cooked anything edible (true story: when Mum was away, we'd have spaghetti the first night, with canned sauce, and whatever was leftover would be magically transformed into chili the next.
It was a rude awakening for me when I realised my mother is not the world's best cook. She's good, but I think our old house, with an ancient electric range that took about an hour to heat up, might have killed her game. Everything was cooked on high heat, everything.
And looking back on dishes like Chicken and Rice with Peaches (which was chicken and rice and canned peaches, and nothing else. I mean, not even salt or pepper) I can't believe I grew up to love food.
But there is one thing: bread pudding. The smell of the kitchen when bread pudding was being made (all sweet and cinnamony and lovely) is my mother's true legacy.
NotAmerican at 12:35PM on 02/03/09
My mom swears she only uses salt & pepper most of the time...(boring- I know- but we are originally midwestern- so don't hate.)
I have yet to figure it out how to make her chicken and noodles "the right way" and secretly accused her of using a spice called "magic". I've even enlisted my father to spy on her.
bisbee at 1:02PM on 02/03/09
My mom was a great cook (as all mom's are, I'm sure) and always tried different things which is where my love of food comes from.
What really stood out was her meat sauce with meatballs, braciole, pork & sausage -to die for--some restaurants wanted her recipe, it was that good!
2) her walnut cake with maple walnut frosting-all from scratch as most of her food..
3)a simple oven roasted chicken---which I was never able to duplicate---skin always crispy and meat always juicy and flavorful--
4) bread pudding--just wonderful and comforting
5) breast of veal with a chopped meat and mushroom stuffing
6) tripe in tomato sauce
7) pigs feet in tomato sauce
There's more but those 7 really stand out .......
Mom always encouraged me to try different varieties of foods & ethnic inspired foods because there are so many wonderful things out there.. Ahhh, she was so wise!
Italiancupcake at 1:31PM on 02/03/09
Her meatloaf. And the heartbreaker is that she stopped making it because my dad is ok with the premade loaf from the grocery store deli.
GretchinF at 1:37PM on 02/03/09
Ouch, Gretchin!
meg3j at 1:42PM on 02/03/09
I will never be able to duplicate my mother's pork chop casserole or corn pudding. I always ask how she makes the casserole and she tells me exactly how, but somehow it just doesn't register with me or something. It is soooo good, though.
Likewise on my dad's gravy. I'm coming closer, but it's still not his.
DCraver at 12:06PM on 02/04/09