• Share:
  • Send to Reddit
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

Anchovy Fillets or Paste? Substitutions OK?

I would like to ask the Serious Eater's crowd if they feel it is acceptable to substitute anchovy fillets with the tubes of anchovy paste? I do understand how important the flavour is, when it is called for and that many times people don't recognize that anchovies are part of what makes a recipe delicious, but still, I have to confess I am not really a fan - and am horrifed of the prospect of actually chomping down on any of the bones. I wonder if using the paste would be a good alternative and if so, what would the ratio be (i.e. one anchovy = 1/2 teaspoon paste?)

24 Comments:

oooh, this is a great question! I've been wanting to try the anchovies-in-tomato-sauce thing, but can't stomach actually opening a can (or jar?) up and looking at them! thanks for asking this!

I love them, but have never seen the paste, although I've looked for it. The anchovies just melt, so bones wouldn't be a concern. In caesar salad dressing, I just put them in the food processor or blender, but I also like a few whole on my salad. If the paste is nothing but anchovies (and probably a little olive oil), I'd add a little to your sauce and taste. You can always add more.

I've used the paste and whole anchovies and can't tell the difference so I keep both on hand....

I'm with PerkyMac, I make a dish with sauted red peppers and spinach, and I add the anchovies with garlic and olive oil and the anchovies basically melt away but add great flavor.

I'm down w/ the paste. I rarely can use a whole can of anchovys and they are a pain to store.

Same here. I have used the paste several times and liked it fine.

Anchovy bones are tiny and soft anyway, and the processing makes them so tender they just melt away, like mentioned above, but the paste works just as well in most recipes I think. I tend to only get the whole ones if I am doing an uncooked dish or know I need the whole jar/can.

I'm with Sadie pix--I'll buy whole ones if they'll be used up. But I keep a tube of anchovy paste on hand for last-minute dishes.

I've used the Amore anchovy paste, and it's pretty great:

http://mybrands.com/Product.aspx?pid=480

I've also used their tomato paste, and I love it. I haven't tried any of the others though.

OK - nobody is answering the question - HOW MUCH PASTE SUBSTITUTES FOR HOW MANY ANCHOVY FILETS? How do you know how much to use to sub in paste in a recipe please?

The suggestion sounds good to me. (1/2 tsp=1 fillet), or perhaps a tad more.

I use the paste because I think buying cans would go to waste when I really only use it for ceasar salad and some italian dishes. I think it makes awesome manicotti puttanesca!

*Perky: I usually find the paste by the canned fish in the supermarket. I live in small town Ohio, so I assume it's widely available now. The tubes are fairly small, come in boxes, and made by the same people who make good Tomato Paste.

*texasdeb, it's called "google" you can use it too.

1/2 tsp. paste = 2 anchovy filets. And here's a site with a recipe for making your own paste: http://www.easy-appetizer-recipes.com/anchovy-paste.html

I almost always use the paste. Few recipes that I use require a full can of anchovies and the tube of paste keeps well in the fridge.

As far as measuring - I just squeeze out enough paste to make something about the length of an anchovy fillet (1.5 - 2.0 in.) and count that as one fillet.

i've used the anchovy paste in i a cesar dressing i used to make all the time. it really added that right 'touch' without having to deal with the slimey cans and leftovers when you only needed a spoon or two. i really have to pull that one out of the closet and try it again. it was such a winner once upon a time. got it from a chef here at a local restaurant. funnny, though he never gave me actual amounts, said it would make 10 gallons if he did. but i figured it out for myself after he gave me the ingrediants. it was an emulsificartion in the blender (back in the late 80's.) I think now i'd whisk it in a bowl by hand. egg, oil, lemon, garlic, anchovey paste, maybe some vinegar, can't remember and salt and pepper. lots of parm cheese on the romaine.

Okay, I'm relatively new here, but I have a comment @bobcatsteph3:

I agree that Google is a useful tool. I wish I'd see more people using a search engine to find the answers they seek.

But I've also read TONS of posts here where people evangelize something like, "Sure, you can look it up on Google, but what's better than a community with which to discuss it?"

So which is it, SE-members? I'm a little confused here. I know there's not going to be any kind of consensus, but I'm still interested in whether you're a community or a search engine or whatever. Cause nobody here seems to know.

@mince ~ First off, welcome to SE. The Google comment have been tossed in here many times. Some of the posters have been part of this community for quite some time and occasionally forget to be patient when they personally find a topic or comment redundant, or feel a poster should complete a Google search before asking a question. We are a COMMUNITY. A kind and supportive group of folks who genuinely believe in the information we share here. Asking a question here, will most likely result in your getting an answer that makes sense to you. Please don't take any comments to heart.

Personally? I would rather ask my questions here, to get an answer from the posters who have experience with a technique, food item or kitchen appliance new to me. Posters who I trust to give me the best advice when I am charting a new course in my kitchen. For example ~ 2009 is the year of the oven for me. I don't bake, never have. I don't know the difference between baking soda or baking powder. I have confidence, my SE pals will take the time to educate this old dog trying to learn new tricks.

In order to get the answer to your question, she probably had to google it. Hence, her request. Finding out whether people like the paste as well as the tin of anchovies is a whole different thing - the kind of question people will respond to and share their experience.

We all do welcome you and hope you find us to be a friendly, helpful group of friends, who also have lots of fun together and share our lives and love of all things food related. ;-D

to all - sorry, guys, but I never thought to "google" information about the paste - I just automatically thought of the SE forum - I am not computer literate and find it difficult to navigate around the internet (I'm learning, though!) - like PerkyMac, I am truly interested in the opinions and suggestions and experiences of the SE readers, so I feel like I am a part of a "community."

I think it also depends on what paste you use. I've seen some that are merely anchovies, olive oil and salt. Then there are others that have butter and cream solids blended in, along with those mystery preservatives. So, I think how much and what brand is definitely something I rather hear from the S.E. community rather than just google. By the way I use the paste in a jar from Flora. It's in the Italian section at Wegmans. Around 1/2 tsp. for 1 anchovy--but I always adjust it to taste.

@bobcatsteph3 ~ thanks for the info. I've been in a grocery store (a very small family operated one in my area) exactly once in the last few years. Friends and family shop for me (I'm disabled) and I was also having food delivered (which was so hit and miss that I couldn't count on anything, and often it arrived the day before it had to be tossed). When I'd give them the list, I tried to stick to the store's perimeter, so it wouldn't be too hard to find things. Anyway, I never did get anchovy paste.

@bareneed ~ you've been around long enough to be family!!! pass the caesar salad?

Has anyone ever used the thai staple nam pla, or fish sauce, when you needed anchovy fillets or paste in a pinch?

Just wanted to say I wasn't implying that all questions should be googled, especially the main question bareneed asked...but I get a bit snarky when someone writes in big capital letters that no one is answering the one part of the question that could easily be found by typing "anchovy paste" in google.

I completely agree that any and all food related questions can be discussed here, I just think some of the general questions can be self-answered in seconds using google, because I am the first to admit, I have a ridiculously bad memory, and don't always remember all parts of questions.

I lose my computer literacy as my illnesses progress, but I don't think that's a very good excuse for what I often find is sometimes laziness. Just my humble little opinion.

And Perky I was pretty sure others were shopping for you, I went through that when I was bedridden the past couple years, you never really get what you ask for, and do you feel rude trying to explain that what you end up with isn't right, because people are doing you a favor, so you don't feel right complaining!?

One thing (OK one of a million things) I wish I could do since I can shop again (albeit with my dad's help!), is shop for others because I know cooking so well, and I think a lot of others who shop/deliver food for others don't, but I'm just not healthy enough to do it. Perhaps other SE's would think about volunteering their time to do this for other foodies who can no longer grocery shop? Just a thought for anyone ever looking to volunteer but don't know where/what to do.

@bobcatsteph3 - it is a bloody great idea, and I know I would definitely be more than happy to do this. Thank you.

@bobcatsteph3~ I agree with brooke29. Great idea, and I'd certainly love to do this for anyone in my area in need. Just for a smile--back many moons ago, my mom asked my dad to pick up some Cool Whip (I know, I know) on his way home from work. He came home, pleased as punch and proud of himself for getting Miracle Whip. Not so great on the apple pie mom had waiting for dessert. My mom never let on that he screwed up. Now, with cell phones, I can send my fourteen year old to the store and once he's there I give him specific directions and descriptions of the one maybe two items I'd like him to get--(usually this involves him asking for a particular dish that I'm happy to make but am out of needed ingredient or two).

I just wanted to say--I got here through a google search for an answer to this question. There seems to be a bit of a disagreement online about how much anchovy paste equals one filet. I was glad to find a forum of people talking about it--so thanks for your question and answers.

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.