What's Your New Year's Menu?
It is not just blind curiosity that makes me ask this. It's also that I'm undergoing total brain freeze regarding what I'm to make, and I'm hoping this gets me out of freeze mode. I've been looking at my old favorites and they all seem kinda meh, the same with the cookbooks I've been pouring over. If this doesn't stop my guests are gonna be stuck with some grinders and beer.
Seriously people, I need help. So what are you making?
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

52 Comments:
BBQ Pulled Pork sandwiches- that's concrete. Other than that, a baked brie, some kind of cake with chocolate buttercream frosting... now i'm getting hungry!
mcanna at 3:02PM on 12/28/08
New Year's Eve: Penne alla Vodka Martini (my own recipe--want it?)
New Year's Day: Black-eyed Peas with Kielbasa, comme il faut, a New Orleans tradition for a lucky new year.
Gourmet Guy at 3:56PM on 12/28/08
Eve - party appetizers galore, very late dinner w/beef tenderloin, shrimp, lobster tails ++++. 'twill be amazing.
I'm an overnight guest, and cooking some of NYDay traditional good luck in the new year PA Dutch dinner. Someone else is bringing lentil soup (Italian). I'm doing pork & sauerkraut (and I'm going to try adding kielbasa, as I saw on another thread) to which I add a little apple cider as my secret ingredient. My "most awesome mashed potatoes bake". Haven't shared that recipe yet - haha. Roasted carrots & parsnips, and some kind of edible greenery. Of course, have to have chunky cinnamon-ie applesauce with pork, as well as cranberry apple waldorf. Dessert is being supplied by others.
I need to check out the superstitions of other regions & cultures, because I need to improve my luck. Maybe I should have scrapple for breakfast, and pork roll for lunch, and a hog jowl appetizer before dinner?
PerkyMac at 4:05PM on 12/28/08
Paella. Seafood is very affordable all of a sudden so I got some crab, lobster, shrinp and clams and my new copper Mauviel pan to do it in.
Saffron is sitting around just waiting for the event.
New Years Day we will be having loin of pork.
@Gourmet guy I want the recipe.
The jury is still out on the dessert. Still have a tray of those cookies to go with it. I want to see the weather report.
JerzeeTomato at 4:06PM on 12/28/08
I always make Veal Oscar on New Year's Eve, wild rice and a veggie. Always always.
joanpieroni2 at 4:12PM on 12/28/08
@joan ~ I love, love, love Veal Oscar! Can't remember last time I had it. Jerzee says seafood is affordable, so I have to send out my scouts to score me some crabmeat!
PerkyMac at 4:25PM on 12/28/08
So far, I'm planning to make:
* pork pot stickers
* prawn egg rolls
* bread sticks wrapped in bacon (our own silly NY's tradition)
* a large cheese, fruit & crackers platter
* possibly, something with crab meat
* homemade gravlax with dill and capers
There probably will be more starters, but I haven't given it much thought yet (tomorrow is when I officially am going to think of it).
I was thinking of making a late night sit down dinner of green salad, porterhouse steaks, prawns sauteed in white wine and roasted asparagus, but now that it seems that we may have more people over than I thought AND having been inspired by Jerzee and Perky's descriptions, I'm actually thinking of pork & sauerkraut with mash (plus, I could also use all the luck I can get), and I was thinking of maybe smoking some sausages and throwing them in as well. Speaking of which, @Perky or @Jerzee - do you use pork loin or shoulder for yours? I have both and can't decide which one I'd like to use (although OH is strongly pulling for the shoulder). I can still go with the steak & prawn dinner for the eve, and pork & sauerkraut for the day, we'll see.
For dessert, I'm thinking of making my Gran's Zebra cake with chocolate ganache - haven't made this one in a long time.
brooke29 at 6:04PM on 12/28/08
Wild Turkey
Crown Royal
Spanikopita
PumpkinBear at 6:22PM on 12/28/08
Everyone is scattered on the Eve so I'm making a New Year's Day supper. For apps I'm going to make gravlax, broccoli rabe pesto, and my never fail chicken liver pate. The main will be a brisket probably done with lots of onions and some beer. Cole slaw, creamed kale, and I think some roasted squash. Haven't figured out dessert yet, but there's plenty of time . . .!!!
ride&cook at 6:41PM on 12/28/08
I am making a homemade curry, possibly lamb accompanied by an eggplant curry, some basmati rice and home-baked parathas and poppadoms with tomato chutney. I am really getting into mkin curries at home now as it's easy, so delicious and quite healthy as well.
HappyMuncher at 7:04PM on 12/28/08
Sorry, no good answer here. Chef BF is working, of course, so there isn't even a kiss on my NYE menu :(
Kerosena at 7:26PM on 12/28/08
@joan~ How do you Veal Oscar for more than 4 people? I hate everyone staring at me in the kitchen for last minute adjustments,reductions,etc..
stacemace at 8:13PM on 12/28/08
Mr. Meatloaf has announced he's doing NYE dinner, and won't tell me what - except that he just realized we need more sparkling wine, having gone through four, count 'em, four bottles since Christmas Day. (A little Roederer Estate is right next to the computer, in fact, and I highly recommend it for a reasonably priced bottle, less than $20, something that winery didn't used to offer. Good stuff in the trad French style.)
I'm thinking he's ordering oysters since he saw them in the NY Times. He doesn't cook, he buys, which is a talent in and of itself, of course, So who knows what else? There is a little of the leftover Caribbean black cake, which turned out to be wondrous, so I'll try to keep that back, just in case.
lemons at 8:20PM on 12/28/08
We won't know until we get to the restaurant. ;-D
izatryt at 9:08PM on 12/28/08
For New Year's Eve. This is the chance I have to rid the fridge and freezer of ingredients not used over Christmas:
Deviled eggs with smoked salmon and chives
Crockpot weinies
Wonton Cups, with sausage and pepper jack cheese
various cheese and crackers
Various cookies, cakes, and candies leftover from Christmas.
New Year's Day,
Lamb shanks with rosemary and mint sauce
mushroom polenta
roasted veggies.
lamora at 11:11PM on 12/28/08
@Perky what is this about your mashers oh do tell please? I plan on having leftovers from when I make the turdunken and all the fixings. Then the BF and I will wander down to the neighborhood spot and have complimentary champagne and the hats yadda yadda to toast the new year. I will not wander off too far on amateur night. New Year Day, recover with bloody marys and maybe a brunch somewhere.
pjracz10 at 11:51PM on 12/28/08
Make sure you all eat your blackeyed peas on New Year's Day for good luck!!!
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 11:57PM on 12/28/08
Leftovers from my traditional New Year's Eve meal -- posted the menu on http://www.seriouseats.com/talk/2008/12/one-down-one-to-go-new-years-eveday-menusplans.html
Cassaendra at 7:38AM on 12/29/08
new years eve is homemade pizza, pot stickers, and assorted apps munched while in a precoma state on the couch, then napping till 11:45 and bed at 12:02 New years day is probably rib roast soup although I'm starting to lean toward paella now that Jerzee putme in the mood for it.
huneybumper at 7:43AM on 12/29/08
@Gourmet Guy, yes, I'd love your recipe for penne alla vodka martini. I know it without the martini part, which sounds intriguing.
And @PerkyMac, what's your mashed potatoes bake? I LOVE mashed potatoes and am always looking for more versions of potatoey goodness.
There's a lot of good ideas here. I'm gonna have my menu set up by tomorrow morning so I can order everything I need.
Right now I'm thinking that my lobster tekkamaki (like beef, but lobster is the filling instead of scallions) is a definite, though I'm toying with the idea of mini lobster rolls. Hmmm, maybe both. This will be mostly apps, with maybe one big main thing, and I gotta say, that paella seems like a darned good idea.
chisai at 8:29AM on 12/29/08
We're going to graze our way throughout the evening. Mini bites of many things. Crab stuffed mushrooms, little quiche, asian chicken salad in cucumber cups just to name a few. I'm thinking about trying the bacon bowl thing on mini muffin pans to create a minature version and put what ever comes to mind in them. I'm also thinking about new golden potato skins, or maybe a twice baked version for a little bite of one of my son's favorite things. New Year's day will be a leisurely brunch of eggs and a sandwich bar. Dinner--fend for yourself. I'll be in bed early, tired from all of the holiday cooking that just didn't seem to end with family and friends stopping by here and there.
dhorst at 9:18AM on 12/29/08
At this point we have no plans. It may be a romantic New Year's Eve in a new place with my snuggly bear - or we may get invited to new friends' and celebrate with them.
I'm thinking of brie kisses - a chunk of brie, some chopped walnuts (or maybe use pecans now that we live in GA), brown sugar, cinnamon - all wrapped into a very small pouch of phyllo dough and baked.
There will definitely be Lentil Soup. As there is every New Year's Eve.
Some other nibbly type foods. I usually lean towards small bites on NYE.
I told BF I'd like to get some decent champagne and he said, "I suppose you want Dom Perignon." I said, "Well, yeah, I was thinking of Dom..." to which he responded, "Dom sucks." (No idea why he feels this way.) I'm sure there's something else out there he has tried in the past and liked but how about you guys?
What's your preference for brand of Champagne for NYE?
For NYE 1999/2000 (you know...the one before the new Millenium began...) I had some of this and loved it. Wonder if they ship to GA??
therealchiffonade at 9:49AM on 12/29/08
Roederer, as I spoke of, if he likes the French style of toastiness, and most of it is higher-priced than that. Is he a French-only guy? Is he just being a wiseguy when he disses Dom? I'm wild about Billecart-Saumon if I'm on an expense account. I am generally fond of all kinds of bubblies, from the sparkling shirazes from Australia to prosecco to the Widow to many of the California brands. We had the B-Saumon at our very small wedding, and I found a slightly sweet prosecco for my son's rehearsal dinner, which was full of non-wine-drinkers, and it was a great hit - my DIL's 80-plus granddad, a delightful guy, was so thrilled with it, I sent him home with the last bottle.
lemons at 10:11AM on 12/29/08
This is New Year's eve number 6 for us making the New York Times' Bacon-Wrapped Herbed Meatloaf and garlic mashed potatoes. There will also be some bacon-wrapped dates for appetizers. (there's a theme here)
andshewas at 10:26AM on 12/29/08
Gourmet Guy forgot the cabbage. Mine will be stewed with a bit of tasso and of course the blackeye peas and sausage.
NO_Pam at 10:44AM on 12/29/08
I'm surprised no has mentioned Chineese! We have it every year. I dont think I'm getting the duck this year though. Last year it wasnt that good and way overpiced.
nhfoodie at 10:50AM on 12/29/08
@therealchiff: i prefer veuve cliquot champagne for nye.
my tradition is pork, kielbasa, & sauerkraut simmering in a crockpot with a bottle of dark beer for 12 hours. i serve them with mashed taters and chunky, warm, homemade applesauce.
gastronomeg at 12:04PM on 12/29/08
Gastronomeg - that pork & sauerkraut sounds great. Is there more to the recipe than what you listed? I'd love to see it! My Pennsylvania grandma used to always make pork & sauerkraut on New Year's day, and I'd like to do the same this year.
LadyMarmalade at 2:27PM on 12/29/08
@stacemace, it just would be a matter of getting more ingredients when I make it for hubby and myself we like some the next day so I buy extra veal, it gets pricy but he's worth it! I just flour the veal cutlets, lightly pan fry in a grapeseed oil/butter mixture, place the cooked cutlets in a baking pan (bigger than a 13 x 9) lay some thin steamed asparagus on top, then crabmeat and top with my homemade hollandaise sauce. Then throw under a hot broiler. Wild rice and sauteed zucchini with dill and garlic.
joanpieroni2 at 5:35PM on 12/29/08
We are having the New Year's Eve party at our house. I will be surrounded by non-foodies so it's going to be quite a casual menu tomorrow night.
Starters:
~Deviled Eggs (probably Italian style)
~Warm Spinach and Artichoke Dip (Alton Brown's recipe)
~Chili Nachos
~Hummus (making my own-anyone have any good recipes they would like to share?)
~Bacon Wrapped Stuffed Jalapenos
~Guacamole
~Salsa
Main Courses and Sides:
~Salad with various Salad Dressings
~Garlic Bread
~Baked Ziti
~Homemade Meatballs (will have spaghetti or rolls-if they want a sandwich)
~Alfredo Sauce with Crabmeat
Dessert:
~Dump Cake (BF loves it)
~Brownies
~Various Cookies
Butrflygirly at 10:27AM on 12/30/08
I've finally finalised my menu, and in addition to what I've written upthread, I'll be making:
*Falafel with tahini sauce
*Assorted tempura - (prawns, veg and even sliced cornichons:-))
*Puff pastry bites with smoked sausage, onions and peppers
*Black-eyed pea salad
And I'll be definitely making pork & sauerkraut with mash. Off to make pot stickers and spring rolls!
brooke29 at 10:44AM on 12/30/08
Typical new year's fare:
Just a bunch of apps to pass around:
sweet potato pancakes with sour cream, smoked salmon and whatever additions you may want
Roasted fingerling potatoes with creme fraiche and caviar (or whitefish roe, which is surprisingly good! Depends on what I can find)
Crudites, flatbreads, easy stuff
New Year's morning we have a tradition of eating Chili dogs (with chili from the local detroit coney islands) - it's a hangover cure!
epidemickittykat at 12:02PM on 12/30/08
I'm raiding the cheese shop at Wegmans and having my own cheese tasting.
fatitalianbroad at 1:55PM on 12/30/08
Osso buco with the traditional accompanyment of risotto Milanese. I also got my hands on a bona fide cotechino today. Made with lentils it is the Italian New Year's Day celebratory meal. Veal and a side of pork. Oh joy!
ohmygod at 3:41PM on 12/30/08
Okay, as requested:
Penne alla Vodka Martini,
With Tomatoes, Sausages, Bacon, and Cream
I always thought penne alla vodka needed the buttery, slightly herbal lilt of vermouth, benefiting by the way it works in a nice, velvety martini. This incredibly rich, voluptuous pasta creation loves to be practically covered with vegetable-peeler curls of Parmigiano-Reggiano, so keep that happily in mind. The choice of bacon or pancetta at the outset is completely up to you: Bacon lends a light smoky flavor; pancetta is more, well, Italian: lots of body with nice rich insinuations.
As for the crushed plum tomatoes, try to find a brand that doesn’t pack them in tomato purée—it can make the sauce too thick. If the order of the list of ingredients on the can begins with tomato purée, keep looking. Muir Glen crushed tomatoes are very good, but if you can find real imported San Marzano tomatoes, lunge. And you can always “crush your own’’ right in the can with a trusty fork.
It takes a certain vigilance to stir and reduce the sauce for the last 10 minutes over spittingly high heat, but it’s worth it, believe me. But if you haven’t got a splatter screen, then God bless you.
The pasta-to-sauce ratio would make Marcella Hazan (among many others) wince. Too bad.
1/4 lb. slab bacon, cut into 1/4-inch pieces
or 1/4 lb. pancetta, cut into 1/4-inch pieces
1 large onion, well chopped
1 teaspoon dried red pepper flakes
1 28-oz. can crushed plum tomatoes, with juice included
About 2 lb. sweet Italian sausage, the best you can get; fennel-free, if possible
3/4 cup vodka
1/2 cup French dry vermouth
3 tablespoons tomato paste
1 cup heavy cream
1 lb. good dried penne rigate
Plenty of Parmigiano-Reggiano,
freshly grated and shaved with a vegetable peeler
Oregano, fresh chopped or dried
More dried red pepper flakes, if desired
In a good, deep, heavy-duty sauté pan, cook the bacon/pancetta over moderate heat until most of the fat is rendered. Pour off all but 2 tablespoons (if you wish) and add the onion and red pepper flakes, and cook just until onions are soft and translucent. Add the tomatoes, lower the heat, and simmer for a half-hour, stirring every 5-10 minutes.
Meanwhile, bring 4 quarts of water to the boil in a large saucepan. Prick the sausages with a pin every inch or so and toss them into the water. Bring them to the simmer and let them bubble away for 10 minutes. Drain the sausages and cool them in a colander. And meanwhile, bring a large pot of salted water to a boil for the penne, which will probably need no more than about 10-12 minutes to cook, so don’t add it to the boiling water until the final phase.
Add the vodka, vermouth, and tomato paste to the tomato mixture. Simmer for 15 minutes. Cut the cooled sausages into bite-sized pieces and toss them into the sauce.
Just when you’re ready to add the penne to the boiling water, turn the heat under the sauce to high, add the cream, and, using a splatter screen as needed, and, stirring often, boil the sauce vigorously for 10 minutes, about the amount of time the pasta needs to cook. The sauce will, of course, thicken considerably.
You can blend the cooked penne with the sauce, stirring in the grated Parmigiano-Reggiano, oregano, and optional additional red pepper flakes, and serve that with curled peelings of Parm-Regg, OR:
Heat the broiler. Drain the pasta and, without rinsing, transfer it to a 2 1/2-quart (or larger) gratin. Add the sauce and stir in (to taste) grated Parmigiano-Reggiano, the oregano, and the optional additional red pepper flakes. Run the gratin watchfully under the broiler until the penne poking out of the top of the gratin begin to singe and crisp and the sauce sizzles, 2-4 minutes. Serve under curled peelings of Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Yield: 4 large servings, but it’s great for 2, because the leftovers are particularly succulent.
Gourmet Guy at 5:55PM on 12/30/08
@Gourmet Guy ~ I'm panting for breath. I must give this recipe to a couple of friends who write romance porn for a living (pseudonyms of course). I'm pretty sure they're going to want to collaborate with you. Recipe sounds tongue tingling and soul satisfying, right down to the throbbing tip of my sweet little thrusting pinky. Wow, I'm so flushed. This voluptuous siren loves to be covered in warm, lavender scented sweats. I think I need some air and a cigarette, then I've got to make this! ;-D
PerkyMac at 6:19PM on 12/30/08
New Year's Eve: Dragon's Portoguese chicken wings, beef teriyaki, shrimp toast, pigs in the blanket, liverwurst spread, goat cheese and smoked salmon spread, artichoke heart gratin,teriyaki peanut mix called Tiki mix (from Food and Wine mag) with peanuts, pineapple and bacon, mini crabcakes with remoulade,edamame and for dessert miniature danish and chocolate Pavlova. Featured beverage- Clamato Bloody Marys.
New Year's Day: Chicken thighs sauteed with pancetta and garlic, spaetzle and a green like turnip or mustard greens and the leftovers from the night before.
deefine at 9:23PM on 12/30/08
Since Christmas dinner was Nathans hot dogs and french fries, I might make pasta, sauce and garlic bread. Glass of wine.
I don't have a big family.
paris221966 at 10:38PM on 12/30/08
I always use pork shoulder unless all I can get is a pork roast or loin.
Some fat on it works well if you are finishing in the oven which in this weather I would do.
@chiff I love GA and you should go to Buckhead. When I am visiting Mr. Tomato's family we all go to Buckhead. Whole Foods, Fresh Market, Savor Specialty Foods, Fresh Fare, and Trader Joe's.
What is there not to love?
JerzeeTomato at 9:06AM on 12/31/08
Oh @gourmetguy, that sounds awesome! Not for tonight because I've finally come up with the menu and it's a bit late to change it, but oh my goodness, I'm totally making it.
For those who care, I've finally come to my menu. It's all HDV's. Kalua pig sliders, baby spam musubi (don't knock it till you've tried it. They go like hotcakes until people know what's in them), bacon wrapped butterflied shrimp, the Pioneer Woman Cooks jalapeno thingies, baby ume riceballs, macadamia nut crusted chicken, lobster/beef negamaki, baby li hing popcorn balls. Other than the lobster/beef negamaki and jalapeno thingies, everything else fits into a Hawaiian theme, but the jalapeno's are universally loved and always served at everything I do, and who doesn't like lobster?
For drinks, chi chi's and mai tai's (only diff is vodka v rum), my personal fave of vodka w/guava and passionfruit juice, and then a regular bar setup.
Admittedly, it's not the most lux menu, but I think it will go over really well. They're all one or two bite foods, tidy (sorta), tasty, and a bit out of the ordinary for the bulk of non-islanders I know in NY. I've got loads of music set on the player and I will have this among others playing on an endless loop on the tube.
chisai at 10:45AM on 12/31/08
Sushi, shrimp & cocktail sauce, stuffed mushrooms, elcairs, puff pastry thingies with whipped cream and raspberries on them, crackers and boursin, veggie tray, and I'm debating making melt-in-your-mouth sugar cookies.
Heatherdee at 12:48PM on 12/31/08
I always get together with my cousin his GF and another friend. We all really love to cook so we splurge and each contribute something to the meal. It's become a tradition for me to supply Sea Scallops in some form. This year I am searing them and serving them with a Lime Vodka sauce. If I'm feeling uber-productive I was also going to make some Oyster Rumaki as well. I hope everyone has a very safe and very jubilant New Year's Eve celebration!
Martini Me at 1:16PM on 12/31/08
homemade pizza for NYE...i've been jonesin' for some shrimp, so maybe a pesto shrimp pie? yum.
slograffiti at 1:26PM on 12/31/08
@Gourmet Guy- that recipe sounds awesome, I'm gonna print that out and give it a try this weekend. Thanks!
dmcavanagh at 1:53PM on 12/31/08
@PerkyMac- your making me excited!
dmcavanagh at 2:18PM on 12/31/08
eve - I'm doing dates stuffed with parm, drizzled with olive oil, a carmalized onion and fennel tart, with an herb salad with balsamic dressing. for dessert - champagne and a triple layer chocolate cake with mocha cream.
day - black-eyed pea stew with collards, cornbread, and beer. Cheers!
csbrown at 2:42PM on 12/31/08
This morning I made Nigella Lawson's Asian Spiced Kedgeree. I was going to do something involving duck breast and red potatoes for dinner, but BF has decided he'd rather have pizza and wings. He's paying, so that's fine with me :) I'm getting lobster on my half of the pizza! Tomorrow I'm going to make sausage with lentils and orichette.
Amandarama at 4:45PM on 12/31/08
Thanks Jerz! I used the 5lb boneless shoulder I had, it seemed to be the best choice. It's cooking now and smells absolutely amazing!
brooke29 at 5:40PM on 12/31/08
For a NYE party tonight, I'm making a cheeseball (kitschy, but delicious) and a loaf of homemade braided sourdough (for easy pulling apart).
The cheeseball is the standard sort (1 packet cream cheese, loads of finely grated cheddar, a wedge of blue, furiously stirred together) with some sun-dried tomato pesto and roasted garlic for flavourings.
The bread is a white-flour only (I ran out of ww), version of THE GREATEST BREAD RECIPE IN THE MULTIIVERSE.
rhinny at 5:50PM on 12/31/08
Today, really early dinner of portobello mushroom burger with lots of veggies and oven fries. Tonight (while babysitting): snacky foods. In a little while we'll do some design-your-own mini-pizzas. On mine: turkey sausage, onion, mushrooms, olives, green pepper and cheese. The kids I'm watching will probably stick with pepperoni and cheese.
Happy New Year!
CooksForOne at 9:56PM on 12/31/08
black-eyed peas with ham hock
cabbage with slab bacon (not sure if i'm boiling or sauteing yet)
whole wheat bread (the new baking fetish is bubbling on the counter as we speak).
perhaps some biscuits so there are enough vehicles for the bringing of apple butter to the mouth.
football
pajamas
kitchengeeking at 1:53PM on 01/01/09
Hey guys... thanks for making me feel like poop. I was thinking that I was going all out with a flippin meatloaf. Hope that my family doesn't look at all of your responses. You all are making very yummy sounding food. I may have to kick it up a bit...
floridagirl at 2:10PM on 01/01/09