"Don't eat dairy when you have a cold"--old wives tale or not?
I know we've done topics about crazy old wives' tales and sickness, like eating a turnip while hopping on one foot during the full moon to cure boils.
But I have kind of a gross question that has been on my mind, as I've been mainlining Sudafed since Sunday (I blame it all on you people, because I clicked on the 'food to eat when you're sick' thread, and then I thought, thank goodness I'm not sick, and woke up like this!).
I've always heard not to eat any dairy products when you have a cold, because it supposedly encourages phlegm production. I've also heard that it's only the fat in dairy products, and fat free dairy products are okay. Also head that both are myths.
I don't eat much dairy but am currently suffering an addiction to fat-free Fage, which I've still been eating.
Just wondering if based on your own experience, or knowledge, if this is true.
Sorry if this is gross and/or has topic overlap (ducks in fear). Blame the Sudafed if you think it's too gnarly to ask?
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

22 Comments:
My son and I are both asthmatics and we are also prone to sinus infections. The specialist has said that there is some correlation between dairy and mucus production. She recommends avoiding milk and milk based products during respiratory flair ups, sinus infections and colds and says instead to pump the clear fluids--specifically water, clear juices and chicken broth to help thin out the mucus/phlegm, which makes it easier for your body to expell. Good luck and feel better soon. We're on some pretty heavy duty meds. Some make us foggy while others wind us right up. Just do what you have to do.
dhorst at 2:15PM on 01/06/09
When I was little, I was only told that I should not eat ice cream when I had a cold. In fact, my Mum would make me drink a hot toddy made of hot milk, a splash of rum (I'm not sure if she always added this part), honey and a bit of butter. It actually wasn't as bad as it sounds:-). And well, I ended up feeling better every time, too:-)
But of course, that's just me. I also have always refused to take pills (even when I was little, mostly because I had trouble swallowing that stuff and when I didn't at once, it was bitter - you have no idea how many pills ended up behind my bed!), so I'm certainly not a good example.
brooke29 at 2:44PM on 01/06/09
If you have a lot of allergies (see: me), you're not supposed to eat dairy because of the phlegm thing. So I don't, though truly I have not noticed a huge difference since I gave it up.
KarynMC at 2:50PM on 01/06/09
I'm not in the mood for anything Dairy when I'm not feeling good..
Markbb at 3:03PM on 01/06/09
I eat very little dairy for that exact same reason - doctor's orders. My children were prone to ear infections from fluid (had tubes several times) and they were on low dairy - Children's Hospital doctor's orders.
PerkyMac at 3:04PM on 01/06/09
I heard you're not supposed to eat dairy when you have a fever, as the milk will curdle in your stomach. Weird.
nightowl at 3:23PM on 01/06/09
Thanks! I had also heard about dairy and allergies before, because supposedly dairy contributes to histamine production (and allergies are relieved by antihistamines, or lowering your histamine production). I've had hives and was told to avoid dairy products for awhile and they cleared up very quickly.
I'll give a dairy-free diet tomorrow a try and see if that improves things--thanks for the good wishes--it's not the plague, just a cold but annoying, as all stuffed noses are!
HeartofGlass at 4:32PM on 01/06/09
I'm with Markbb - dairy isn't that appealing when I'm sick, especially with phlegm-related symptoms.
joyyy at 4:36PM on 01/06/09
No Dairy and drink as much water as possible.
joanpieroni2 at 4:44PM on 01/06/09
@Heart -- ouch, I didn't realise my post got submitted somehow before I finished it, but in any case - dairy or not, I hope you feel better soon!
brooke29 at 4:48PM on 01/06/09
Dairy usually doesn't appeal to me when I'm sick, and seafood never ever appeals when I'm sick.
However, this brings to mind the old-fashioned doctor my mother used to take me to. One time, when I was sick, the only thing that I was willing to eat was cold hot dogs. I don't actually remember this particular craving, but everything else was a few bites and I wasn't interested. But I'd eat the hot dogs. She called the doctor, asked him what to do.
(shaking head) Sorry. Got a song stuck in my head for a second there.
Anyway, she was afraid that I wasn't getting enough nutrition, and was fearing scurvy or rickets or whatever, and he said that while I was sick it was okay to feed me whatever I wanted to eat. A few days of indulging my whims wasn't going to kill me, and if I was craving a particular food, there must be something in it that my body needed at the time. He said that when I felt better, I'd probably start wanting other things.
So, if you feel like eating dairy products, I'd say just eat them. The extra goo production isn't a pleasant thing, but it's your body's way of combating what's wrong with you, so unless this is a severe problem, I'd still opt to go with whatever the craving happens to be.
dbcurrie at 5:01PM on 01/06/09
@nightowl - my mom always said the same thing! i've always wondered if its true or not.
ive never heard of it before, but i dont really WANT to eat dairy foods if i have a cold. soup for me!
listener at 5:01PM on 01/06/09
When I had pneumonia, my doctor said to lay off the dairy since it could possibly worsen it.
SusanP at 5:13PM on 01/06/09
I think it's true that dairy just creates more mucous and therefore worsens your symptoms. I don't think it's "bad for you" - it's just going to make you feel worse. Sometimes it makes no difference though if I consume dairy or not, it's just a bad cold.
Hillary
Chew on That
Chew on That at 5:52PM on 01/06/09
My 2 cents--at drama camp they always told us to lay off dairy for 24 hours before a performance. I am not sure if the leading lights of Broadway do this, but I know I had a lot less throat-clearing when I was off dairy.
My mother used to say "no dairy with a stomach bug" because the dairy gave the bug something to work on. I think this is pretty much lunacy.
annien at 6:18PM on 01/06/09
annien, i always thought the reason to lay off dairy (and eggs) before a big performance was for the jitters and the nausea that comes with it. some things are just not pleasant on the second tasting.
blizcheetah at 7:20PM on 01/06/09
Dairy thickens the mucus you have during a cold therefore not good to consume dairy when you have a lot of congestion.
dmcavanagh at 8:20PM on 01/06/09
GARLIC, GARLIC, GARLIC!!!
pooch at 9:52PM on 01/06/09
@Heartofglass- That is the most funniest one I have heard yet. Now I wonder how that old wives-tale came about? lol Anyways have allergies and I tend to TRY and stay away from dairy (again TRY) because can tell a difference. Now my mother got this one from her grandmother who insists that you where something on your feet (socks, slippers, shoes ect) when in the kitchen because if you don't you get a bladder infection lol.
pjracz10 at 5:19AM on 01/07/09
@annien--when I acted, I was always told to lay off dairy, sugar, and high-fat foods before a performance, to avoid coating the the throat. That also explains @brooke29's comment about ice cream being the worse thing for a cold, given that ice cream would have all three (plus, lowering the body temperature as well).
I'm feeling better today, simply from the passage of time, even though I did have yogurt before I posted here in the morning! Still, it seems like the consensus is that this old wives' tale has some justification!
HeartofGlass at 8:03AM on 01/07/09
I dont know if dairy actually produces mucus, but dairy is hard to digest. I would avoid it, but if its what your craving, and you can handle it, go for it!
huneybumper at 8:38AM on 01/07/09
If it's just a cold, eat what you feel like eating. Fage has so many other nutritional benefits, it might outweigh the drawbacks. Plus, you've already got the phlegm/ mucous.
My best cure for that is some broth or boullion with a clove of fresh chopped garlic, chili paste, and black pepper. It'll cure what ails ya.
Kerosena at 2:20AM on 01/09/09