Lay out your cookie tray for me, see if we need to trade recipes
DB's holiday baking thread got me thinking. I tried this too early before. Let's tell what cookies we will actually be making for our cookie trays and then we can share recipes and ideas that are different from our own. I already want Ande's macaroons and I'm trying to remember who had the rum or bourbon balls.
Snowflake cookies a.k.a. chocolate crinkles
lemon bars
Cookies while you sleep a.k.a. meringue cookies
pumpkin cookies
sugar cookies with frosting
shortbread
lemon shortbread
chocolate covered peanut butter balls
and, these ridiculously cute, somewhat labor intensive Pretzel snowmen. They are giant pretzel sticks, top half covered in white chocolate, mini choco chip eyes and buttons, sugared fruit jelly hats and smiles.
Sometimes pop rock cutouts
Hanukkah Gelt
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

52 Comments:
I am so swamped this season, the only cookies I will be baking are drop cookies. I came up with a new peanut butter oatmeal cookie the other day that was pretty darn tasty, if I do say so myself. The recipe is up on my blog:
http://tinyurl.com/62tlxt
KTempesta at 9:02PM on 12/06/08
For sure there will be:
Crescent cookies aka mexican wedding cookies
Chocolate chip-type cookies using holiday colored chips and M&Ms
Walnut shaped cookies. No idea what these are really called, but I make them in a mold and then use peanut or almond butter or chocolate to glue the two halves of the nuts together to make whole nuts
Spice roll-out cookies
Kolachky or jam thumbprints
Probably:
A vanilla or almond flavored roll-out cookie
Peanut butter cookies
Some kind of oatmeal cookie, maybe with butterscotch or cinnamon chips
Spritz cookies
Linzer cookies
Maybe
fortune cookies
Pinwheels
Dorie Greenspan's World Peace cookies
biscotti
And I usually browse my baking and cookie books and see what else looks interesting. As for exact recipes, that's what happens right before I'm ready to bake. I browse the books and look for the stained and bookmarked pages, and I check my computer for the ones I found online.
Right now it looks like my selections are a little heavy on the nuts, but that's because I tend to like nutty cookies. I'll probably end up adding some that are nutless to even things out.
dbcurrie at 9:37PM on 12/06/08
I usually make a tray for my husband to bring to work--you know, to give the guys a break from donuts :) It always includes:
Pecan tarts
Potato chip cookies
Chocolate chip cookies
And I try to throw in something different each year as well. Last year it was ginger snaps. This year I'm thinking maybe shortbread with my cookie press.
buffy at 12:33AM on 12/07/08
Ok. Yea!
@buffy~What are potato chip cookies?
and I forgot that I got a new cookie press. I've never used one, I'm excited.
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 12:38AM on 12/07/08
I'm making both biscuits (cookies) and tea breads. I'm still undecided regarding biscuits though (I've narrowed it down to 17 possible candidates), but I'm definitely making some kind of biscotti (chocolate hazelnut, most likely), some kind of shortbread and sesame biscuits. I'm considering chocolate & peanut butter cups. And I'm certain about the 3 kinds of tea bread: blueberry, banana/walnut and spiced butternut squash/almond.
brooke29 at 12:48AM on 12/07/08
@brooke~I want your choco hazelnut biscotti recipe please.
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 1:03AM on 12/07/08
I haven't finalized my list but here is how my cookie tray stands at the present:
The definites:
1) For my gluten-free/wheat-free family members:
- flourless chocolate almond cookies
- flourless PB blossoms
- cranberry pistachio meringues
- peppered peanut brittle
2) For the rest of the family:
- more of the above
- rasberry jam bars
- speculaas (Dutch and/or Belgium spice cookies)
- Mexican wedding cookies
One or more of the following:
- oatmeal carmelitas
- cafe latte cookies
- lemon poppyseed cookies
- chai snickerdoodles
- sweet/spicy and/or savory/spicy trail mixes
Esmeralda at 7:48AM on 12/07/08
I'm still narrowing it down. The candidates:
After Dinner Mint Brownies
Chocolate peanut butter fudge
Russian teacakes
mini sticky buns
mini apple tarts
Santa Baby Biscotti
some sort of decorated cookie (gingerbread or sugar)
chocolate chip
oatmeal
Maple Shortbread
I need to keep it simple, so I will probably choose 2 or 3 from the list.
KarynMC at 7:55AM on 12/07/08
Oh, I was also considering peanut butter granola ...
KarynMC at 7:56AM on 12/07/08
Who needs my address to send cookies?
izatryt at 9:46AM on 12/07/08
@Esmerelda--tell me about your chai snickerdoodles.
I'm planning on a much simpler array of cookies to share:
snickerdoodles (traditional ones unless Esmerelda comes through with that chai recipe)
pecan tassies
lemon bars
and a pistachio and dried cranberry cookie (green and red, get it?)
I'd like to make some Linzers...we'll see.
wookie at 10:31AM on 12/07/08
mocha rum balls
60 nilla wafer, finely crushed (about 2 1/2 cups crushed )
1 c powdered sugar
1 c planters pecans, finely chopped
1/2 butter melted
2 T light corn syrup
2 T unsweetened cocoa
1/4 c rum
1 t instant coffee granules
powdered sugar, coconut, nuts, sprinkles, etc. for coating
mix crumbs,powdered sugar and cocoa in large bowl. blend rum and coffee until dissolved. stir intp crumb mixture. let stand 15 minutes.
shape into 1-inch balls, roll in additional powdered sugar or other toppings and store in a airtight container separating layers with wax paper. flavor improves witch standing. makes about 3 dozen.
takes about 1 hour to make....
dearrie at 11:24AM on 12/07/08
i'm doing the bulk of my holiday baking this weekend. I'm making:
Monster Cookies (signature chocolate chunk/oatmeal cookie recipe)
Molasses Spice Cookies with a Dark Rum Glaze
Fleur De Sel Caramels
Biscotti di Prato
Chocolate Wasabi Cookies (an experimental recipe I'm going to work on today)
I wish I had more time, though, because Rum Balls are sounding better and better!
melanzane at 11:56AM on 12/07/08
the rum balls are great. and if anyone steals some. you can tell, their nose gets a little pink.. they make little kids walk into walls also.
dearrie at 12:05PM on 12/07/08
Fruit-nut bars
Gingersnaps
Chocolate-chocolate chip peppermint cookies
mini mince pies
sugar cookies
Those are the regulars demanded by my family
And then I will probably do some looking around for something new and fun
smallblondemom at 12:17PM on 12/07/08
@carol - I'm in bed (still have the stupid fever and can't master much walking round without feeling rather dizzy, so I stay here for now, with my laptop), but once I get to my desktop where I keep the recipes, I'll post it for you.
Forgot to mention - I will also be making at least one batch of mini doughnuts for Hanukkah (with raspberry and dulce de leche fillings).
brooke29 at 12:19PM on 12/07/08
brownies
short bread (both plain and chocolate-dipped)
M&M cookies
pecan bars
coffee toffee (actually candy - not cookies)
sugar cookies
gingerbread men (and stars, trees, etc.) -- with dough left over from the gingerbread houses
cheese straws (savory -- not sweet, but an annual tradition)
papillon at 12:33PM on 12/07/08
@dearrie~thanks for the rumballs! I never would have suspected the coffee.
@brooke~aawww. I'm sorry you're sick. Feel better soon. I believe we discussed hot toddies on another thread...
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 1:58PM on 12/07/08
Izzy's not kidding. She really wants us to send her cookies.
Now she's sad =(
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 2:32PM on 12/07/08
@carol - thanks!
@iz - I'll be happy to send you a nice tin of cookies! Any preferences?
brooke29 at 2:46PM on 12/07/08
i think izzy should heat up her oven and bake us the cookies.
dearrie at 2:51PM on 12/07/08
@wookie - Sorry, but I don't have a formal chai snickerdoodle recipe. I was just going to take a standard snickerdoodle recipe and add a little chai spice to the sugar/cinnamon mix. I had given my family a choice between chai spice or Chinese 5-spice. My family chose the chai. I think I'll make a small batch to try it out. It could totally bomb.
Esmeralda at 3:56PM on 12/07/08
Thanks Brooke! I really hope you feel better soon. Your biscotti sound really yummy! *she says with a hopeful look*
@dearrie ~ Izzy don't bake.
izatryt at 4:12PM on 12/07/08
come on. tis the season
dearrie at 4:20PM on 12/07/08
I use my oven for storage. Where would I put everything?
izatryt at 4:26PM on 12/07/08
It's okay, @Iz, it all evens out. I've got three ovens and I use them all. On average, I've got both you and my MIL's non-oven use covered.
I'll just bake an extra tray or two of cookies, and the baking karma will be balanced.
dbcurrie at 5:13PM on 12/07/08
@iz~What do you need to store if you don't bake? Look at all that space you just freed up!
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 5:26PM on 12/07/08
@melanzane~What are fleur de Sel caramels?
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 5:30PM on 12/07/08
@TEXIE ~ Salted caramels.
izatryt at 5:39PM on 12/07/08
Hmmmm. Is that good? I can't imagine that taste.
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 6:12PM on 12/07/08
@Texas--it's basically a butter cookie with crushed potato chips added. The sweet/salty/crunchy combo is insane. Here's the recipe:
2 sticks butter @ room temp
1 cup granulated sugar
3 cups AP flour (give or take a little, depending on the humidity)
2 tsp vanilla extract
1 1/2 c crushed potato chips (plain, obviously--BBQ or salt & vinegar would be very strange)
1 cup confectioners' sugar
Preheat oven to 350. Cream butter and granulated sugar until fluffy. Add the flour and vanilla and beat on low speed until flour is incorporated (here's where you'll need to play it by ear on the flour. If it's raining or otherwise precipitating, I'll use the full 3 cups, but if the air is drier, 2 1/2 cups is enough). Add the potato chips and beat until the mixture comes together.
Place balls of cookie dough (I do about 2 Tbsp each) on ungreased cookie sheets and bake until lightly browned around the edges but soft in the center, 10-12 minutes. Remove and let cool 1 minute before transferring to wire racks. Then immediately generously sprinkle half the confectioners' sugar over them. Let them cool completely, then sprinkle the rest of the confectioners' sugar before serving.
Melt-in-your-mouth goodness awaits.
buffy at 6:13PM on 12/07/08
@dearrie--what kind of rum do you use? White? Spiced?
buffy at 6:17PM on 12/07/08
captain
dearrie at 6:23PM on 12/07/08
a little bit for the rum balls, a little bit for dearrie, a little bit mooorre for dearrie...
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 6:29PM on 12/07/08
@buffy~Thanks, I copied it and I'm going to try them.
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 6:30PM on 12/07/08
Chai Snickerdoodles sound great. It reminded me of a recipe I saw for Chai Shortbread cookies in Cooking Light mag a few years ago. I meant to try it and forgot all about it.
http://tinyurl.com/56eukc
KTempesta at 6:53PM on 12/07/08
@texas you got it
malibu would be good if you rolled them in coconut
dearrie at 7:16PM on 12/07/08
My cookie tray list:
chewy molasses,
Russian tea balls,
basic chocolate chip,
oatmeal chocolate chip,
lemon frosted crisp gingerbread,
snickerdoodles,
homemade caramels and pecan brittle,
and this years new addition is Sugar Shuttles from Gourmet
After looking at the list, I think I need to add something with fruit so maybe a thumbprint cookie as well.
maggiehc at 9:20PM on 12/07/08
I would like to know more about the Russian tea balls.
@texas & dearrie--my t-totaling grandmother, who's already pretty crazy to begin with, enjoyed a few too many rum balls at a Christmas party last year and got quite tipsy, from what I heard. Wish I could've been there to see it.
buffy at 9:38PM on 12/07/08
@maggiehc~Those sound yummy.Chewy molasses Russian teaballs? explain please. And your lemon frosted gingerbread sounds good.
How hard is it to make caramels? I notice alot of you doing it and I never have. And marshmallows. My boyfriend Alton likes homemade marshmallows.
And why isn't anyone else asking for recipes? This was supposed to be for all of us.
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 9:44PM on 12/07/08
He's MY boyfriend!!
buffy at 9:48PM on 12/07/08
Are we gonna do this? (Little threatening face)
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 10:08PM on 12/07/08
How did I miss this thread? Phooey!
Those Chai snickerdoodles sound good. I have had the Chai shortbread and it was pretty good, but I have not tried making any.
I always make too much. Hard to help myself! Plus everyone wants a favorite...and I am bad at saying no...
Moravian spice cookies
Chewy ginger cookies
Mexican wedding cakes
Kourabedes
Espresso-almond sticks
Baklava
Mammoul
Date swirls
Fig pinwheels
Mission fig bars
Marzipan-filled bars
Raspberry bars
Plain and dark chocolate-dipped, shortbread
Lebkuchen
Lemon raspberry shortbread sandwiches
Peppermint surprise cookies
Chocolate covered cherry cookies
Mixed dried fruit and nut bars
Hopefully that is all, though most this year are single batches so it won't be bad.
I am already making some of the simpler doughs and freezing them in advance. Saves time and space in my tiny kitchen.
@Texas--those potato chip cookies sound fun! I may have to make some, they sound good!
Good thread!
sadiepix at 10:12PM on 12/07/08
Listen ~ Alton is ALL mine until further notice. simon stood me up!!
izatryt at 10:18PM on 12/07/08
Waaaa Waaaa Waaaa. Get lost Cookie.
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 10:53PM on 12/07/08
I have a cream cheese almond cookie dough which is my Go-To recipe every year. It makes a huge amount of dough from simple ingredients and whatever comes out is wherever your imagination takes you. I have from this one recipe made cutout cookies, logs which I dip in chocolate and nuts, bon bon cookies which I dip into melted white choc and Christmas sprinkles, or roll it out and make jam slices. Also, you can add chocolate to part of the dough and make any type of chocolate cookie. I usually have 3 or 4 different variations on my cookie trays. If anyone would like the recipe, let me know. I will be glad to post it.
lamora at 12:19AM on 12/08/08
@lamora - cream cheese and almonds, you certainly got my attention! I would love the recipe, please!
@iz - thanks! And since you're asking so nicely, the first batch of chocolate hazelnut biscotti I make once I'm back on my feet is going to you:-)
brooke29 at 1:35AM on 12/08/08
@KTempesta - I'll have to look up that chai shortbread recipe just in case my test batch of snickerdoodles don't go over well
@sadiepix - your "international" cookie tray sounds divine! Your family and friends are soooo lucky.
@lamora - yes, please post your multi-purpose cream cheese almond dough!
So many good ideas, so little time and energy!
Esmeralda at 8:11AM on 12/08/08
OK I am talking on behalf of my mother here;
Nut bread
stollen
popseed bread
fruitcake
spritz cookies
sugar cookies shaped with holiday cookie cutters
biscotti with both ends dipped in choc.
the horseshoe shaped cookies with powdered sugar on them (forgot name)
rum balls
fudge
Linzertorte cookies
some Austrian jam cookies (forgot name).
I make naomie bars, and peppermint brownies .
pjracz10 at 8:41AM on 12/08/08
Thanks brooke!
izatryt at 8:45AM on 12/08/08
@lamora~I know this is an old post, but if you get back could you pleeeeze post the recipe? I think I'm starting Tuesday. I suddenly realized I'm mailing most of them!
carolrsfMISSESTEXAS at 2:10AM on 12/15/08
Don't you ever sleep?
izatryt at 9:17AM on 12/15/08