Is It Just Me, or Does Saffron Taste Terrible?

I have had it three times now where I was aware of it:

1) Once in paella (ruined the paella)
2) Recently in a semifreddo (ruined my dessert)
3) More recently in a pasta sauce with tomatoes and cream (didn't quite ruin dinner, but didn't help it)

Times 1 and 3 I cooked it myself. Time 2 was at a Rather Nice Italian Restaurant, so I assume they knew what they were doing, but good heavens -- the stuff tastes like gasoline in a monkey's butt to me. Not that I would know what that tastes like.

You might ask yourself why I keep cooking with it, but having seen so many recipes that call for (and adore) the stuff, I assumed on times #1 and 2 that I or the pastry chef had done something wrong. But after meal #3, I have come to the conclusion that it may not be me.

And yet, I cannot help but feel that in my years of eating abroad and at home I must have had saffron and not noticed it. I had bouillabaisse for the first time in December and loved it. The paella I ate in Barcelona was fantastic. But I do not know if these things really had saffron in them. Perhaps the chefs omitted them, just as I would if I were making them in my own kitchen today.

So what's the deal? Why do people like gasoline/latex paint flavor in their food? Is it just bad saffron that I (and the upscale restaurant) have/had? Is it a money thing -- people using the spice because they know it's expensive? Enlighten me. Thanks!

Serious Eats Newsletters

Keep up with our latest recipes, tips, techniques and where to eat!


Comments are closed

Talk is closed - check out our Facebook and Twitter accounts instead.