Looks Like an East Coast Super Bowl: What Foods Shall We Wager?
With the Pittsburgh Steelers, Baltimore Ravens, Philadelphia Eagles and Arizona Cardinals vying for the SHOW, who wants to put their food where their mouth is??? I'm willing to cough up a Pittsburgh specialty dish to a Ravens fan if they win next week. No kidding...made from scratch specialty. You other two birds (Eagles and Cardinals - LOL!) can do the same thing. If we're lucky enough to make it to the Superbowl, our wager must increase a notch. Who's game?
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

53 Comments:
Looks like a battle of Pennsylvania.
dmcavanagh at 11:45PM on 01/11/09
I won't count out the Ravens yet. They're tough birds :-))
Josdean at 12:01AM on 01/12/09
So funny. I don't really care about football (go cowboys) but I keep up with it because of my boys and Izzy. My son Dash was saying tonight; it's going to be a birds NFC. That was enough to intrigue me.
I like it Josdean. How do we make the exchange? I'm so in/down.
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 12:10AM on 01/12/09
So funny. I don't really care about football (go cowboys) but I keep up with it because of my boys and Izzy. My son Dash was saying tonight; it's going to be an all birds NFC. That was enough to intrigue me.
I like it Josdean. How do we make the exchange? I'm so in/down.
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 12:18AM on 01/12/09
sorry :{
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 12:19AM on 01/12/09
I'm so furious. I wish the Giants could learn to play football correctly TWO YEARS IN A ROW.
therealchiffonade at 7:18AM on 01/12/09
What else could I offer up, other than a cheesesteak? GO EAGLES!!!!!!!
izatryt at 8:12AM on 01/12/09
I say GO EAGLES!!!!!!!! Amen @Izzy!
I really don't have anything that's East Coast (Philly) specific. I buy those types of things: cheesesteak, rolls, pretzels.
I really just wanted to put in a good word for my boys!
Butrflygirly at 9:07AM on 01/12/09
GO STILLERS!
i'd definitly send yinz guys some kielbasa and saurkraut, homemade perogies, couple of capicola primantis "samwidges", and wash it dahn with some iron city's! keep it nice and light :)
Make it a six pack this year!!!
hungrygrl7 at 9:49AM on 01/12/09
Stop it hungrygrl7. I'd take sausage over fake steak any day ~ you might get me to switch my allegiance from Da Iggles. ;-( (clothespin your ears izatryt)
PerkyMac at 10:06AM on 01/12/09
haha as you should!!!
hungrygrl7 at 10:41AM on 01/12/09
I've never been able to care about pro sports of any kind, but being from the Pgh area and having gone to school in the city, I have to default root for the Steelers. So if the Steelers go big (instead of going home), I agree with hungrygtrl7 - you gotta make some Polish food. I want to add cabbage & noodles to her recommendations, along with the fact that you can get pretty close to recreating the Primanti's sandwich if, like me, you're no where near close enough geographically to snag the real deal. Speaking of that, did they open the Florida restaurant ever? I remember hearing about it ages ago, but never anything since.
1 loaf fresh Italian or French bread, sliced thick
tomatoes
fresh made french fries (I bake mine)
provolone cheese
ground sirloin/meat of your choice (or egg!)
amish-style coleslaw (very easy to make)
I believe the order of stacking is: bread, meat, cheese, fries, slaw, tomato, bread.
I made these a while ago and while it's not the same thing, it comes about as close as you can get, because you simply can't get a Primanti's sandwich anywhere else.
joyyy at 11:06AM on 01/12/09
The Pats blew another year....so it's another Superbowl I'm totally not invested in. Have fun with your wager!
juliebugsmama at 11:19AM on 01/12/09
Oh, also, you don't toast the bread or anything. And if you have to put ketchup on everything, like me, IT MUST BE HEINZ ... n'nat.
joyyy at 11:20AM on 01/12/09
@joyy ~ amen
hungrygrl7 at 11:42AM on 01/12/09
I have a lot of friends in Erie, PA and have visted there many times. I have yet to figure out/get used to the fries on the salad and sandwich thing but highly recommend homemade pepperoni balls. Go Steelers!!!
Rottenmom at 11:50AM on 01/12/09
My team is also out so I'm not really invested in the SB this year but, shouldn't you PA folks be wagering scrapple?
geekyguy at 12:50PM on 01/12/09
@geekyguy ~ I'd give away a Philly cheesesteak in a heartbeat, but don't you even glance in the direction of my scrapple if you'd like to keep that eye. 'nuff said? ;-D
PerkyMac at 12:59PM on 01/12/09
Go Eagles. Haven't seen Tastycakes mentioned yet.
donnie at 2:39PM on 01/12/09
STEELERS!
GrabTrees at 2:54PM on 01/12/09
@Perkster ~ I better not see you changing your allegiance over here!
izatryt at 3:02PM on 01/12/09
@carolsfMISSESTEXAS - Depending upon the food, we can make it, chill it and ship it on ice...OR...we can send the ingredients with instructions on how to assemble.
@hungrygrl7 - Wow! You pretty much covered the Pittsburgh specialties. One last thing: Eat'n Park Steeler Smiley Cookies. They're even offering free shipping this week to Baltimore fans. For those not in the know, Eat'n Park is the biggest and best family restaurant chain in Central and W. PA, Ohio and WV. If we lose the Superbowl, I have some influence, and as a penance, I could probably send Smileys decorated for the winning team. It will kill us, but we'd honor our bet.
Josdean at 4:18PM on 01/12/09
@ IZ and Perky - Sit down, relax and watch the pendulum swing back and forth, back and forth. You're getting tired and more tired. Now repeat after me.."I love the Steelers", "I love the Steelers". When I snap my fingers, you will awaken refreshed and a Steelers fan.
Josdean at 4:28PM on 01/12/09
I really don't care, but I promised my support to izzy...so GO EAGLES! Now, somebody needs to explain to me what I'm committing to from a culinary point of view:-)
brooke29 at 4:53PM on 01/12/09
Go Ravens!!!!!! What's our name? I'm not a gambling woman, but I'll take shameless advantage of you bringing it up to wave my Purple and Black!
AliceBlue at 4:53PM on 01/12/09
E-A-G-L-E-S EAGLES............ you can't forget a six of Yuenglings.
dozertx at 5:06PM on 01/12/09
@Josdean ~ Nice try, but you are going to have to actually bring your A game to try and infiltrate this noggin.
izatryt at 5:16PM on 01/12/09
@brooke - good.question. I'm thinking this week, the competition should be Steelers vs Ravens and Eagles vs Cardinals. Soooo..each match-up should have their own culinary competition. I will commit to sending Raven cookies to an SE participant from Baltimore. Anyone serious about swapping with me, let me know. More than one couple can play this game! State your actual donation and another SE person can respond and commit back. For an additional twist, the sender must include the recipe (if possible). We'll expand the game for the actual Superbowl!
Josdean at 5:34PM on 01/12/09
@josdean~ HOW COULD I FORGET THE COOKIES!!! i didnt know they were doing that though...def. have to be black and gold i hope... thats great though. maybe they could send a breakfast smile for the next day :)
hungrygrl7 at 6:13PM on 01/12/09
Well, my team is out of it, but those in PA may be interested to know that the NY Times wrote in "Rendell Is Ready to Bet Against Himself on Super Bowl" that if there is a Pitt-Philly final:
"He said that he would continue the tradition of opposing Super Bowl governors placing a bet on the outcome, and that he would bet against himself. If the Eagles were to win an all-Pennsylvania Super Bowl, a shipment of sandwiches from Primanti Bros. would be donated from Pittsburgh to a senior citizen center and a homeless shelter in Philadelphia. If the Steelers were to win, Philadelphia would send Pat’s cheese steaks to a senior center and a shelter in Pittsburgh."
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/13/sports/football/13rendell.html
Anyway, officially according to the Times, those are the 'foods of those PA' teams. I would assume Baltimore is seafood and Arizona is, I don't know, iced tea ;)
HeartofGlass at 7:00PM on 01/12/09
go pat's.. sorry iz. go eagles.
dearrie at 7:08PM on 01/12/09
dearrie......... Don't make me come up there!
izatryt at 7:13PM on 01/12/09
if it would end up an all PA super bowl i'm afraid we're going to have West PA and East PA added to the United states cause its two different worlds in this state once you cross the middle.... it would be awesome though...
hungrygrl7 at 8:22PM on 01/12/09
Josdean, I LOVE you!! Totally forgot about the Eat'n Park cookies and I ordered the whole black and gold kit to be delivered to my husband (who has not my name, but the Steelers tattooed on his arm) at work!
I will win the best wife prize and he will share the cookies with me - it's a win-win!
And seriously everyone, of course the Steelers are going to win - no question about it!!
floridayaya at 8:56PM on 01/12/09
P.S. even down here in Florida, the Steelers rock - we even have a special Steelers bar to watch the game! And Joyyy, the only thing allowed on the table is Heinz!
floridayaya at 9:01PM on 01/12/09
Steelers fan since 1974. Could be a PA superbowl. Tampa is never going to be the same those Pirates Phillies games always erupt into fighting.
JerzeeTomato at 9:08PM on 01/12/09
Oh, you had me at kielbasa.
We had our honeymoon in Prague, and there are many streetside kiosks that do kielbasa...they hang bunches of sausages above huge flat griddles covered in sauerkraut and butter. When you order a sausage, they cut it in half and chuck in on the kraut, then serve it on a delightful soft-yet-chewy roll. The mustard came from a sort of bag that hung from the ceiling with a nipple on the bottom. I had to be pried away with a crowbar.
NotAmerican at 1:29AM on 01/13/09
i just had to wipe the drool off my desk....
hungrygrl7 at 10:41AM on 01/13/09
@ floridayaya - I forgot about the black and gold gift set! I have transplanted Steeler fans friends in Atlanta. I think I'll send one to them! I'll need to upgrade to the black and gold gift set now for my wager :-)
Josdean at 11:25AM on 01/13/09
@HeartofGlass: Thanks for sharing that NYT article Rendell, Rendell, Rendell. He's got a heart of solid gold! But I think if the Steelers win, he should dress up and parade around Harrisburg in tights, dressed as a pierogi. If the Eagles win, he should dress up and parade about as a Hostess twinkie. Got any better ideas?
Susquehanna at 12:23PM on 01/13/09
What the s#!+? Tastycake, I mean. Rendell should dress like a tastycake. A butterscotch crimpet or something.
Hostess is based in Indiapolis, in case you care.
Nice gaffe, Sucksquehanna . . . .
Susquehanna at 12:33PM on 01/13/09
The Super Bowl will get higher ratings if the Cards and Steelers play.
If the Ravens and Eagles go, we all might as well watch a DVD, or do some yard work. For those stuck in the snow, shovel the sidewalk.
If the Steelers and Eagles play, I may watch, but really, will anyone care outside of the northeast? Not really.
The one thing that can't happen, is the Ravens getting in. I hate the Steelers, being a Raiders fan, but the Ravens are the most boring team in all of football to watch. The "big game" will be ruined if they make it. Don't get me wrong, I love thier fans, as they have always been nice to me when going to games in Baltimore. Love their city as well. Still, their footbal team is sleep inducing. I love a great defense, but teamed up with a "just don't screw it up" offense, and you have nap time.
If the Ravens make it, I know a lot of people who are going to just sigh, and say "please make sure the keg is in a warm spot, so we can all hang out".
Raiders757 at 9:58PM on 01/13/09
I'll throw my hat in and challenge a Steelers fan - I'll send you some homemade Berger cookies if the Ravens lose, but since they won't, what will you send me? (Keep in mind that I'm a vegetarian so meaty things are simply out of the question.)
charm city cupcake at 12:31AM on 01/14/09
HERE WE GO STEELERS, HERE WE GO!
The only thing I have to donate from Pittsburgh to Baltimore is one extra large can of whoop-arse in exchange for a superbowl ring!
Pavlov at 6:39AM on 01/14/09
How about a chipped ham bbq from Isaly's? (I have dreams about these by the way, no chipped ham going on down here in Florida).....http://www.isalys.com/
floridayaya at 6:31AM on 01/15/09
mmm chipped ham bar-b-q ... with ketchup and brown sugar....
hungrygrl7 at 2:12PM on 01/15/09
Here's the recipe - everyone should try one at least once in their life!
http://allrecipes.com/Recipe/Pittsburgh-Chipped-Ham-Barbecues/Detail.aspx
floridayaya at 12:28PM on 01/17/09
Looks like you guys jumped the gun. Wonder if crow is as tasty as the roasted Eagle the Cardinals are serving. Guess you'll have to include some southwest flavors now.
PommeDG at 5:26PM on 01/18/09
HERE WE GOOOOOOOOOOO... YEAH STEELERS!!! load up on the keilbasa and saurkraut!!!
hungrygrl7 at 10:34PM on 01/18/09
GOOOOOO....STEELERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!
TAMPA, HERE WE COME!!!!! BTW, What were Raven folks sending us Steeler folks????
Josdean at 11:32PM on 01/18/09
Well, dang! No Battle of Pennsylvania this year and I was all ready to wager a few pounds of our homemade scrapple on this one too!
lacrenshaw
lacrenshaw at 10:24AM on 01/19/09
Chipped ham bbq is one of the few things we always had that I loved as a kid but haven't cooked (or eaten) since I left home five or six years ago. My mom's recipe was dreadfully easy - ketchup, brown sugar, and a little bit of Coca Cola. Mmm. I pretty much forget about it until someone mentions any sort of ketchup/brown sugar bbq sauce.
I wonder if 'Burgh kids will be lighting shit on fire and rioting again over this year's game like the did when the Steelers took it in '06.
joyyy at 6:35PM on 01/19/09
No shit fires this year, at least not yet. Mostly good-natured drinking and eating 'burg foods. Hope it stays that way!
Josdean at 11:49PM on 01/19/09