• Share:
  • Send to Reddit
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

Do You Love Onions?

I'm beginning to feel like my great love of onions is a bit ... freakish. Today my mom told me that when I was little I'd take a bite out of an onion as if it were an apple and she and my dad would take it away from me because they thought it was gross or bad for me in some way.

I remember being in elementary school and having one of my favorite foods be a raw onion and mustard sandwich, sometimes with a Kraft Singles slice if we had them.

Now that I'm an adult I literally put garlic and onions in everything, but who doesn't, right? I love the burger joint across from my house because they mix loads of raw, chopped up onions with Thousand Islands dressing and put it over your fries. I eat the onions other people take off their burger. I could eat a bowl of caramelized onions as if it were a meal in and of itself.

My boyfriend, of course, thinks all of this is disgusting. Aside from the bad breath it may give me, he has some weird aversion to raw onions and has successfully managed to convince me that my love of onions is a bit extreme and weird.

So, let's hear it: Am I gross? Are there fellow onion lovers on SE?How much do you love onions?

38 Comments:

you would get along with my Dad so well! he used to eat white onions like a normal person eats an apple or orange.

my Dad's love of raw onions plus my Mom's love of cooked onions means i can cut onion after onion without crying (much), and i put onions in EVERYTHING. Ok, so i don't eat 'em straight or as the star character in a sandwich, but i go through a few pounds every week. but i could totally eat a bowl of carmelized onions as a meal, and i'm pretty sure i've actually done that.

icky breath aside, there is nothing wrong with onion love. and onions are full of vitamins! is your boyfriend full of vitamins? didn't think so. ;)

my husband's gotten used to my nasty onion breath. and i've gotten used to his nasty hot dog and dr. pepper breath.

While I'd never eat a raw onion as if it were an apple, I certainly love onions very much. There is rarely (if at all) a thing that I cook (other than desserts) that doesn't include onions and garlic. My Gran used to tell me that onions make everything better, and they do. Like you, I can eat a bowl of caramelised onions with a slice of freshly baked bread and consider it dinner.

That said, I'm not that crazy about chunks of raw onions (I don't mind them when they're cooked and still slightly crunchy in some applications though). In salads, I mostly use shallots or red onions, and when I do use yellow or Spanish onions in some salads as well (like, smoked whitefish salad), I dice them very finely.

Anyway, as far as I'm concerned, there's absolutely nothing wrong with you!:-)

I adore onions. Your boyfriend is just a guy... What does he know? Ha. Juuuust kiiiidding. No, but seriously... I love onions every way possible. I love a slice of grilled red onion on my burger. I'm talking like... you slice an onion and you have a complete onion circle from the center to the outside, not just an onion ring. Then you grill it. Put it on a medium rare burger. Onion goodness in each juicy bite.

Skip the fries. Go for onion rings. Obviously...

Oh, I also love spring onions. Yum.

This GUY loves onions a lot.They're in almost every savory dish that I cook.Also love a load of paper thin onion slices on some cheap white bread with mayo and S&P.So there.......

Don't listen to him, men aren't too smart when it comes to women. Trust me, I am one and I'm not always so smart.

In Hungary, my cousin makes this kind of savanyusag with onions. You take a whole lot of onions (cut into rings) and you cover them in vinegar... maybe with some water mixed in. Some secret spice blend added into that...

You let it set overnight or whatever. Taste as you go. You want the onions to lose some of their bite texturally and taste wise. Drain the onions. After, you make this dressing with this type of yogurt/sour cream/crème fraîche thing they have there... again with the spices and you let it set for an hour or so in the fridge.

SO GOOD.

You know why God created women don't you? Men couldn't handle it by themselves.

While I don't think I love them with quite your fanaticism PB, I surely do love them! Cooked in every possible way, but I suppose fewer ways raw. I like them on a sandwich with many other things or diced raw in certain things, but overall I prefer them cooked, and I can't say I have ever eaten them alone (just pick up a slice and eat it say, or like an apple)

My dad ate onion and cheese sandwiches on white all the time, and a Brit friend of mine loves his apples n' onions for breakfast every day in the fall and winter.

What kills me is trying to cook for friends who don't like onions, and I seem to have many. I understand maybe not wanting them raw, or needing them in a dice because of texture issues, but not liking the flavor they give other food? Makes me cry!

Yay for onion love!!!

Hey, am I the only one who LOVES it when that oniony smell wafts through the air after the grass gets mown? Everyone I know hates it, but I love that smell! Makes me hungry!

@Meg - your story reminded me of my roasted potato salad. I make it with plenty of sliced red onions and a rosemary-red wine vinegar dressing/vinaigrette (I may also add some kalamata olives and/or real bacon bits, but the basic ingredients are roasted red potatoes, red onions and the vinaigrette).

I make the vinaigrette first, slice the onions and soak them in it, for at least two hours. Overnight is even better (when I have patience). Only then do I roast the potatoes and while they are still hot, I mix them with the onion/vinaigrette mixture. It turns out so good, and the onions are absolutely incredible. I keep meaning to just make a jar of red onions in that vinaigrette.

OK....OK......MAYBE I'm not that smart......and MAYBE men can't handle it themselves (whatever IT is)......but I still love them onions!!!!....lol

I love all onions and anything remotely related to the onion family. I have to have onions in everything. The only way I don't like onions is some of the frozen breaded onion rings you get at the supermarket or some joint that serves such (but that is not the onions fault).

@onepercent- That's the smartest thing you've said all day. ;)

Juuust kiiidding.

YES! Onions RULE!

I love onions, but I have a bad aftertaste that lingers for a looong time after eating raw onions. I like eating raw onions, but regret it every time. Cooked onions are completely fine, though.

It's not just me, because I know of one Caucasian male who has even stronger reaction to raw onions/green onions so he avoids onions altogether, and one Japanese female who also has stronger reaction than myself.


I love onions, but I don't think I'm quite hardcore enough to nosh on them like an apple. I'll eat raw slivers, and I'll put raw onions in sandwiches and salads and whatnot, but a bite out of an onion? Don't think I could handle that. And I love cooked onions in well...whatever you can put them in.

The correct answer to the question, "Would you like raw onion or grilled onion on your burger?" is "Both, please."

As as kid, one of my favorite things was a cream cheese and raw onion on rye bread.

How about pickled onions? Slice red onions and put them into a jar, and cover with fresh lime juice. Stick 'em in the fridge, and the next day they're a magenta-ish pink color and sooooo yummy. Other recipes tell you to blanch the onions first. I've done that as well, and don't see a difference in the result, but it might increase the storage time. You can also add sugar, salt, hot peppers, or spices -- kind of depends on what you're serving them with.

db~i think your on to something.

onions any way shape or form.... when we were kids my mom used to slice up an onion and squeeze fresh lemon juice and a pinch of salt on them. my brother and i would sit and watch tv eating raw onions.
i hear they're very healthy -- keeps the mosquito's away. and good for the blood... or so the old wives say.

I hate onions, so I return dishes with onions and garlic in it...so you won't catch me eating it like a pear.

My husband is not allowed to eat raw onions when I'm around because I detest the way they smell to the point of retching in public. He tries to eat them in burgers when I'm at work, but I can always smell them 6 hours later...in the 5 minutes the burger was transported in the car to be consumed at home.

I wouldn't say your obsession is bizarre, just as my polar opposite hatred of onions and garlic isn't bizarre. We all have our quirks.

I love garlic in an obscene way. I regularly use 6-8 cloves in any pasta, vegetable or risotto dish I make. My boyfriend and I think that amount is perfect--and it is!

I also love COOKED onions. If I eat even the tiniest bit of raw onion, I get the woooorst heartburn for hours. I'm always careful to let them cook down. I do like them quartered and roasted though.

I think I could love garlic and olive oil in an obscene way. I use olive oil the way most people use butter--not on toast, but to drip bread in. We never had butter on the table with bread as a kid...and one of the first times I ate at a friend's house and there was butter, not olive oil, on the table...I was so confused!

I love onions. My 10 year old son loves them even more.
He eats onions (red) like apples.
He loves roasted pearl onions.
When I make pizza, there has to be more onions than cheese on his pizza (he doesn't like cheese, he likes ONIONS).
Burger--an equal amount of sliced raw onion to the patty, please. Yes, at least he says please.
Scalloped potatoes with a sprinkle of onion on top!
Don't even think about an omelet without chives (onion related flavor), and no, I haven't suggested an onion filled omelet; it's just a matter of time before he comes up with it on his own.
Brush well and shower once or twice daily to avoid smelling like a sweaty armpit is advice to him. He thinks I'm funny when I say that.

You're not gross! I love all types of onions and garlic. I like them cooked and raw, and can find a way to work them into almost any dish. Carmelized onions in pasta, sauteed onions in omelettes, scallions in miso and cold peanut noodles, grilled onions by themselves, pearl onions in stew, etc. I love them all...

ONIONS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Oh magical onions. If I have time I will chop up 4 or 5 big ones knowing they will be used soon. Our kids were weaned on onions and love them. Husband would wonder if I had gone mad if no onions were to show up in a meal. We asked a friend who was passing through Valdosta, GA last year to pick us up some Vidalias. He brought 50 pounds!! Onion heaven.

I lurve onions! My soups and pasta sauces are not complete without onions. Nothing is, really. I feel the same way about garlic. When I first got together with my husband he had a serious aversion to onions, claiming that he was allergic. I didn't inform him that I added onions to almost everything I would cook. No hives, no swelling, no anaphylactic shock. Not allergic. Turns out his mom just made him eat them in some awful dish she used to make so he thought he hated them in all things. I fixed that!

Absolutely. On and in nearly everything with a couple of notable exceptions. Never on pizza and I've agreed to try with fish (another thread).

I roast, grill, saute, carmelize, and add to every soup and stew, sauce, you name it. Raw - salads of all kinds, diced on a hot dog, sliced on a burger and liverwurst sandwich. Grated in a deviled egg. I couldn't eat one like an apple.

Onions don't make me cry. I remember that they bothered me when I was a kid making salads and such (I was a sous chef by 5 LOL), but they don't even irritate my eyes anymore. I wonder if it's something you get used to?

I LOVE onions!! I too put onions in just about everything. In my mind properly carmelized onions are one of the simplest, yet most significant culinary wonders. The transormation dishes go through with the addition of carmelized onions is nothing short of amazing. I definitely could eat a bowl of carmelized onions for dinner.

I like onions, but don't always eat them because of the bad taste they leave!

I had a boss once in college who seemed to think she liked onions an awful lot! I was working as this lady's personal assistant. She would always demand I go to the store, buy some onions (about 10) and cut them all up and put them in a tupperware container in her fridge where they would sit there and rot. This cycle would repeat itself varying between purple and white onions. I don't think she ever ate any of them. Even if she did, she was one person living with 2 kids. No way would anyone eat THAT many onions at once!

All this onion chopping lead to the oddest "compliment" I have ever gotten. One day as I was chopping and crying as a result, she came in and stared at my eyes. Then she ran to a mirror and told me to follow her. Then she stated that the whites of my eyes were the whitest she had ever seen and she wished hers were that white. Needless to say, I'm glad I don't work in that job anymore! Maybe I should consider adding "onion chopper" to my resume though. ;-)

Whenever I'm chopping or slicing onions my boyfriend--who usually only enters the kitchen to make cocktails--sneaks in beside me and steals some raw slices off the cutting board to eat. Last night he complained because by the time he snuck back in for seconds I'd already thrown them in a pan with some olive oil and red pepper! (Being the pushover I am I fished a still-nearly raw slice out for him.)

I'm an onion lover too....yes...a dish of onions as my vegetable with dinner isn't out of the question. I'm also like dhorst's son....have to have lots of onions on my pizza....I regularly ask for extra onions.
I rarely get sick either....had a nun in school who used to tell us to eat raw onions if you felt a cold coming on.

@meg3j.....YOU'RE sayin that I'm smart????...WOW....what a compliment!!!!....lol

And it isn't just 'onions', but SWEET onions. I have no use for yellow onions for the most part, but living here in the home region of Walla Walla Sweets made me a true believer of sweet onions over 50 years ago.

I tend to buy local as much as I can, however with onions I will buy whatever sweet is available, even Peruvian if that's all that I can get. Vidalia, Texas Sweet, Mayan, whatever. We tend to buy 3 or 4 pf the 5-pound bags at CostCo every time we go and usually supplement with others in between. In season I get them at the co-op or farmer's markets.

I tend to put sweet onions and garlic in everything except for breakfast cereal, and I don't eat breakfast cereal.

My dad taught me at a young age to love eating chunks or slices of sweet onions just like an apple. If I make a green salad I always put lots of fresh raw onion in it. Omelets, stews, everything. First thing we did with our new crockpot last week was make a couple of quarts of carmelized onions.

I don't get what some folks have said about "bad breath" or "body odors" - that is what you are SUPPOSED to smell like.

Raw onions are great, but there is nothing like caramelized. Cooking them with mushrooms is especially great. The mushrooms soak up all the flavor. Add that to an omelet with cheese. Delicious!

foodbuff, that sounds wonderful! I love both mushrooms and onions!

First, I do love onions. When I was a kid though I wouldn't touch them. Once I started working at a restaurant as a teen is when I got a taste for them. Pumpkin, I'm not sure where you are from but from the sound of your onion love, I feel confident that you would love RAMPS (sort of a wild onion). You need to seek out a ramp feast. It will be ramp season near end of March beginning of April. Ramp feasts are all over West Virginia. I'm sure you would not be dissapointed. Beware of eating them raw. They say eating them raw makes your whole body reek for days.

@onepercent- Eh, I wouldn't take it that far... :)

Onions make me very happy. Thankfully I live in Georgia and have lots of vidalias here to enjoy. I love them any which way...

I'm an onion lover and usually have at least two or three varieties in my kitchen. Right now I have sweets, regular "boiling" onions, scallions and leeks. What annoys me is some supermarkets mark their sweet onions "vidalia," but they're from other places such as Texas, Colorado or Mexico. You'd think the produce manager would know that vidalias come from a specific region in Georgia. I like to eat the sweet varieties raw (besides vidalia, there's walla walla, oso sweet, Texas sweets). And I don't have to worry about onion breath. I live alone and, unfortunately, I don't have anyone to kiss!

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.